Quarterback:
It’s hard to overcome six turnovers, especially when five come from the quarterback, but Ben Roethlisberger had three interceptions and two lost fumbles – the first time in his career he threw three interceptions in the first half. Roethlisberger answered the Browns’ first touchdown with passes of 67 yards to JuJu Smith-Schuster and a 22-yard TD to Antonio Brown, but he couldn’t make enough plays in the end.
Grade: D
Running backs:
James Conner’s performance – 192 yards offense, including 135 rushing – was just what the Steelers were looking for in the first game without Le’Veon Bell. But it was dampened by his fumble that led to the first of Cleveland’s two fourth-quarter TDs to tie the game. Conner was the only running back, other than fullback Rosie Nix, who played, getting 36 touches and scoring two touchdowns in a Bell-like performance.
Grade: A
Read More
Receivers:
There were a couple big plays – the 67-yard catch and run by Smith-Schuster, Brown’s terrific 22-yard TD catch along the end-zone stripe – but not enough to put away the Browns after taking a 21-7 lead. Brown, who did not play in the preseason, had a game-high nine catches, but was targeted 16 times. Jesse James five catches, including a 37-yarder, but he let a pass go through his hands that was intercepted.
Grade: C
Offensive line:
The good news is the way the line opened holes for Conner, who had four runs of 10+ yards, including a 22-yard touchdown in which he got a big block from G David DeCastro. The bad news is the pressure the Browns generated on Roethlisberger, especially from DE Myles Garrett, who had two of the four sacks. Garrett forced two fumbles, including the one of Conner that started the Browns’ comeback.
Grade: C
Defensive line:
Yes, the Browns rushed for 177 yards, but the stats are a little misleading. With the exception of one series by the Browns and scrambles by Tyrod Taylor, who had eight rushes for 77 yards, the line did a solid job helping to stuff the run. But Taylor escaped too many times, including on his 20-yard touchdown, which capped drive in which the Browns ran nine times for 76 yards.
Grade: C
Linebackers:
It was a monster game from T.J. Watt, who did not play in the preseason because of injuries and responded with 11 tackles, four sacks and a big block of the potential game-winning field goal in overtime. The Steelers had seven sacks – Jon Bostic and Bud Dupree each had one – and Vince Williams had 12 tackles. But their failure to protect a 14-point lead in the fourth quarter made this tie feel like a loss.
Grade: B
Secondary:
Normally, getting seven sacks and holding Taylor to just 15 completions in 40 attempts would be a job well done. But Taylor was able to connect on three passes of at least 33 yards, two to Jarvis Landry, and his only completion to Josh Gordon was the tying 17-yard TD over Cam Sutton. But Sutton responded with a big interception when the Browns were trying for the win in regulation.
Grade: C
Special teams:
As rare as it is for a tie – the Steelers haven’t had one since November 2002 – it is even more rare to see Chris Boswell miss a game-winning field goal, which he did from 42 yards with 1:44 remaining in overtime. The trade for Ryan Switzer looks like it will be a good one. He averaged 11.2 yards on five punt returns, none bigger than a 22-yarder that to the Browns 39 that set up Conner’s 22-yard TD run.
Grade: B
Coaching:
Blowing a 14-point lead in the fourth quarter to a team that never won a game in 2017 and was 1-18 in season openers is never a good way to start the regular season. The Steelers were penalized 12 times for 116 yards and lost the turnover battle, 6-1. That’s either indicative of what happens when regulars rarely play together in the preseason or a portent of things to come.
Grade: D







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.