Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start our chat so fire away with your questions.
Evan: Is there 1 thing that you’d say led the Steelers to be in the situation they’re in? (the Oakland loss, Bell distraction, etc)
Gerry Dulac: Inability to come up with late-game defensive stops. Think about it: If the Steelers get just one stop -- ONE!! -- against Denver, Oakland, Chargers and New Orleans they win those games. But, it doesn't even need to come down to that. If they get just one stop -- ONE!! -- in any one of those games, they win the division. Just one stop in any of the 4 games. That's all it took. And it didn't happen.
KWJ-MD B&G: What is current roster status of Mason Rudolph? Do you see him with a much larger role next year and unseating Dobbs?
Gerry Dulac: yes. that is the plan
Nolrog: Very frustrated, but have no question. Happy New Year and thanks for keeping us informed.
Read More
Gerry Dulac: You are not alone. Thanx for joining the chat.
Retire21: I love MT and not advocating a change for a guy with no losing seasons in 12. But if you thought you'd lose Munchak to a HC job, and you could "trade" MT for a lot of picks ala Gruden and elevate MM, would you do that?
Gerry Dulac: I never thought of that, to be honest. Probably not
Chas: Firing Tomlin has it risks, just look at the Giants since firing Coughlin, but Tomlin's poor team prep against weaker opponents and his poor handling of game situations does warrant a change and a risk worth taking.
Gerry Dulac: That's a pretty big risk. But the Tampa Bay Bucs did that with Tony Dungy. Even though he was always getting them to the postseason, Dungy was fired because he could never get them past the playoffs and into the Super Bowl.
JuJu Smith-Schuster thanks teammates for MVP honor
Charlotte John: Would you be more supportive of defensive coaching changes with adding a few new pieces or keeping the coaches for consistency but still adding a few new pieces? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: They have one big problem and it's not coaching. They need better players at inside linebacker, players with speed who can cover more ground, especially against the pass. Don't get me wrong, they also need another cornerback, but their biggest weakness is in the middle of the field, not the coaching.
Brad : when will some from PG media step up and ask Tomlin a challenging question? How long does he get a pass for? Does the PG media really not know enough about football to realize he IS the Steelers biggest problem?
Gerry Dulac: I'll tell everyone in the media room.
KWJ-MD B&G: As someone who only ocassionaly visits the Pittsburgh area, but is a dedicated and loyal fan (we journey to training camp every year for instance) do the Steelers have more than their share of distractions and drama?
Gerry Dulac: If they do (and they probably do), it's for two reasons: One, they are a popular winning team that gets a lot of national attention for that reason, so their issues are magnified more so than most if not all teams (with the exception of NE). Two, they have a lot of big-name players on the team and it just so happens that several of them -- Antonio Brown and Le'Veon Bell -- cause a lot of the distraction.
Fineline: NFLcoaches will eventually figure out Baltimore’s unorthodox offense but maybe not in time to help the Steelers. How does Cleveland matchup with them?
Gerry Dulac: Actually, Cleveland matches up very well with them. They have an aggressive defense that can move.
Paul: Who was responsible on the 3rd and 20 conversion? Happy New Year
Gerry Dulac: I'm still not sure if it was Mike Hilton, who looked out of position, or Sean Davis, who typically has the middle of the field. But it was a huge gaffe
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Gerry, If it’s safe to say Munchak is the top offensive assistant, who in your opinion is the Steelers top defensive assistant? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I'm assuming you mean "top" in terms of who you think is the best assistant coach? I will not argue your point about Munchak. But it's not always fair to evaluate coaches in that regard because some coaches have better personnel at their position than others.
KWJ-MD B&G: As we all know this has been a frustrating season and perhaps another opportunity lost with seemingly good talent in place. Will “lessons learned” be applied so whatever the outcome we perform better next year?
Gerry Dulac: You think they would have learned their lesson after last year. How did that work out??
Nick: Jerry, love your chats. Many things went adversly for steelers in 2018. Bell pulled the plug on them. Conner got hurt at the critical time. Defense never showed up. But because of Ben and good receivers they showed a lot of mettle. Shouldn't the steeler nation be proud of them?
Gerry Dulac: I get your point, but, right now, after losing four of their past five games, all in the final seconds, I don't think too many people are feeling pride.
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Gerry, If your taking off season questions..Does Fitzgerald give a home town discount for a role and chance to win a ring? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I don't know about that ....maybe if you offer him membership at Oakmont CC. I will tell you this, every athlete should be like Larry Fitzgerald. They don't come any better.
JoeB: Looking back on the season, perhaps Ben was correct when he said the Steelers should have drafted help for this year rather than a third string QB.
Gerry Dulac: We don't need Ben to tell us that, but, yes, he was correct. I am still dumbfounded they didn't even DRAFT an inside LB, not on any round. And their answer to the biggest weakness on the team was signing Jon Bostic. Just incredibly bad planning for the one area that was costing you advancement into and through the postseason.
WV Joe: We know that Gilbert and Foster are gone for next year. What are your feelings about the replacements and the expected performance of the OL next year?
Gerry Dulac: How do you know that??
Huck: Give Tomlin's poor judgement on throwing out the challenge flag,do you foresee the Steelers assigning the call to another coach?
Gerry Dulac: No, he's the boss
Dave: The Steelers won only 5 playoff games in 8 years. This coach seems to always make bad gut decisions. If this continues, the Steelers brand will diminish. When will the Rooney’s make a chance?
Gerry Dulac: Well, as we have seen since 1969, that is not in their nature.
Jason: If Butler and some others are not let go, then Tomlin needs to find work else where. That D has cost us big time this year. Do you thing changes will be made? Thank you.
Gerry Dulac: I will remind once again that it's not just Keith Butler who is making the defensive calls and decisions. It's the guy above him as well.
Evan: I know it’s not the Rooney way to fire coaches, but do you see any changes coming? This roster has too much talent to miss the playoffs. Someone needs to be accountable for this
Gerry Dulac: I am always amused when people keep talking about how much talent the Steelers have, and how they appear to be wasting it. And I will agree they have talent on offense. But do you really think there is an abundance of talent of defense, any more than any other team?
JoeB: Why is Tomlin so stubborn about having assistance on replay challenges and time management?
Gerry Dulac: C'mon. Just because he's has gotten a challenge right in three years??? Just because he's 0-for-10 since 2016??? Why should he change???
Ben Roethlisberger focused on last game against the Bengals
Brad : How many more years does Tomlin get a free pass from the PG media? Are you guys really afraid to ask the tough questions that NEED to be asked over losing access to locker room or do you guys just not know football well enough to demand answers to the many questions and defencies about Tomlin being a head coach?
Gerry Dulac: I'm guessing we don't know football well enough.
Rod in Indy: Where does this season rank in terms of disappointment of not making playoffs (assuming they don’t) with talent level of.
Gerry Dulac: It's right up there. They did it to themselves with untimely fumbles, lack of defensive stops, missed kicks. The last six games have all been decided on the final play in the final seconds. The Steelers are 2-4 in those games. This team could very easily be 12-2-1. They could also easily be 6-8-1. That's why the disappointment level is at a record high
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Gerry, I can understand the fake punt call.. where was the breakdown on the 3rd and long? Was that suppose to be Hilton or a safety? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: See earlier answer...I'm still not sure. But I will find out.
Jimohiosteelerfan: With the additional cap space due to Bell not reporting, Do you see management maybe going a little out of character and bringing in a free agent CB, LB, or OLB to help out?
Gerry Dulac: They need to do something like that because right now they need ILB help and another corner. What they have isn't working, nor will it.
Joe: When will people stop calling for Tomlins head after every loss. He is a much better coach then most in the league and is capable of doing the job. Players have not executed in tough situations. Fumbles, picks and Swiss cheese defenders at crucial times is why we need the Browns help.
Gerry Dulac: I don't think it will ever stop.
JoeB: I noticed Tomlin took a timeout when the Saints had first and goal inside of two minutes this time instead of letting them run off 45 seconds like the Raiders did. What was the difference in situations (hint: none)?
Gerry Dulac: It was the Saints, not the Raiders
mrbig: it's been several years, there's no denying it. Tomlin can't put together a complete season & it ultimately affects playoff runs. Andy Reid is a great coach but just can't win it all. He may be a top10 coach, but he's not capable anymore. it's obvious he tries more for certain games than others.... why is it not time to let him go??
Gerry Dulac: Andy Reid or Tomlin?
Mick : Hi Gerry. How do you anticipate the Steelers will use their additional free agent money that will be available as a result of Bell leaving?
Gerry Dulac: You would think they would use it for a top-tier ILB or CB. They didn't do that this year, especially at ILB. Do you think they will have learned a lesson???
Rod in Indy: Biggest offseason need, via FA or draft: CB or ILB
Gerry Dulac: See above. But priority No. 1 is ILB. Biggest weakness on this team.
Jack: What chances did you give the Browns of beating the Ravens in your opinion.
Gerry Dulac: A good chance. They've won five of their past six games, in case you haven't noticed, and want to finish this season strong.
Tom in CA: I fully accept when the team lays an egg or gets outplayed...I can handle that. But when one ref singlehandedly keeps us out of the playoffs with BS pass interference calls, that’s hard to stomach. That 4th and 2 was a sound defensive play by a great player and would’ve ended the game.
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man
Mark in North Carolina: Big changes in coaching coming up in the off season? Thinking Butler, Bradley, Olsavsky, Porter and Danny Smith. Only seeing Dunbar hanging around on D. What are your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: Yep. Fire em all. Might as well include the entire offensive staff while you're at it
Paul: With Tomlin unlikely to be going anywhere, what would you say the chances are of of a Porter/Butler finally leaving?
Gerry Dulac: What was that call when Tiger Woods made that long bending putt at the 17th island hole at TPC Stadium Course years ago? "Better than most." At least with one of the two you mentioned.
KWJ-MD B&G: Do you believe that Samuels has provided enough evidence at RB that he and #30 are a sure-thing tandem plan for next year or do the Steelers shop the draft for another talent (not demeanor) like Mr. Bell? As just stated, stud speed and instinct is required at ILB. Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: I think Samuels has shown them that a need for a RB in the early rounds (1 thru 3) is not a necessity
Mark in North Carolina: So what happens with Bell in the offseason. Do the Steelers get anything for him?
Gerry Dulac: I think they will let him become a free agent and just take the third-round compensatory pick in 2020.
Bob: Did the NFL move both the Steelers/ Bengals, and Ravens / Browns to 4pm because of if the Ravens win at 1pm, there would be no reason watch the Steelers / Bengals at 4pm ? No reason to risk injuries to starters etc ? Just a preseason type game ?
Gerry Dulac: I think they wanted to create a made-for-TV situation where the network can keep going back and forth with each game to create drama. That's what TV does.
Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, that's all the time we have. Thanx for all the questions. We will be back next week at our usual time, postseason or no postseason.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.