The Steelers acquired tight end Vance McDonald in a trade with the 49ers a week before the 2017 season began because they were unhappy with the play of incumbent starter Jesse James. Their plans to incorporate McDonald into their high-powered offense, however, had to be put on hold until late in the season after McDonald missed six games with various injuries.
McDonald’s production once he got healthy and had a firm grasp of the offense bodes well for his second season with the Steelers. In the final four games he played during the regular season and the playoffs, McDonald caught 19 passes for 216 yards. In the playoff game against Jacksonville, McDonald caught 10 passes for 112 yards and was targeted a team-high 16 times.
The Steelers clearly believe the speedy McDonald can add another dimension to their offense, and the hope next season is that he can do it over a full 16-game season. McDonald has endured injuries throughout his first five seasons in the NFL. He also never played a full season with the 49ers, the team that drafted him in 2013.
McDonald, who will earn $3.7 million in salary in 2018, is the highest-paid tight end at a position where the Steelers have a bit of uncertainty beyond next season. McDonald’s salary goes up to $4.2 million in 2019 and $5.5 million in 2020 and 2021, but there is no dead cap hit in any of those years if the Steelers wanted to part ways with him for any reason.
This is a big year for McDonald. If he can stay healthy and produce the way the Steelers believe he can, they will gladly pay him his salary in coming years. But if he has trouble staying healthy again and he cannot produce, the Steelers have the option to easily get out of the remaining years of his contract.
In addition, James, who has started 29 games over the past three seasons, is entering the final year of his rookie contract. Xavier Grimble, a little-used third tight end the past two seasons, is back on another one-year contract.
Read More
Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
The Steelers could add another quality player to the group in the draft, and they might opt for a player who is proficient as a blocker. None of the tight ends currently on the roster are considered strong blockers. In fact, when the Steelers needed some extra muscle in the running game in recent years they used backup offensive lineman Chris Hubbard as an extra tight end.
With Hubbard signing as a free agent with the Browns, the Steelers could replace him with a tight end from the college ranks who can be groomed for a role as an in-line blocker.
The Steelers met with several tight ends at the NFL combine in March and are expected to interview more at the team’s practice facility during top-30 visits this month.
One reason the Steelers sought McDonald in a trade — and a reason they signed Ladarius Green in free agency the previous year —- has been the lack of depth of quality tight ends in the college ranks. It’s difficult to find tight ends who can block and be threats in the passing game.
Increasingly, NFL teams have to decide if they want to draft a pass-catching tight end or blocking tight ends. There isn’t much in-between in the prospects available, mostly because of what they are asked to do for their colleges.
The Steelers have been in somewhat of a transition the past two seasons since Heath Miller retired. They signed Green, a pass-catching tight end, to a four-year, $20 million contract in free agency in March 2016, but he only played six games. He was cut last year after suffering foot and head injuries that also kept him from playing for another team last season.
Through all injuries to their higher-priced signings and acquisitions, James has been there to hold down the end of the line. He’s not a dynamic receiver in the passing game, and he’s not a dominant blocker, but he is durable and accountable, two traits that have served him well after getting drafted in the fifth round out of Penn State in 2015.
James has reliable hands, but he is not a player that will threaten defenses with yards after the catch. He caught a career-high 43 passes for 372 yards and scored three touchdowns last season, but his 8.7 yards per reception is representative of his ability as a pass-catcher. McDonald, by comparison, averaged 13.4 yards per catch.
In a perfect world, James is a No. 2 tight end, but the injuries to Green and McDonald made James a starter. That’s not his fault. And until the Steelers have someone — maybe McDonald, maybe someone they draft in two weeks — who can take over the starting role on a full-time basis, James remains a valuable member of the team for at least one more season.
Sometimes a player’s best ability is his availability, and James has proven to be a reliable, if unspectacular, player during his first three NFL seasons.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.
HOW THEY WERE BUILT
Jesse James
Year acquired: 2015 draft, fifth round
School: Penn State
Signed through: 2018
Vance McDonald
Year acquired: 2017, trade with San Francisco
School: Rice
Signed through: 2021
Xavier Grimble
Year acquired: 2016, free agent
School: USC
Signed through: 2018
Top five tight end prospects as rated by nfldraftscout.com
• Dallas Goedert, South Dakota State, senior
• Mike Gesicki, Penn State, senior
• Mark Andrews, Oklahoma, junior
• Jaylen Samuels, N.C. State, senior
• Ian Thomas, Indiana, senior






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.