The Steelers find themselves in a quandary with their kicker.
There is little doubt had Chris Boswell not performed so exceptionally last season when he made the Pro Bowl and signed a five-year contract worth nearly $20 million, he would not be here today.
No coach would stand pat with their kicker missing so many extra points and field goal tries and costing them perhaps three victories. Mike Tomlin never did previously, which is why Boswell was here in the first place, after Josh Scobee failed in 2015. Tomlin also replaced Jeff Reed in the middle of the 2010 season after Reed made just 15 of 22 tries, which was a better percentage than Boswell has this season.
But Tomlin this time is sticking by his man, at least for now. After the season, though, the Steelers will need to make another one on their kicker, one that could cost them another $2 million in March.
Of all the kickers this season who have attempted at least 10 field goals, Boswell’s success rate of 61.1 percent (11 of 18) is the worst. It ranks 41st of all the kickers who have tried a field goal this season. His five PAT misses are most in the league.
He cost them a chance at overtime in Oakland when he slipped and banged low a 40-yard attempt on the last play of the game. Earlier in that game, he missed a 39-yarder wide, and an extra point clanged off the upright and went through.
Read More
Then, with a chance to put the Steelers ahead of New England 17-7 midway through the third quarter last Sunday, he sent a 32-yard attempt wide to the right.
Among the surprises of that game against the Patriots was Tomlin’s decision to send Boswell back out to try a 48-yard field goal with 2:34 left. The Steelers led 14-10 with 2:30 and had a fourth-and-6 at New England’s 30.
The Patriots had no timeouts left, so had the Steelers gone for the first down and made it, it virtually would have wrapped things up. Even if they hadn’t, the Patriots still needed a touchdown from 70 yards away. Had Boswell missed, the Patriots would have gotten the ball at their 38 with 2:30 to go.
As it was, Boswell made his kick, but it still put the Steelers up by just one score at 17-10 with 2:30 left and New England needing a touchdown and PAT to tie — or two-point conversion to win.
But the Steelers held off the Patriots’ charge at the end to win 17-10.
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down the Steelers-Saints matchup
Unlike the previous week, the Steelers brought no kickers in for tryouts this week even though Boswell was just 1-for-2 and missed badly from 32 against the Patriots. Did that 48-yard kick really mean all is well with their kicker? Turns out, those three points didn’t even matter to the outcome of the game.
Sticking with Boswell at this point is somewhat understandable for a few reasons. One, the kicker they liked in that two-man tryout, Kai Forbath, signed with Jacksonville last week. Two, there may be no one else available they do like — although any kicker could come in and miss 32-yard field goals. Three, what Boswell did for them last season and beyond still carries weight.
Boswell made 35-of-38 field goal tries last season, four of them to win games near the end or at the end. He was 21-of-25 in 2016 and 29-of-32 in 2015.
That is an impressive kicking history. Maybe Boswell suddenly came down with Steve Blass disease and he’s never going to find his accuracy again. But what if he does get it back?
It would appear they will stick with Boswell the rest of the way, unless the wheels really go off the track. If he stays, they still will have another decision on their kicker after the season.
As part of the five-year contract he signed this year, Boswell is due a $2 million roster bonus next March, to go with a $1 million salary. If they cut him, his cap charge will be $4.8 million next year, but they also will not be charged the $2 million roster bonus and $1 million salary, although they must pay the kicker who would replace him.
If he’s on the roster by the end of this year, they probably will not cut him to save that $2 million bonus in 2019. But rest assured another kicker will be signed to compete with him in training camp next summer.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.