Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down the Steelers-Ravens prime-time matchup

During the second quarter of Monday night’s game between the Steelers and Buccaneers, referee Pete Morelli called roughing-the-passer penalties three times in 11 plays from scrimmage. Two of them were called on Steelers defenders Sean Davis and Stephon Tuitt in the span of five snaps. After throwing the flag on Davis, the fourth time before halftime, Morelli was well aware of the absurdity of the situation.

“The more we complained about it, he just kept throwing the flag,” Steelers cornerback Joe Haden said. “He even laughed on the last one he threw. He was like, ‘Stay off him.’ ”

The four roughing-the-passer penalties were the most in an NFL game in 17 years.

It’s not an NFL season without a controversial rule, and one season after the catch rule stirred debate and angered players and fans, we’re now knee-deep in controversial plays involving pass rushers as they try to figure out how to hit quarterbacks without getting penalized.

Advertise with us

It’s not a new rule. Officials, on the recommendation of the NFL competition committee, are merely putting an emphasis on and enforcing the language of a rule that was adopted in 1995. The part of the rule the competition committee wanted emphasized was the following: When tackling a passer who is in a defenseless posture (e.g., during or just after throwing a pass), a defensive player must not unnecessarily or violently throw him down or land on top of him with all or most of the defender’s weight.

The rule is being emphasized this year because owners don’t want their franchise quarterbacks getting injured. Last year Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers missed 13 games after Vikings linebacker Anthony Barr drove him into the ground and injured his shoulder after he released a pass.

Rodgers is one of the NFL’s top quarterbacks and earns $33.5 million per season. It’s not hard to figure out why Packers ownership and others with high-priced quarterbacks want the rule enforced.

The competition committee approved the renewed emphasis on the rule in the spring, and the league’s officials have followed their marching orders. There were 34 roughing the passer penalties through the first three weeks of the NFL season. That’s more than double the amount last season when 16 roughing-the-passer penalties were called through the first three weeks.

As a result, picture-perfect form tackles are penalties on quarterbacks. Just ask Packers linebacker Clay Matthews, who has been penalized twice in the past two weeks for roughing-the-passer because he landed with his body weight on the quarterback.

Advertise with us

Matthews did everything he was supposed to do to avoid a penalty against Washington quarterback Alex Smith last week. He kept his head to the side and contacted his shoulder. He did not hit him high. He did not hit him low. But, by the letter of the law, Matthews committed a penalty because he landed on top of Smith with his body weight.

Clay Matthews reacts to a penalty during last week's game against the Redskins. (Associated Press)

It has left defenders confused about how they should do their jobs. When Steelers defensive end Cameron Heyward was asked how he’s now supposed to sack a quarterback he said: “Uh, hug them very tightly.”

“I don’t really know,” he continued. “There’s just not a detailed definition of what’s going on.”

“I get the concept of what they’re trying to tell us to do, but I think the only thing that makes it hard is it’s almost impossible to do that in the speed of that moment,” Tuitt added. “You’re so used to putting on the pressure and taking down the quarterback. We’re not out there trying to kill the quarterback. You’re trying to do everything the right way.”

Steelers coach Mike Tomlin is a member of the competition committee and was in the room when the renewed emphasis was agreed upon in March. Tomlin’s experience with rules changes is there are always unforeseen issues with the application of the rule by officials.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think you ever have a feeling of what it is until you see how it plays out in stadiums,” Tomlin said. “The application is just as significant as the rule itself. So I think I am learning, just as we all are learning what it means.”

In other words, the frequency with which the referees have been calling the penalties has been a surprise.

Tomlin and other members of the competition committee held a conference call Wednesday night to discuss the roughing-the-passer penalties and decided no changes will be made at this time. That disappointed the Steelers, according to a source.

The committee did seek to clarify techniques that constitute fouls, and the league will continue to distribute teaching videos in an effort to help players adjust.

One league source stressed the officials will not change their approach.

Advertise with us

“Like other points of emphasis in years past, historically you see an uptick in fouls early in the season, and then as players and coaches adjust, the numbers move accordingly,” the source said.

Unintended consequences

Last Sunday, Miami defensive tackle William Hayes was bearing down on Oakland quarterback Derek Carr. He accomplished his mission of sacking Carr, but in an attempt not to land on Carr with his body weight, Hayes tore the ACL in his knee and is out for the season.

“I wish the guy had just landed on me,” Carr said this week.

It was only a matter of time before a defensive player was injured trying to sack a quarterback the way the rule is being emphasized. More injuries likely will follow.

Advertise with us

The NFL is asking defenders to tackle quarterbacks in a different manner than they tackle other players on the field. It’s a difficult assignment.

“I always thought wrap up, get your shoulder in there and you’ll be able to stay clean,” Heyward said. “You’re almost better off either going for the ball, or holding them up and having the referee blow it dead, which is crazy to me. This is 2018. This is what we’re dealing with.”

When Matthews sacked Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins two weeks ago, he placed his arm on the ground and caught his body weight in an attempt to avoid the penalty. By doing so, he was putting himself in danger by absorbing his own body weight.

Tuitt, for one, won’t put his own health at risk in those situations.

“I’m 310 pounds,” Tuitt said. “I can’t brace myself. I can’t put my arm on the ground. I’m falling to the ground. I’m not going to lie. I’m falling down to the ground. It’s body weight. I’m not going to keep my arm up. That’s too much weight falling down on my arm.”

Advertise with us

So how do the Steelers and other teams teach defenders to tackle quarterbacks while staying within the rules? It’s not easy for defensive coordinator Keith Butler.

“I think you have to try to adhere to the rules of the game,” Butler said. “How you do that sometimes is a mystery. You see guys throughout the league that come off the quarterback and the quarterback keeps going. If you’re going to do that they need to blow the whistle.

“I understand what they’re trying to do and help the quarterbacks maintain health. That’s what they want to do. But coaching it and trying to get our guys to be aggressive and harass the quarterback and keep their weight off them is challenge for us, but we’ll continue to try to coach them.”

The Buccaneers were penalized for roughing the passer twice during Monday's game against Ben Roethlisberger and the Steelers. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It’s especially difficult when facing a big quarterback, which is what both coaches in Sunday night’s Steelers game will be facing. Ben Roethlisberger has been torturing opposing defenses for years with his country-strong demeanor in the pocket while Joe Flacco of the Ravens can shurg off pass rushers as well. Heyward said defenders must tackle with force when trying to sack big quarterbacks. Otherwise, they’ll escape pressure and make a play. Ravens coach John Harbaugh agreed.

“It’s hard,” Harbaugh said. “We’re trying to figure it out, just like everybody else is. We want to get the quarterback down. You have a guy like Ben Roethlisberger. He doesn’t just go down easily. You have to bring some force to get [him down]. He’s a big man, and he’s strong and does not want to go down, so you have to wrap him up and tackle him to the ground. Now, you have to do that without landing on him or a number of other certain things that you can’t do, and we just have to be conscious of that.”

Advertise with us

The dead giveaway that something might be amiss with the rule is how many calls Roethlisberger has received this season. In addition to the two calls in the Buccaneers game, Browns defensive end Myles Garrett was called for roughing Roethlisberger in the opener.

Roethlisberger getting calls in previous years was a rare occurrence. Heck, in a 2010 game in Baltimore, Ravens defensive tackle Haloti Ngata broke Roethlisberger’s nose with a swat to his face and was not penalized.

“Every year we get new rules and new points of emphasis,” Roethlisberger said. “Sometimes the officials even have a hard time explaining them. I don’t think they can fully understand when to call it and when not to. I know for me to get three calls during a season is out of this world, let alone through three games. You know me. I don’t ever really complain or talk about it. To get a couple is kind of crazy.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.