Since 1981, NFL teams drafted 84 quarterbacks in the first round. The Steelers drafted one.
Now as Ben Roethlisberger enters his 15th season at age 36, the question becomes, when do you find, or at least try to find, his replacement?
That is a chore that no team takes lightly, is complicated and can involve pluck and luck. With the 28th pick in the first round, the Steelers would need to be luckier than the Miami Dolphins in 1983 when they drafted Dan Marino at 27, and luckier than the Green Bay Packers when they drafted Aaron Rodgers at 24 in 2005. That, even if they WANTED to draft a quarterback this year.
Since 1981, Marino and Rodgers are the only first-round quarterbacks drafted as late as the 20th pick who amounted to much, judging by a list researched through Pro Football Reference.
What is left are the likes of Tim Tebow, J.P. Losman, Patrick Ramsey, Jim Druckenmiller, Jason Campbell, Brady Quinn and more who never made it.
“What Green Bay did when they had the opportunity was to me the ultimate game-plan — if you have a chance,” said Ernie Accorsi.
Read More
A little history lesson on Accorsi: A Hershey, Pa., native, he was general manager of the Baltimore Colts, old Cleveland Browns and New York Giants. He joined the Colts in 1970 in the waning years of Johnny Unitas. He drafted John Elway (later traded by the Colts owner to Denver), Bernie Kosar and Eli Manning. He has consulted for the NFL and several teams since his retirement.
Few GMs can match his credentials when it comes to knowing quarterbacks.
“Here’s the thing about the quarterback,” Accorsi said. “People say, ‘Well, you have to draft a quarterback.’
“I’m not saying this isn’t the case with every position, but it’s magnified by the quarterback: You can’t grade by the curve. If you don’t have a complete conviction on the quarterback, you can’t draft him. You can’t just draft him out of need. I don’t believe in drafting out of need anyway, but particularly at quarterback.
“If you blow that pick, that can set you back 5 to 10 years.”
That applies mostly to a first-rounder because once a team drafts a quarterback that high, they become fully committed to his development.
Accorsi believes a quarterback needs time behind a starter in order for that development to take place, which is why he said the Packers had the ultimate game plan by selecting Rodgers to develop behind Brett Favre. But teams are impatient with first-rounders; Rodgers is the only quarterback in the past 16 years to mostly sit as a rookie and become that team’s franchise player (if you want to count Mike Vick in Atlanta in 2001).
“Roethlisberger was an exception, Marino was an exception and even Elway,” Accorsi said of the rookie starters. “Eli struggled. Usually you don’t do well early so it’s obscured — ‘Is this going to be a mistake or does it just need time?’ So you give them the time and by the time you find out, if he isn’t the answer, now you’re behind the 8-ball.
“I mean, you can find another safety, OK? But to pick a quarterback? I’m not saying Joe Montana in the third round or Tom Brady in the sixth. I’m talking a top five pick. You have to be right.”
The Steelers are not close to a top five pick and they can’t get that high to grab one even if they wanted to. Four quarterbacks could be drafted in the top 10 — Sam Darnold, Josh Allen, Josh Rosen and Baker Mayfield.
“I’m not going to tell the Steelers what to do,” Accorsi said. “They won six Super Bowls.”
But.
“They’d have to give away eight million draft choices to get in the top four if they believe in these kids. So they’re not going there. That’s not how they do business.”
No, it’s not. So when and where do they find a replacement for Roethlisberger, who told teammates he plans to play at least three more seasons?
Brady plans to play at age 41 next season and the Patriots have no viable successor on their roster. They had one in Jimmy Garoppolo but, faced with the dilemma of keeping Brady or moving him and playing Garoppolo, they stuck with Brady. The Patriots traded Brady’s natural successor to San Francisco, and the 49ers just lavished Garoppolo with a five-year, $137.5 million contract, highest in NFL history.
New England has two first-round draft choices (No. 23, No. 31) and could put together a package to move higher if they want to draft a quarterback next week.
Often, teams must hit rock bottom in order to get their next franchise quarterback. That’s why the Giants are in position to do so this year even though Manning remains their starter and was drafted the same year as Roethlisberger, 2004.
The Giants went 3-13 last season and have the second pick in the draft. After the Cleveland Browns pick their quarterback at No. 1, New York can draft one, and he can sit behind Manning for a year or so.
That’s how the Steelers got Roethlisberger. They had Tommy Maddox and Kordell Stewart at quarterback and went 6-10 in 2003, still their worst record in this century. It afforded them the 11th overall pick in 2004.
Three quarterbacks were rated highly that year — Manning, Roethlisberger and Philip Rivers. San Diego drafted first and the Giants fourth. Accorsi wanted Manning, as did the Chargers. But Manning did not want San Diego. The Chargers picked him anyway, Accorsi chose Rivers and then swapped players shortly thereafter with the Giants adding draft picks to persuade the Chargers to deal.
Accorsi really wanted Roethlisberger if he could not get Manning but knew the Chargers would trade for Rivers and not Roethlisberger.
“The problem is, that 4-12 season in 2003, if we don’t have it, we don’t get Eli or Ben,” Accorsi said. “If you’re .500, you have too far to go; we had to give up the moon to get from 4 to 1 [in the trade].
“I was worried until I got on the clock that the Raiders were not going to pick Robert Gallery, they were going to pick Roethlisberger. Right now you’d pick those guys 1-2.”
Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
The Cleveland Browns offered Accorsi a high second-round pick to move from fourth to seventh in the first round in 2004.
“I was afraid to do it because I wasn’t going to take the chance of losing Roethlisberger at seven. I would have gotten him, but when that gun’s at your head ...”
Philadelphia found their quarterback in similar fashion in 2016. They traded veteran players to move from 13 to eight in the first round. That allowed them to trade with Cleveland from eight to No. 2 by giving away a slew of picks, including their first-rounder in 2017 (which they essentially got back when they traded quarterback Sam Bradford to Minnesota).
Then they drafted Carson Wentz.
“I know this, if you have an opportunity to move up and take Carson Wentz, you do it,” said Eagles senior player personnel adviser Tom Donahoe, a former Steelers player personnel honcho. “It’s changed our whole team, changed our whole outlook for the future. He covers up a lot of warts.”
And the Browns were again holding the bag. Since they returned to the NFL as an expansion franchise in 1999, they’ve drafted four quarterbacks in the first round. Three are out of the NFL, and there is Brandon Weeden. They passed on Roethlisberger, Rodgers, Wentz (by making the trade) and Deshaun Watson, among others.
Of course, a team can get lucky by finding a Brady in the sixth or a Dak Prescott in the fourth. The Steelers reached a Super Bowl with Neil O’Donnell, a third-rounder.
Finding those is hitting the lottery. Drafting one in the first round has proven no sure bet either.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.