
Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, we're going to start our chat in about 10 min
Gerry Dulac: OK lets get started....Go!!
Gerry Dulac: I can think of at least one who is available -- Dick LeBeau
Captain Midnight: Gerry, I got the feeling the refs (including the replay ref in NY) got the message to let ‘em play. I’m convinced at least one, if not both Eagle TD passes would have been overturned in the regular season. So my question: do you agree, and do you prefer the games to be called this way, or as they are during the season?
Gerry Dulac: I think you might be right and I agree -- I prefer it that way. Let 'em play .... within reason of course. Too many ticky-tack calls
Leaper: What's the scoop on John Mitchell?
Read More
Gerry Dulac: He was probably going to retire this year or next, so maybe it's going to be this year.
Drewo77: Do you think the steelers will go free agents to fix there defense because to me if go draft to fix the D the window will close
Gerry Dulac: They will do both. But, I will say it again, the defense doesn't need a lot of fixing. What needs to be remedied is how to replace Shazier.
Todd - Michigan: Where are they now.. Bryan Hinkle .. any idea ? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: Nope. Havent seen him in a couple years. Probably at a beach somewhere. Good dude
Todd - Michigan: Do you expect them to terminate the Mitchell contract? ..if so, when? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: If you mean Mike Mitchell, I expect them to release him because of how much he will count against the cap. Of course, they could also ask him to re-do his deal, tho that seems unlikely
Todd - Michigan: Do you expect them to make Nix and Chickillo an offer to return? What about Moats? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I do on Nix and Chickillo for sure. Moats might be able to get a better deal elsewhere, if he chooses.
Leaper: Is there concern the relationship between Ben and Fichtner will duplicate Ben and Arians?
Gerry Dulac: And what was wrong with that??
Ron: Well, I guess the owner has finally defined the 'standard' for us. We all assumed the standard was that anything short of a Lombardi trophy was failure. How wrong we were! The standard is simply something a little to the better of mediocrity and a participation trophy. Maybe the problem starts at the very top. If that's all he expects, it's all he'll every get: a 'decent' showing.
Gerry Dulac: Ron, that is very well-stated point.
chuck: gerry, what's the scoop with john mitchell? he gone or being promoted to d cord? thanks
Gerry Dulac: No, they have a defensive coordinator. As I said, it's possible he could retire. But it's also very possible the Steleers could bring in a D-Line assistant to work for one season until Mitchell retires after 2018 seasaon
Todd - Michigan: Was the Lake departure a surprise and or by choice? ... I’m your opinion Gary... Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I believe it was by choice, but I'm not naive enough to think it might not have been encouraged. I don't believe Carnell Lake was any problem, tho. He didn't deserve to be let go, if that were the case.
Jeff from Massachusetts : Gerry - for our HC to fully “embrace” situational football would AR force a seasoned assistant coach on him that can help in that regard?, tired of us lacking in that dept!
Gerry Dulac: No.
Brian in CA: How many of the other 31 head coaches in the NFL would have made the playoffs this year if they were the coach of the Steelers, given their talent and schedule? My guess is most of them(20+?). And if they coached the Steelers against Jacksonville in the playoffs, how many would have won? My guess is most of them, as the Steelers had in my (granted, completely amateur) opinion more talent than the Jaguars. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: They didn't have more defensive talent. They were outplayed and, more important, physically overwhelmed by the Jaguars on both lines of scrimmage. To your other point, maybe Mike Mularkey. He beat Jax twice this year w Tennessee.
Dsf: gerry, much has been made about fixng the defense but wouldn’t it be easier to fix unforced mental errors that lead turnovers? were it not for those, we may have had home field advantage throughout the playoffs or beaten the jags in the playoffs.
Gerry Dulac: Mental mistakes and bad fundamentals hurt the Steelers as much as anything this year. And the coaches know it. The solution: Get more fundamentally sound players who can think on their feet
ryanh: Is the rumors true about the steelers looking to replace john mitchell
Gerry Dulac: Nobody said they are looking to replace him as though he is the problem. As I said, they could be bringing someone in to work under Mitch for a year until he retires after 2018. Do not read this as a problem with JM
Don: I really hope they don't sign Bell. I don't think he fits the Steelers and will stick it to them before long. Selfish me firster. They need an ilb and a safety far more than a rb. Defense wins sbs. I'm still not confident they are secure enough at cb but I would hope a draft pick or FA would get that done. I drool at what this team could have done with a better than average defense.
Gerry Dulac: I agree with your first premise about Bell but I stopped reading your question/hypothesis when you said defense wins Super Bowls. Did you watch the postseason? Point up one game since the divisional round where the defense won the game? Defenses were non-existent. It was all about offense.
talldrinkofwater: Jerry, don't you think Ben should sign a reasonable 3 year deal, take over leadership of this team and move them forward both on and off the field? He wears the C on his jersey, has many years of experience and wanted more control. MT's comments only go so far. This team needs a leader to get them focused and minimize the drama.
Gerry Dulac: That sure sounds nice on paper, or the script for a good movie
Joel for the defense: What would the Steelers have to get back in a trade for M. Bryant to make it work in your opinion if they were to try and trade him?
Gerry Dulac: They probably wouldnt get anything more than a 4th rd pick. He's a huge risk factor, considering his suspension issues
ryanh: do you think the steelers let bell walk and just pair conor wit a change of pace back i think thats the way to go
Gerry Dulac: They won't let him walk. And they are not prepared to think James Conner can be a No. 1 back
Steeler in Charlotte: Steelers typically don't make huge panic changes. So assuming they make only one key signing this offseason, what position do you think they focus on before the draft?
Gerry Dulac: ILB. And still address it in the draft
Joel for the defense: Which would you rather have: A late first, late 2nd, and late 3rd round picks or three 2nd round picks?
Gerry Dulac: Good question. Depends how high the second-round picks were
Franco : Gerry, I'm a Canadian and the biggest Steeler fan............really enjoy your Steelers chat as well as Ed's. Just wanted to mention that My Steeler fantasy would be joining you and Ed on one of your fabled road trips..............any chance?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know about the chances, but it's a good thought on your part.
Joel for the defense: Do you think Rod Woodson would be open to coming in and being the DB coach?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know...maybe. Depends on his contract situation. That would be a lateral move
ryanh: Any idea on who will be our new DB coach
Gerry Dulac: Not yet
Colin: Thoughts on guys like Demario Davis and Eric Reid and free agent pickups after we cut a few guys and extend Ben and Bell? Could then go Edge in 1, ILB in 2.
Gerry Dulac: Their plan is not to go on the edge again. Their plan will be to address the inside LBs
Phil Toledo: Is it safe to say in your opinion, both Gay and Mitchell could end up as cap casualties?
Gerry Dulac: You're being kind w referring to them as cap casualties. Mitchell maybe. But I don't expect both back
Joel for the defense: If the defense does not need a lot of fixing, what happened to the front 7 (front 3/ outside LB's) in the domination by the Jags OL?
Gerry Dulac: Tuitt (hyperextended elbow) and Hargrave (back) were injured. And the inside LBs just aren't that good without Shazier. By the way, did you happen to watch any of the No. 1, 2, 3 and 4 ranked defenses in the postseason? Did you? They were disgraceful
Phil Toledo: Do you think the plan is to stay at 28 in the Draft? Or maybe the pull off a trade with Bryant and are able to move up and get a top 15 talent at inside LB?
Gerry Dulac: That's a long way to jump, though the thought sounds good
JR: Gerry, I never thought I would say this but I don't want them to sign Bell to a big contract. We have one of the best lines in football and I know we can replace his running ability. His pass catching is what makes him unique but this team does not need his pass catching. I wish we would just use that money to bolster the middle of the defense. We lose one big superstar but it makes a better TEAM. Am I wrong for thinking this way?
Gerry Dulac: You are not. Pay the man
Joel for the defense: What is the point of having two number one's as the compensation for an exclusive Franchise Tag if everyone understands no team will ever give up two number one's?
Gerry Dulac: Just in case. Whats the harm?
Rick Sunner: Does anyone know the true back story with what happened with Harrison and the coaching staff? Especially with Shazier going down, JHay would have greatly helped the depleted linebacker corps. I think he clashed with the ego maniac Porter who was trying to bring Dupree along. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: Your premise is way off. His only clash was with how much playing time he was receiving. And that's w Tomlin
Matt: Gerry, great job as always covering Steelers. We will prob cut Mitchell. Who else do you see them cutting to save $?
Gerry Dulac: That's the big one. A lot will depend on what happens w a Bell contract. A long-term deal would save them money under the cap.
Matt: Chances we resign Hubbard?
Gerry Dulac: He probably realizes he can get a much better deal on the FA market
Matt: Is Coach John Mitchell leaving? Hearing we want Karl Dunbar as DL Coach.
Gerry Dulac: No, he's not leaving. He will be back in some form
Joel for the defense: How do you think they will change the catch rule for next season?
Gerry Dulac: Hopefully for the better
Matt: Who is the backup NT 2 Hargrave next year?
Gerry Dulac: Probably not on the roster yet
John: Gerry- Any thoughts on the Steelers packaging picks to move up in the first round for an elite LB like Roquon Smith from Georgia?
Gerry Dulac: That's not their style
Josh: I keep hearing that the Steelers should consider not signing Bell at his high price and point to the teams in the super bowl that made it without great backs. I think that is poor way of looking at it. Every team has its own strengths and weaknesses and those teams have different strengths than the Steelers. Using that logic, three of the four teams in the super bowl had back-up QBs or Bortles (and winning team had a back-up), so should we just disregard having a good QB now because we can win without one??? Our D was not as good as the Eagles or Jaguars. But we make up for it with offense, which is one of the Steelers' strengths at this time - and Bell is a big part of it. Why weaken our strength when our other areas aren't ready to make up for that loss? Agree?
Gerry Dulac: I disagree
bill: is there still a possibility that some assistants will be elsewhere before long?
Gerry Dulac: Possible yes
ryanh: one of the biggest issues on defense is tackling every year it seems the tackling gets worse how is it that this has been allowed to go on for so long
Gerry Dulac: I agree
Rich M: If Steelers resign Bell does that mean the only improvements on Defense we can make will have to be through the draft?
Gerry Dulac: Not necessarily
Don: Yes Gerry, it was all about offense. That was my point. Don
Gerry Dulac: Thanx Don
SteelLion: Gerry, a Steeler website says the Dupree/Haden side was 3'rd in the NFL vs runs and short passes while the Watt/Burns side was 31"st. Does that change your thinking about Bud?
Gerry Dulac: Nope. You watch him play?
ryanh: Do you think Bud 5th year option gets picked up he been better then jarvis but he hasnt had a impact the way the team has expected
Gerry Dulac: Agreed on both fronts. Damning him w faint praise
John: Gerry, will Phil Mickelson win another major? asking just for the hell of it. I know you like golf
Gerry Dulac: I hope but don't think he can put 4 good rounds together
JB: I hear a lot of media folks say Mike Mitchell will be gone, but Tomlin likes his vets and does not have a player to take his place. Have you heard any people inside the organization say they will move on from him? Could they find a replacement in the draft for that and ILB, seems a reach to plan on that?
Gerry Dulac: It might not be up to Tomlin
Ray-Gun: I love defense but this entire postseason was abysmal for defense.
Gerry Dulac: Yes
Steeler in Charlotte: Communications issues on defense seemed to happen a lot this year. Just a few key "splash" plays made a big difference, even though the offense was able to overcome a lot of it. How do they fix that next season?
Gerry Dulac: Smarter players
JB: Howe many new starters will there be next year and what positions?
Gerry Dulac: Two -- safety and ILB.
JB: Based on your intel, what are the chances they resign Bell, tag him or move on?
Gerry Dulac: I'd say sign him, unless the would-be-rapper RB pulls another not-so-smart move and declines

David B: Do you think we go ILB or Safety first round?
Gerry Dulac: ILB is the target
JB: Do the Steelers keep Vance McDonald, release him or draft a new tight end?
Gerry Dulac: No, they really like him. And so do I. He changes their draft strategy
JB: Sorry save all my questions for you, but I feel you give the most reliable intel. Sorry Ed. :) Any idea who they will look at to replace Lake?
Gerry Dulac: I dont, not right now
Zack: Thoughts on drafting an OLB with Bud not producing quality sacks.
Gerry Dulac: I think they rely on him one more year. That's it
JerseySteel: Hi Gerry - it seems like there is a better crop of free agent safety's than ILBs. Sign a free agent S and draft a couple of ILBs as the plan?
Gerry Dulac: I think it will be the opposite
Brian: fwiw- I talked with a player. Was in the steeler camp also in two other camps. Had good things to say about Tomlin. Said he was EVERYWHERE always involved in all facets. said in other places you never saw the head coach!
Gerry Dulac: He is everywhere. Watches all facets
Josh: You disagreed with my prior comment regarding Bell, but there has to be a price at which you would agree with signing him. What is it? If he were willing to sign at $12 million a year (a lot front loaded so different than last year), what about then?
Gerry Dulac: Sure
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're out of time. Thanx for all the questions






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.