Here are some names for you. LaRod Stephens-Howling. Felix Jones. Jonathan Dwyer. Jordan Todman. Josh Harris.
What do they all have in common? They’re among the poor souls who’ve piled into the veritable clown car of running backs who’ve filled in for Le’Veon Bell as the Steelers’ lead rusher since he broke into the league in 2013. Most of them struggled, often in defeats.
Here’s another name for you: DeAngelo Williams. You remember him. He hasn’t been gone very long, but as the Steelers prepare for Bell’s holdout to last in the regular season, he’s missed nevertheless. He brought consistency those other guys didn’t.
Presumptive starter James Conner’s teammates sound confident he can be more the latter than the former. Looking at the numbers over the years, though, that’s far from a guarantee. Here’s a season-by-season review of how the Steelers have coped without Bell.
2013
Oh, folks, it was a mess. The Steelers drafted Bell to replace Rashard Mendenhall that spring, but he missed the first three games of the season with a Lisfranc injury. And his many replacements weren’t up to the job at all.
Read More
Isaac Redman fumbled twice, and Stephens-Howling, the former Pitt star, led the team in rushing with just 19 yards in a season-opening loss to Tennessee. The empty husk of Felix Jones was brought in to get the bulk of the carries the following week, and he managed just 37 yards as the offense sputtered again in a 20-10 defeat at Cincinnati. Then Dwyer got a shot and posted a meager 39 yards on 12 carries in a third-straight loss against Chicago.
The season had combusted on the launch pad before Bell made his debut in a loss at Minnesota in Week 4. The Steelers rallied to sniff a playoff bid, but the running game’s slow start was a big reason they didn’t make it over the hump.

2014
Bell only missed one game, but it was a big one, and his absence was conspicuous. A hyperextended knee suffered in the Week 17 win against the Bengals forced him to miss the Steelers’ wild-card playoff game against Baltimore. The team responded by signing free agent Ben Tate, who came in cold to gain all of 19 yards on five carries, while Harris led the team with just 25 on nine carries in a 31-17 season-ending loss.
2015
With the disasters of the previous two years fresh in their minds, the Steelers added Williams as insurance on a two-year deal in the offseason, and it paid off immediately. Bell was suspended for the first two games, and Williams filled the void admirably. He gained 127 yards in a season-opening loss against the Patriots, then rushed for 77 and three touchdowns in a win against the 49ers the following week.
It wasn’t the only time he proved his worth that season. Bell returned for the next six games but was lost for the season with a torn MCL after taking a hit from the Bengals’ Vontaze Burfict in Week 9. Williams responded by rushing for at least 70 yards in five of the last eight games as the Steelers slipped into the playoffs.
Unfortunately, they didn’t have Williams available for those biggest of games. He was injured in the season finale against Cleveland and missed the wild-card win against Cincinnati, then the divisional round loss at Denver. In his place, Todman and Fitz Toussaint combined for a respectable 123 yards on 28 carries in beating the Bengals. The wheels came off the following week, though. The duo had almost nothing for the eventual Super Bowl champion Broncos as receiver Martavis Bryant ended up leading the team in rushing.
2016
Bell earned himself a suspension for the beginning of the following season, too, and the Steelers were again lucky to have Williams. He torched Washington for 143 yards and two scores in the season opener, then piled up 94 yards against Cincinnati in Week 2 before Bell returned and dominated for the balance of the season.
Until the Steelers were one step from a Super Bowl.
Bell tried to play through a groin injury against New England in the AFC championship, but he didn’t make it. He got just six carries before Williams relieved him and struggled, gaining just 34 yards in a 36-17 Patriots rout.
2017
A healthy Bell sat out of the season finale against Cleveland to avoid injury. Late-season addition Stevan Ridley filled in, picking up 80 yards and a score on 17 carries.
***
Add it all up and the Steelers are 12-9 in regular season and playoff games in which Bell doesn’t get any action. Their lead back has gained fewer than 50 yards in nine of those games, and six of those are games in which Williams wasn’t available or was limited heavily by injury.
That’s the recent history into which Conner seems poised to step. Can he succeed where (checks notes) almost a dozen backs not named “Williams” have struggled over the past five years?
We shall see.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.