Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Centers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
georgekircher, @georgekircher4: I know Ron (Cook) calls Bradshaw the biggest phony he ever met, but could it be (Bradshaw) was right about Tomlin?
Starkey: Let’s examine that, Mr. @georgekircher4, shall we?
First of all, let’s examine the source: After he left the NFL, Bradshaw got rich by playing his country bumpkin character to perfection. You might recall that around the time Chuck Noll passed away, Bradshaw was at The Meadows Racetrack and Casino doing a one-man show called “America's Favorite Dumb Blonde.”
He’s a professional fool. But hey, it pays well — and Bradshaw isn’t the only phony in television history.
To your question: Did he have a point in his latest criticism of Tomlin?
Read More
Yes and no.
Bradshaw told 97.3 The Fan in San Diego that Tomlin’s players do not fear him, and that is mostly true. Tomlin treats his players like men, and some in turn abuse that freedom and act like children (hello, Antonio Brown and Bud Dupree and some of your latest social-media posts directed at fans).
Then again, it’s comical to hear Bradshaw wax poetic about Chuck Noll instilling fear in players and how great that was. Bradshaw chafed at such treatment when he played. Hated it. Yet, in his book “Looking Deep,” he incredibly characterized his relationship with Noll as a “friendship” and wrote, “The friendship ended when I was no longer of use to Chuck.”
Now it’s, “If only Mike Tomlin were more like Chuck,” right Terry? No wonder long-time Steelers publicist Joe Gordon, one of Noll’s pallbearers, once told me Bradshaw is “the most insincere person I've ever known.”
Anyway, Bradshaw rips Tomlin for being enthusiastic with his players on the sidelines. Which is silly. He also criticizes Tomlin for underachieving since the Steelers’ last Super Bowl appearance, which is fair.
“I think that football team should have been in another Super Bowl or two,” Bradshaw said. “How could they not be? And to lose at home to Jacksonville, I don't care how good of a run Jacksonville got on … You don't lose, what, 45-42? Are you kidding me?”
It was ridiculous. No arguing that. But I’m not sure I would call that Steelers offense “great,” which brings us to Bradshaw’s final criticism.
“(Tomlin) fires the offensive coordinator and keeps the defensive coordinator," Bradshaw said. "Now, I don't know the reason behind that. I’ve asked a few people, and they're as puzzled as I am.”
Shredding the defense and wondering why Keith Butler kept his job is well within reason. But this idea that Tomlin was nuts for getting rid of Todd Haley really needs to go away. It has become quite popular (much more popular, ironically, than Haley ever was).
Haley couldn’t find a way to keep peace with the quarterback, succeed in the red zone or score enough points in most playoff games (his offenses totaled fewer than 20 in five of seven). And that 42-point game against Jacksonville was more a product of Ben Roethlisberger ditching Haley’s game plan and going playground than anything else.
The Steelers offense helped put the team in a hole that day, later failed in two fourth-and-1 situations (with no fullback on the field) and scored a junk touchdown with 1 second left. Spectacular individual plays by spectacular players, ad-libbing out of desperation, accounted for most of the points. Haley was an innocent bystander.
All righty then. Now to our ever-popular “Twitter Poll” segment. I wondered Monday about the “percent chance” the Steelers make the playoffs. Nearly 1,200 respondents voted:
Percent chance the Steelers make playoffs ....
— Joe Starkey (@JoeStarkey1) September 17, 2018
What we learned: Fans are not confident in a team that has started 0-1-1, tied the Cleveland Browns, gave up six touchdown passes to Patrick Mahomes and face what appears to be a fairly brutal schedule. Can you blame them?
I’ll take three more …
FiddyNap, @fiddy2nap: Was I looking at a Polanco slide or a Picasso painting?
Starkey: That was no Picasso, Mr. FiddyNap. I hated that Polanco got injured, but this was a result of him somehow never learning how to slide properly. Or even close to properly. It’s incredible. Neal Huntington defended this insane play — Polanco looked like he was trying to fly — as great hustle. He said nothing about the fact that a player somehow rose through the system without grasping so many fundamental aspects of the game. Polanco literally never learned how to slide. The Pirates never bothered to teach him. He was lucky not to have sustained a serious injury before this. He should never slide again. It’s not worth the trouble.
Jordan Dee, @JDeePGH: The #pirates were in a much better position last time I checked in. But even the most optimistic local media prediction I can recall had them below .500 this season. How should a fan view a .500 or better year?
Starkey: Good question, Mr Dee. I’d view it as a mild success — but expectations change. When a team starts 26-19, as the Pirates did, and makes significant moves at the deadline, then crumbles in August (10-17), it’s difficult to pronounce the year a success no matter what happens in a meaningless September.
On the other hand, when referencing the season after the fact — in bar-room arguments and talk shows — a winning record is the kind of minuscule, simple, out-of-context, chewable factoid that works to support an argument. And what have we become but a society that feeds off minuscule, simple, out-of-context, chewable factoids?
Maureen Stofanak, @mstof12912: Will the Pirates actually play the make up game on October 1st and will that be Buctober?
Starkey: I honestly don’t know, Maureen, and I frankly don’t feel like asking. My guess is that the game would be played only if it had postseason implications. Either way, you know what they say about “Buctober,” right?
It’s the shortest month of the year.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.