Ray Fittipaldo: Ok let's get started

Marty: Do you think the drafting of Rudolph in the 3rd round was a wasted pick as was the drafting of Dobbs last year a wasted pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: We'll have to wait and see. If Rudolph is Roethlisberger's successor and wins a bunch of games then it will be a good pick. If he ends up being the next Jimmy Garoppolo and never succeeds Roethlisberger then obviously it's not a good pick. No way to tell right now.

Perry: I'm still confused about the anxiety over not drafting an inside linebacker. Since we only run out of a base defense about 30% of the time, (and have acquired Bostic for that role, at least in the short term)doesn't it make sense to draft a safety/linebacker hybrid who can play in a dime, big nickel, and possibly nickel packages?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think you answered your own question somewhere in there. Boiled down, Bostic is replacing Ryan Shazier and most people don't view that as a positive. While the Steelers were not going to get another Shazier at No. 28 I think Rashaan Evans would have been viewed by many Steelers fans as an upgrade over Bostic.

Guest: Thoughts on quadree henderson?

Ray Fittipaldo: Only shot to make it is on special teams. He never really produced as a slot WR at Pitt. He was more of a gadget player, a guy who took jet sweeps and made them into big plays. So he'll have to prove he can be a viable slot option as a WR. I think he is a long shot to make the 53-man roster.

Kingmatt: Regarding L. Bell. Who in their right mind would pay a RB 17 mil a year! The Steelers should go back and watch the tape when we had deangelo Williams in the back field.. the offense didn’t skip a beat. I believe le’veon is mainly a product of the system and if he really wants that ridiculous amount of money he can go to a losing team and watch his production fall off a cliff.

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, the Steelers would pay him $14.5 million so they obviously value what he brings to the table. Not sure if they'll budge in their negotiation, but it's hard to watch this team and not value what Bell brings to the offense. He's a good runner, an excellent receiver out of the backfield, and he can pick up blitzes. My only issue is his inability to break long runs in recent years. That's the reason I wouldn't go much above $14.5 a year. He just doesn't make a lot of big plays for you in the running game.

Advertise with us

Federico Lopez-Conde: Who could be the 3rd QB next season ?

Ray Fittipaldo: I am assuming it will be Rudolph to start the season and likely end the season, unless there is an injury.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

DaquidoBazzini: Hello Ray - Can you elaborate a bit as to why you think Mason Rudolph slipped to the 3rd round?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, five QBs went in the first round so a lot of teams with needs at QB obviously had that need filled early. No QBs taken at all in the second round so it is a little strange that he fell all the way to No. 76. Kevin Colbert said he had a first-round grade on Rudolph. Maybe the Steelers had him valued higher than other team or perhaps other teams had to fill other needs before finding a QB.

mtsteel: Hi Ray and thanks. So Ben's comments about Rudolph. I do agree with him, he said to the FO he intends to be three 3 years at least. So how does that pick help the team now? Why not wait a year or two for the successor pick? The only thing I feel, is Ben should have kept his thoughts in house. Your thoughts? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Roethlisberger is right. The pick does not help the team now. Then again, there are no assurances another third-round pick would have either. I don't necessarily think what Ben said was wrong and or that he needed to keep it in-house. I just think the part about sending Rudolph to the playbook if he had any questions was a bit over the top. I mean, Rudolph simply said he didn't want to bother Roethlisberger, and he kind of turned it into something else without merit.

mtsteel: Hi Ray and thank you for your time. The Steelers players maintain that the secondary issues last season were mainly "communication based". That being said, who's the culprit? All of them? The guys that are gone? As a fan who was very frustrated with their play last year, I'd hope we dont have to repeat/hear about the same issue next season. Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure several players at one time or another had mistakes in that regard. But the free safety is the signal caller for the defense and the fact that Mitchell is no longer here likely speaks to his inability to do that job exceedingly well.

Advertise with us

DaquidoBazzini: Ray- Is there any ILB out there that you might foresee being available in a trade between now and TC?

Ray Fittipaldo: More likely than a trade would be waiting for a team to cut someone late in camp and then pick him up and sign him to the 53-man roster.

Al in NJ: Ray, do Ben's comments about the Rudolf pick surprise you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Read above. Not surprised except for the part about pointing him to the playbook.

Brij: Ben is an elite quarterback and future Hall Of Famer. Why does he continue to act immature and create unwanted noise each and every season? Mason Rudolf has fared better than Ben in the latest exchange. Ben sets a wrong precedent for a talented but already distracted locker room.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: More drama! Just what this team needs.

Jacob: I understand that Ben doesn't have to like a third round QB being drafted, but doesn't it strike you as odd that he would have the thinnest of skin to call out his employers? Are you that insecure that you have to question the abilities of your bosses? That's just stupidity on display in my humble opinion. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Roethlisberger knew this team was close last season. He thought they might use the draft picks to address the defense. The front office did not. He was merely saying what a lot of us were thinking. It doesn't make him a bad person.

Steeler fan in New England: 2018 draft shows Colbert’s genius. I know that fans and pundits alike hated the draft selections however this draft will free up 1m from Bryant, 3m for Wilcox, 14.5 for Bell, 20m for Ben, 5m for Mitchell as well as replace Hubbard. It sets up this franchise for the future while allowing us to compete this year. Will allow us to target free agents and sign our own moving forward. How can anyone be so blind not to recognize the net gain especially since there was no ILB worthy of a top pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: Colbert will be a genius is Rudolph is a really good QB who someday becomes Roethlisberger's successor. By the way, he's done pretty well in his 18 years as GM to this point.

Advertise with us

Jacob: Ray, I'm not asking for names, but last year, were there any players that from being around the locker room as often as you may be (far more than probably everyone else on this chat) were on the spectrum of locker room cancer to disliked or just a negative influence? Are there still?

Ray Fittipaldo: Looking back, it's hard not to recognize James Harrison was a locker room cancer in some ways. It was quite obvious players in that locker room had lost respect for him and the way he handled his final year with the team. That's the most obvious one.

Jacob: Odds of Steelers getting a deal inked to keep Le'Veon on the team longer than a year? We keep cutting higher cap players like Wilcox and Mitchell so do you see that as a potential move to have room for Mr. Bell?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not optimistic. I say 15 percent.

Jacob: Without signing a big ILB name or drafting one who would be a 3 down player, can we really make this work employing more LB-sized Safeties rather than the opposite in Shazier? I know it's a bit of a wait and see situation, but I'm very interested in your perspective on the feasibility of such a peculiar predicament we find ourselves in on D.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: The potential predicament is whether Bostic can hold up in his role. The part about safeties being dime LBs isn't that big of a deal. Really, you're talking about Terrell Edmunds taking over for William Gay. If Edmunds comprehends the defense and can play fast that should be an immediate upgrade. The issue for me is this: Is this defense going to be able to stop the run effectively with Jon Bostic as the ILB replacement for Shazier?

jim: Like most Steeler fans ,I am still searching for bright spots in this years draft! I am looking for anything that can justify our way too many offensive picks.When our obvious need is linebackers and we choose none? Do you think the Steelers have something different in mind ? Are we doomed to having to score 35 points or more to win every game?Please, I would appreciate anything to make this better!

Ray Fittipaldo: Eventually, Edmunds will become a starter and I think Burnett could settle into the dime linebacker role. But that won't happen right away. Washington is expected to come in and play right away. Randy Ficthner came out and said that. As always, if the top two picks do well there won't be many issues with the draft. So I'd say this: Watch and see how Edmunds and Washington develop before you say anything definitive about this draft class. And wait three years before grading it. It takes time.

Steelers47: Hello Ray - wouldn't you say adding another Body at ILB is a Must? very think there - Timmons and NVarro are still there and both would be solid 2 down backers.

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure it's a must, but I wouldn't be surprised if they made a move.

Advertise with us

Scott in Dallas: From Peter King MMQB:

2016 Ben: I’m thinking about retiring.

2017 Ben: Man, I’m probably going to retire.

2018 Ben: Why did they draft a QB in the 3rd round?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's kind of a simplistic national view to be honest with you. Around here, we all kind of know Roethlisberger's tune changed as soon as Todd Haley was fired. Almost immediately, the retirement talk changed to "I want to play 2-3 more years." Then after Rudolph was drafted it was "I want to play 3-5 more years. So Roethlisberger's retirement talk was more about Haley than anything else. Not sure the national people picked up on that. I am sure the Steelers realized that was part of the equation, too.

Advertise with us

Johnny2.0: Can we expect significant improvement on the defensive line next year? I thought we had a pro bowl type player in Tuitt...and I thought Hargrave showed flashes early on. Both of those players were dreadful in the second half of the season..and especially the playoffs. I watched them closely...they made very little plays, or provided any pressure. Was a lot of it nagging injuries?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tuitt struggled with injuries all year, could never really get completely healthy. Hargrave was injured late in the year. The problem was the depth behind them. They didn't have anyone who could give you better play than what they were offering when they were injured.

Las Vegas Steeler Fan: Hello Ray. Are you as surprised as most by Ben’s comments about drafting Rudolph? I am a diehard steeler fan and will always defend our team when other team’s fans run their mouth. I don’t understand why everytime a steeler player is unhappy the whole world has to know about it.

Ray Fittipaldo: Here's a secret: Journalists really like it when athletes tell us their feelings. Really, this is what you should want as fans. The truth eventually is going to get out. It always does. Why not give Roethlisberger some props for being honest and sharing his thoughts on the matter?

Ashton: Hi Ray! Do you think Jaylen Samuels is guaranteed a roster spot or will he have an uphill battle to make the 53?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Fifth-round picks are not guaranteed anything. Remember Shaquille Richardson and Wesley Johnson?

Corey R: Will James Washington start out on the outside with AB or will he start in the slot?

Ray Fittipaldo: Too early to say. JuJu Smith-Schuster had a ton of success in the slot last season. He showed he could play outside. I think we all know Washington can play outside. He has to show he can play in the slot.

Jeff: This RB we drafted seems to be Bell 2.0 and alot cheaper.

Ray Fittipaldo: Really? Jaylen Samuels averaged something like eight carries a game for NC State.

Advertise with us

Begonia Bob: Ben: Drafting Rudolph a wasted pick. Me: Having a better backup QB than what's already on the roster IS a good move for 2018 (ask the Iggles). What does Ray say?

Ray Fittipaldo: Nick Foles was a 29-year old veteran when he stepped in and led the Eagles to the Super Bowl. No one would expect Rudolph to do that in 2018. It takes time to develop into a quality QB in the NFL. So as far as 2018 goes, it's not a great move that is going to help this team. At least that wasn't their intention when they drafted him. They came out and said that.

Rick : Ray, I think the comments by Ben on the draft choices reflect his concern for their chances on winning another SB while he is the QB. It will be interesting how he interacts with Mason. Your thoughts? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: Some interesting times ahead indeed. I wrote about it today: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2018/05/07/mason-rudolph-s...

Brian in Va: I’ll give props to Ben for being honest but his feelings were “me first” not “team first.” Fans like players with a more team first mentality like Heath Miller had.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No one will really care about this in November if the Steelers are in contention for the No. 1 seed in the AFC. It's just offseason fodder.

Mark in KY: I believe Ben wants to play as long as possible and that the retirement talk was just that, but isn't it really more likely that age and mileage will set him down sooner rather than later? If that's the case, doesn't that make the Rudolph pick reasonable insurance from management's point of view?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure that's at least part of the reason they made the move. We have no idea what the future QB draft classes will be like. Kevin Colbert came out and said this 2018 class was special. They liked Rudolph in that group with the five that were taken in the first round. It's quite possible the Steelers won't like another QB as much in the next 1,2,3, however many years.

Chris: I seen where ben made the comment they may trade him just ben being salty or what

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe a bad attempt at humor.

Advertise with us

NC Steel: Ray, drafting the huge guy to play OT looks like a boom or bust pick. The odds are it will be bust, Why not use that pick to select a genuine OT from a Power 5 school? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Munchak took Al Villanueva and made him a starting left tackle after he came to him as a defensive lineman who had just been cut by the Eagles. Okoafor started for three years at Western Michigan, which has been one of the top mid-major programs in the country. We'll have to wait and see how this ends up, but Munchak is a great coach and I'd be surprised if this guy isn't starting by 2020.

OLB Needed: Everyone is so worried about ILB. Have they seen the roster at OLB? We couldn't stop Jacksonville because of Bud Dupree, not because Shazier was gone. That was evident from the first meeting in week 3. Do you they will address OLB in coming months?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not to the point of challenging Dupree. Maybe a depth move.

Gyest: I understand Ben was a little perturbed at the Steelers drafting Rudolph but disappointed when he indicated he wouldn't mentor him. I think once they're on the field that will change don't you?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think that will change.

Everyone's a linebacker!: I believe I heard a Dunbar assessment that Frazier got "Wally Pipp'd" at Alabama when Da'ron Payne took his spot after an injury. Am I silly to think that a 7th rounder can beat out Big Dan, claim a spot on the 53, and contribute to run D in his rookie year?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not a silly notion at all. Could happen if Frazier plays well in camp.

JamesinNYC: Remember there were a lot of FA QBs Cousins, Keenum, Bridgewater and even AJ McCarren. Plus trades of Alex Smith and Tyrod Taylor so there was a lot of pre draft changes.

Ray Fittipaldo: This too.

Steeler in Charlotte: Do you think our No. 4 WR when the season starts is on the team right now? (Not counting Bell)

Ray Fittipaldo: No.

Franco : Why would Ben create an issue by questioning the Steelers drafting of Mason Rudolph? Why not come in and help the young QB - I think it has really made him look petty and selfish, your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's not his job to mentor his replacement. His job is to win games and try to win another Super Bowl. If mentoring happens along the way that's fine. But that's not what this is all about.

Everyone's a linebacker!: Samuels certainly appears to be the sort of weapon a stacked O like the Steelers could take advantage of, but he doesn't have a solid position nor is his blocking considered NFL-ready. Do you think he has a chance to make the 53, and if so where could his roster spot come from?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes he has a chance. Maybe they don't keep three TEs.

JamesinNYC: Reading the article on why the draft doesn't make sense I would disagree with one major point. I think they could have a late RD1 grade on Rudolph the same as Washington and picked for need. I think a solid backup with starter potential is worth a mid third round pick. Do you think Ben will stay injury free and play 4 more years really?

Ray Fittipaldo: No one really knows for sure. But he's been pretty healthy ever since they made a commitment to protecting him and trying to get the ball out of his hand sooner. But to your point, injuries can happen, and it might be nice to have Rudolph on the roster if that does happen.

Kool-Aid: Hi Ray, Mike Mitchell claimed he played last season with a broken foot. Did you hear anything supporting that?

Ray Fittipaldo: Excuses, excuses.

Ray I.: Would you entertain bringing back Marcus Wheaton on a one year prove it deal as the #4/5 WR?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure what he would want in terms of money but if you;re asking if he's a better option than Eli Rogers I sat yes as long as he is healthy. The issue with Wheaton was his health not necessarily his production.

Chris: Could we keep Dobbs and let jones go it would be cheaper right

Ray Fittipaldo: It would be cheaper but not by much. I think they are comfortable with Jones as the backup.

pdxJaxon: in regard to Mitchell's foot, his foot is a long way from his HEAD and MOST of his errors were mental ones.....like stupid penalties, etc.

Ray Fittipaldo: Right.

JamesinNYC: Samuels a bigger attempt at all the scat backs that failed? At least he is big enough to block so you don't know the gimmick play is coming if you are on D.

Ray Fittipaldo: That might be. I'm interested to see him later this week in minicamp and then in OTAs and training camp.

Bulldogs : I see Chuks making the roster. So who goes from current OL? Is drafting Chuks in 3rd fire intended to light as fire under Hawkins who may be in trouble for a roster spot?

Ray Fittipaldo: I assume Matt Feiler, but if Hawkins regresses for any reason he's not safe either.

LatrobeGuy: why would a super bowl contending team release a proved back-up QB to go with 2 unproven new guys?

Ray Fittipaldo: Correct.

Dom: Do you think that Brian Allen will make the team again this year? If so, would you think he would be designated for Special Teams only or compete for a roster spot?

Ray Fittipaldo: They liked him enough last season to keep him on the 53-man roster so I assume they'll keep him again if they believe he is developing as a DB. We really don't know how well he can play in the secondary because he hasn't played much.

Nate: Hi Ray, do you think Finney is a potential starter for Foster next year? Or do the Steelers only view him as quality back-up C/G? Thanks!

Ray Fittipaldo: The fact they did not take a guard in the draft this year might speak to their thoughts on Finney. Foster is entering the last year of his contract so unless they re-sign Foster or draft a G high next year then it seems like Finney's job in 2019.

Redmon: Ray what makes Edmunds so special to the point he was drafted ahead of the other safeties were rated better? I.e. Reid,Bates,Harrison

Ray Fittipaldo: Rated better by whom? Not by Kevin Colbert. He said Edmunds was their highest-rated safety when they picked. These guys you mentioned were rated higher by the so-called draft experts but not by the Steelers.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. I am on vacation next week so no chat. See you in two weeks.