There are some undeniable trends that are happening in today’s NFL. Lining up in spread personnel and in the shotgun formation in goal-line situations is definitely one of them.
When the Steelers reached a half-yard from the goal line against Jacksonville with eight seconds left on the clock eight days ago, they lined up in the shotgun and called a pass play. Ben Roethlisberger surveyed his options and decided to run in for the winning score. It worked, but barely, as he stretched out to reach the ball across the plane.
When the Steelers reached the 3 at the two-minute warning against Denver Sunday, they ran once and threw twice. Roethlisberger’s 56th passing attempt of the game, again from the shotgun formation, was intercepted in the end zone, and the Steelers lost, 24-17.
The Steelers clearly have a philosophy of passing first and running second in goal-to-go situations. Offensive line coach Mike Munchak shed some light on the trend and the Steelers’ philosophy when asked about it a little more than a year ago.
“I think a lot of people don’t get in [goal-line personnel],” Munchak said. “I think because it’s big-on-big, and it’s not as easy as you think. Everyone wants to prove they can run it in from a yard out, and usually, it is easier to pass it from a yard out. I think you still have people in the goal-line formation and throw the ball more than they run it. The success rate is much higher throwing it than running it.”
Well, after watching the Steelers’ goal-line offense the past two weeks, it might be time to go against the grain, ignore the trends and play some old-school football. It actually might help them become a more complete football team for the playoffs.
Read More
The Steelers have the NFL’s No. 2 red-zone offense, so it’s hard to argue with their overall success rate. The execution the past two weeks, however, screams for some tweaks in personnel and play-calling.
It’s easy to overlook because the Steelers won the game in Jacksonville, but Roethlisberger also threw a red-zone interception against the Jaguars. Jalen Ramsey picked him off when the Steelers had second-and-10 from the 11 midway through the third quarter. He had another interception that was nullified because of a defensive penalty in the final minute when D.J. Hayden grabbed Ryan Switzer’s helmet.
One might say it was an easy call to make because the penalty was so blatant, but it’s also not wise to always count on officials to make the correct call. Officials miss calls all the time.
The poor execution has not just been the past two games. This team’s goal-line passing woes can be traced to a year ago. Roethlisberger’s careless decision and subsequent interception against the Patriots with nine seconds remaining in the game in December is another example. The Steelers had a chance to kick the tying field goal if they failed on third down, but Roethlisberger took a gamble and lost.
If you’re not holding your breath when Roethlisberger drops back to pass when the Steelers are near the goal line, then you just haven’t been watching this team play in recent years.
Offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner has to be cognizant of Roethlisberger’s struggles near the goal line. The statistics certainly aren’t lying to him.
Roethlisberger has completed 53 percent of his red-zone passing attempts with 12 touchdowns and four interceptions. His four interceptions in the red zone are the most of any quarterback in the NFL this season.
His red-zone percentage is well below the league standard, too. Baker Mayfield, C.J. Beathard and Jameis Winston have better red-zone passing percentages.
Roethlisberger’s goal-line (inside the 10) percentage is only marginally better. He is completing 56 percent of those passes with eight touchdowns and two interceptions.
Andrew Luck is the league’s top passer in the red zone and goal-line situations. He is completing 61 percent of his passes in the red zone with 26 touchdowns and one interception. He is completing 67 percent inside the 10 with 15 touchdowns and no interceptions.
That isn’t a gap in goal-line efficiency. It’s a chasm.
This is where play-callers such as Fichtner must distinguish between the rationale of following league trends and analytics and developing a feel for players and their performance in certain areas of the field.
The Steelers are so wildly successful with Roethlisberger otherwise that it’s easy to see why Fichtner doesn’t want to go away from him in the scoring area. Roethlisberger is second in the league in passing yards and eighth in touchdown passes.
But there has to be some room for James Conner and the running game to get involved more. The Steelers own one of the NFL’s most lopsided pass-run ratios in the league. They throw the ball 66.7 percent of the time. Only Atlanta (66.9 percent) throws the ball more. No matter what caliber of offensive line you have, it’s hard to develop confidence and rhythm in the running game when you are passing so much.
Forget the analytics. Forget trends. Football, in its simplest form, is about beating the man in front of you and imposing your will upon your opponent. How did the Broncos score the winning touchdown Sunday? Running back Phillip Lindsay scored from 2 yards and made it in rather easily.
It’s time for the Steelers to rediscover old-school football on occasion. It doesn’t have to be every snap in goal-to-go situations, but they need to develop a running mentality down there. Line up with fullback Roosevelt Nix and play smash-mouth football.
Nix has played just 88 offensive snaps this season, or an average of 11 per game. He’s almost never in the game in goal-line situations.
Other teams, even ones that are cast as finesse offenses, thrive with fullbacks in goal-line situations. The Patriots are probably the best team in the NFL when it comes to situational offensive execution.

New England quarterback Tom Brady can pick apart a defense with the best of them, but the Patriots also run the ball effectively when they need or want to. Their fullback, James Develin, has played 245 offensive snaps, nearly three times as many snaps as Nix. He is a regular part of their goal-line offense.
Nix is good at his job, but he’s a non-factor in the offense most weeks. If lining up with Nix and running doesn’t work at the goal line either, then so be it. But it can’t be any worse than turning the ball over as often as the Steelers have in crucial situations this season.
Roethlisberger and Fichtner, on the whole, are having excellent seasons, but they would do well to clean up their sloppy goal-line execution. They’re going to be in lots more of these situations the next few weeks against quality opponents. And they’ll need to execute much better if they want to win those games.
Ray Fititpaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.