OK, Steelers fans: Leighton Vander Esch or Rashaan Evans?
That’s the most popular question as the hours dwindle between now and the first round of the NFL draft Thursday night.
Both are considered to be among the top four inside linebackers in this rookie class and have been connected to the Steelers for months because of their projected draft slots.
The top two inside linebackers in the draft — Roquan Smith of Georgia and Tremaine Edmunds of Virginia Tech — are expected to be top-15 picks and long gone by the time the Steelers select at No. 28.
That leaves us with the Evans-Vander Esch debate, and the waters were muddied last week.
Medical and character red flags are two pieces of the evaluation process that tend to influence where teams will draft players. Teams might know information before reporters, but sometimes there are leaks.
Read More
Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Such was the case last week, when walterfootball.com reported one team had taken Vander Esch off its draft board due to a medical red flag with his neck. Other reports surfaced that debunked the original report, and now we’re all left to decipher exactly what it all means.
Before the report surfaced, Vander Esch, who played at Boise State, had been a fast riser on draft boards after an excellent combine that thrust him into the conversation with this year’s most athletic inside linebackers. Most had him ascending into the first round after starting the process as a second-round option.
Now, it’s a matter of trying to uncover if there is any truth to the rumors. One source said the Steelers are not overly concerned about his neck issue. They had him in for a visit and attended his pro day. There is undoubtedly interest on their part. What we don’t know for sure is if they have a first-round grade on him. If they do, the neck issue won’t be a factor in their decision.
A medical issue last year with former Auburn edge rusher Carl Lawson dropped him to the fourth round. He had a great rookie season with the Bengals and was among the top sackers in the 2017 rookie class. Sometimes, perceived medical issues don’t surface. At least not right away.
It was only 13 years ago that a medical concern allowed the Steelers to get Heath Miller with a late first-round pick. He had a sports hernia that prevented him from working out for teams in advance of the draft. The Steelers ran to the podium with the pick, and Miller helped the Steelers win a Super Bowl as a rookie.
Could Vander Esch do the same for the Steelers in 2018?
Evans, who played at Alabama, is viewed as the safer of the two prospects by many teams. There have been some concerns about Evans not running the 40-yard dash during the predraft process, and his unwillingness to run might be a problem for some teams that want to know what they’re getting. There also seem to be some durability concerns after playing through some injuries in college.
But Evans was a productive player for a national championship team, and his tape suggests he should transition well to a three-down linebacker role in the NFL. He’s not the most athletic linebacker in this class, and Vander Esch, Smith and Edmunds are said to have better upside. What Evans does possess is instinctual skills and a demeanor that many analysts believe will fit perfectly with the Steelers’ mentality and scheme.
Daniel Jeremiah, who scouted for the Ravens, Eagles and Browns before becoming an analyst for the NFL Network, said Evans “looks like a Steeler.”
In a year they are desperate to find an impact player for the middle of their defense, the Steelers take Evans and plug him into their starting lineup.

RAY’S PICKS
1. Cleveland: Josh Allen, QB, Wyoming — Todd Haley gets to work with another strong-armed quarterback with ability to be creative outside the confines of the offense.
2. New York Giants: Saquon Barkley, RB, Penn State — Manning, Beckham and Barkley give the Giants the skill players needed to compete in NFC East.
3. New York Jets: Sam Darnold, QB, Southern California — The Jets are hoping Darnold isn’t another Mark Sanchez.
4. Cleveland: Bradley Chubb, DE, N.C. State — Chubb and Myles Garrett on the edge of the Browns defense means AFC North quarterbacks better be aware.
5. Denver: Baker Mayfield, QB, Oklahoma — The search for Peyton Manning’s successor continues with the confident (cocky?) Sooner.
6. Indianapolis: Denzel Ward, CB, Ohio State — The Colts need help everywhere and start on the outside with the best corner in the draft.
7. Tampa: Derwin James, S, Florida State — The Buccaneers add an explosive athlete and playmaker to their secondary.
8. Chicago: Quenton Nelson, G, Notre Dame — The Bears add the best (and nastiest) offensive lineman and instantly improve their running game.

9. San Francisco: Roquan Smith, ILB, Georgia — Speed to cover sideline to sideline and a strong presence in the middle of the defense.
10. Oakland: Minkah Fitzpatrick, S, Alabama — Jon Gruden doesn’t pass on the most versatile and accomplished defensive back in the draft.
11. Miami: Josh Rosen, QB, UCLA — The Dolphins cut some big salaries this winter, so they’ll commence the total rebuild with Rosen as their quarterback of the future.
12. Buffalo: Tremaine Edmunds, LB, Virginia Tech — The Bills add speed and versatility to their defense, which was among the worst in the league in yards allowed.
13. Washington: Vita Vea, DL, Washington — Big and nimble, the Redskins land a disruptor for the middle of their defense.
14. Green Bay: Marcus Davenport, OLB, Texas-San Antonio — With Clay Matthews getting older, the Packers add the small-school wonder to the edge of their defense.
15. Arizona: Lamar Jackson, QB, Louisville — Dynamic playmaking quarterback and Heisman winner lands in the desert.
16. Baltimore: Calvin Ridley, WR, Alabama — The Ravens have struggled to find receivers, but Ridley should put an end to that.
17. Los Angeles Chargers: Da’Ron Payne, DL, Alabama — The strongest player in the draft will make the Chargers harder to run against.
18. Seattle Seahawks: Josh Jackson, CB, Iowa — The Seahawks need to replace Richard Sherman, and Jackson can step in and start as a rookie.

19. Dallas: D.J. Moore, WR, Maryland — Moore has been rising up draft boards, and the Cowboys fill a need after releasing Dez Bryant.
20. Detroit: Harold Landry, LB, Boston College — New coach Matt Patricia gets a talented edge defender to build around.
21. Cincinnati: James Daniels, C, Iowa — The Bengals need a center, and Daniels is the best one in the draft. Easy pick.
22. Buffalo: Will Hernandez, G, UTEP — Two retirements decimated the offensive line. Hernandez fills one of those needs.
23. New England: Kolton Miller, T, UCLA — Bill Belichick gets a talented but raw left tackle prospect to develop.

24. Carolina: Courtland Sutton, WR, SMU — The Panthers need more skill players around Cam Newton, and Sutton has potential to be a No.1 receiver.
25. Tennessee: Leighton Vander Esch, LB, Boise State — New coach Mike Vrabel knows linebackers and picks one to solidify the middle of his defense.
26. Atlanta: Taven Bryan, DL, Florida — More potential than polished, but coach Dan Quinn knows how to develop defensive linemen.
27. New Orleans: Hayden Hurst, TE, South Carolina — A well-rounded tight end who can work the middle of the field for Drew Brees.

28. Steelers: Rashaan Evans, ILB, Alabama — The three-down linebacker the Steelers need to plug their biggest area of need.
29. Jacksonville: Mike McGlinchey, OT, Notre Dame — The Jaguars offense is built around the running game, and Doug Marrone adds another quality blocker to the mix.
30. Minnesota: Isaiah Wynn, G, Georgia — The Vikings invested big in quarterback Kirk Cousins. Now they have to make sure they protect him.
31. New England: Jaire Alexander, CB, Louisville — A talented corner to replace Malcolm Butler. Belichick might even decide to play him in the Super Bowl.
32. Philadelphia: Justin Reid, S, Stanford — The Eagles have some aging defensive backs and Reid is a versatile athlete who can play a number of roles.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.