Like any young quarterback coming into the NFL, Mason Rudolph would like to be on the field rather than watching from the sideline. He looks around the league and sees the five quarterbacks drafted ahead of him playing for their respective teams. Four of them are starters, one of whom he will see Sunday at Heinz Field. The other is a change-of-pace option for a division rival.
Rudolph, though, not only doesn’t play, he doesn’t even dress. He has been inactive for every game as the Steelers’ No. 3 quarterback, watching Ben Roethlisberger take all but one of the 401 offensive snaps through six games. If something happened to Roethlisberger, Joshua Dobbs, not Rudolph, would be the backup quarterback to enter the game.
None of this is to suggest Rudolph, a third-round draft choice, is upset. Or even frustrated. He knows he was brought in to sit and watch and learn from a two-time Super Bowl-winning quarterback who is off to one of the most productive seasons of his 15-year career. Deep down, he knows the Steelers did not move up in the third round and use the 76th overall pick to merely draft any backup quarterback, especially when they already had Dobbs and Landry Jones.
Rudolph, a record-setting quarterback at Oklahoma State, was brought in to be the eventual heir apparent when Roethlisberger retires. It is an educational template that worked with Philip Rivers in San Diego, Aaron Rodgers at Green Bay and, most recently, Jared Goff with the Los Angeles Rams and Patrick Mahomes with the Kansas City Chiefs.
They sat and learned for several years under the likes of Drew Brees, Brett Favre and Alex Smith before getting a chance to play. Rodgers, the greatest pure passer of his generation, waited three years before he got his chance to replace Favre.
But that doesn’t mean Rudolph, the sixth quarterback selected in the 2018 draft, wouldn’t rather be playing.
Read More
“Yeah I would,” he said. “I’m a competitor, so that’s the way I feel.”
Five quarterbacks were taken in the first round of the draft, four in the top 10 picks. The No. 1 overall selection, Baker Mayfield, will make his fifth start for the Cleveland Browns at 1 p.m. Sunday at Heinz Field. The others — Sam Darnold of the New York Jets (third overall), Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills (seventh overall) and Josh Rosen of the Arizona Cardinals (10th overall) — have each started at least four games. Darnold is the only one to start every game.
The other first-round quarterback, Lamar Jackson, taken with the 32nd overall pick, is sitting behind Joe Flacco with the Baltimore Ravens. However, he has appeared in every game, often used in specialty and Wildcat packages to take advantage of his electric athletic ability.
No other quarterback was taken after Jackson until the Steelers moved up three spots in the third round to take Rudolph. The Steelers were going to draft Rudolph in the second round until they traded receiver Martavis Bryant to the Oakland Raiders on draft day, necessitating a need for a wide receiver. So they drafted Rudolph’s college teammate, James Washington, in the second round, and still got their quarterback-in-waiting 16 picks later.
Now, he sits and learns and waits. Sunday, he will watch Mayfield — who was supposed to sit and learn and wait behind Tyrod Taylor this season — try for his second 300-yard passing game and third victory. But Rudolph understands why, especially when he considers the voluminous amount of information he has had to absorb, and will continue to digest.
“It’s taking advantage of the situation I’m in now,” Rudolph said. “I really do learn so much each day — signals, protection adjustment, new run schemes, route adjustments, new code words. It’s never ending. It’s new information. I’m encouraged with my development. I’m looking forward to every single day and just try to maximize every single rep I do get. It’s a good situation.”
Growing pains
When the Browns drafted Mayfield with the first overall pick, they almost immediately indicated he would spend his rookie season understudying behind Taylor, a two-time Pro Bowler who was acquired in a trade from the Buffalo Bills.
But that all changed in Week 3 when Taylor sustained a concussion in the second quarter against the New York Jets. Mayfield brought the Browns back from a 14-0 deficit to win their first game in 635 days, throwing for 201 yards with no interceptions and outdueling his contemporary, Darnold.
The following week, Mayfield made his first NFL start and threw for 295 yards and two touchdowns and the Browns scored 42 points in an overtime loss in Oakland. He followed that by throwing for 342 yards and a touchdown in an overtime victory against the Ravens. All of the sudden, the city of Cleveland had someone to help them forget LeBron James.
Who needs a learning period, right?
“I think a lot of NFL football right now has moved towards spreading the field out a little bit, maybe a little less of the old school, two-back football,” said Steelers offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner. “And so, therefore, you’re going to see guys who play the college game at this level, and that may be part of the transition. But they, by no means, ever see the structures and the different defenses that you get at this level. It’s above the neck is where they get you.”
Maybe that’s why Mayfield has been sacked five times in each of the past three games. Or why his completion percentage of 57.3 — his three-year career percentage at Oklahoma was 69.8 — is the fourth lowest among quarterbacks with at least 100 attempts. The only three lower are the other rookie quarterbacks – Darnold (56.1), Rosen (55.0) and Allen (54.0).
Learning on the fly might be preferable to all rookies, even Rudolph. But it might not always be the best plan for NFL teams, even though there have been more than a few exceptions.
“Baker has continued to improve,” said Browns offensive coordinator Todd Haley, the former Steelers coordinator. “It’s a growing maturation process at this level. Everything is different — the looks are more complicated with each and every week. When we go in the meeting rooms to watch tape, there’s enough times where you see the light bulb go off to be encouraged that he’s growing.”
Instant contributors
What would have happened if Tommy Maddox didn’t get hurt in the second game of the 2004 season? Or his backup, Charlie Batch, hadn’t had offseason knee surgery and been on injured reserve? What would have happened if Bill Cowher elected to start Brian St. Pierre in Week 3 in Miami and not his No. 1 draft pick, Ben Roethlisberger?
The question was posed to Roethlisberger.
“I don’t know,” he said. “I guess I never thought about it.”
Like Rudolph, Roethlisberger was not supposed to play in 2004, at least not right away, even though he was the 11th overall pick in the draft. Of the three marquee quarterbacks in the draft — Eli Manning was taken first overall and Rivers fourth — Roethlisberger was considered the least ready to play immediately.
Turns out, he was the most ready.
He became the first quarterback in NFL history to go 13-0 in the regular season and led the Steelers to the AFC championship game. He destroyed every myth about rookie quarterbacks needing two to three years to get acclimated to the NFL game.
“I had the benefit — a lot of guys don’t — of having a really good team,” Roethlisberger said. “A lot of guys, especially when a young quarterback has to play, it’s usually with a bad team, typically.”
Since then, there have been other Roethlisberger-like starts for rookie quarterbacks:
• Andrew Luck, the first overall pick in 2012, led the Indianapolis Colts to three playoff appearances and was selected to three Pro Bowls his first three seasons in the league.
• Russell Wilson has started every game for the Seattle Seahawks since he was a third-round selection in 2012 and led the Seahawks to back-to-back Super Bowl appearances in 2013 and 2014.
• Oakland’s Derek Carr was the only quarterback from the 2014 draft class to start the season opener and never missed a game for three seasons, passing for more than 11,000 yards and throwing 81 touchdowns in that time.
• Jameis Winston, the first overall pick in the 2015 draft, started every game for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and became the third rookie in NFL history to pass for over 4,000 yards.
• Marcus Mariota, who was taken right after Winston by the Tennessee Titans, started the season opener against Winston’s Buccaneers and threw a touchdown on his first NFL pass attempt. He became the first rookie in league history to throw four touchdowns with no interceptions in back-to-back games.
• Carson Wentz was originally scheduled to sit and learn behind Sam Bradford after the Philadelphia Eagles made him the second overall pick in 2016, behind Goff. But that all changed when Bradford was traded to Minnesota. Wentz started 16 games, became the first rookie since 1970 to win his first two games without an interception and completed an NFL rookie record 379 passes.
• Deshaun Watson, the 12th overall pick in 2017, didn’t start until Week 2 and appeared in only seven games for the Houston Texans because of a season-ending knee injury. But, he threw for 1,699 yards and 19 touchdowns and ran for 269 yards and two more TDs in those seven games.
Curiously, Roethlisberger thinks it’s more beneficial for a quarterback to come in and learn for a year or two before becoming the starter, even though it doesn’t always work that way. Goff and Mahomes, though, are perfect examples.
“I think it’s so beneficial when you come in and watch,” Roethlisberger said. “People forget, you just played a hard year of college, then you trained [for the combine and draft], so there’s no offseason so your body is worn down. The game has changed so cerebrally; it’s such an important part of the game. It’s not easy for guys to do.”
Many are trying in 2018. Rudolph, though, isn’t one of them.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.