Gerry Dulac: OK lets get our chat started kids...

Eddie G: Just read "Bradshaw's half baked" comments... While I agree he is off base saying Haley's play calling was great... he is 100% correct that Haley's offense didn't give up 45 points to the Jags. The defense is broken. Why aren't Tomlin and the defensive coaches held accountable. Haley was, and his offense scored 42 points.

Gerry Dulac: I can't argue with you or him, Eddie. That no defensive coach was held accountable, when they know fundamentals were part of the problem, is terribly surprising (and inexcusable) to me.

Kyle: Is this years defensive performance combined with the fact they only play the base 3-4 35% of the time an indicator that the game has passed the 3-4 defense by and time to change?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: No, I don't think so. Ask any of the people who run or built the 3-4 defense, it is predicated on the linebackers. And right now the Steelers LB aren't a strong unit, not without Shazier.

Skerns: Chances the Steelers bring in a free agent Nose Tackle and or draft one with a top 3 draft pick. Javon Hargrave needs pushed I think. What say you?

Gerry Dulac: None. There is nothing wrong with Hargrave.

JJ: I know that a win is a win, and 13 out of 16, on the surface, certainly seems impressive. (Every team would love that). However, considering that 2 of those wins came against an 0 - 16 team, and only by 3 and 4 points, Lions only by 5, Colts (w/o Andrew Luck) only by 3, Packers (w/o Aaron Rogers) only by 3, and Bengals only by 3, (that's 6 of the 13), was our presumably high powered offense really an under achiever ?

Gerry Dulac: I think your first line would suffice for the answer. You can do that with EVERY team in the league. At the end, you count em up. That's ALL that matters.

Advertise with us

vut5686: Gerry, local writers seem to give Tomlin a pass on his support of defensive coaches. If the same management drafts players going forward and coaches them as they have in the past, how can we get better? There does seem to be agreement the defense is the problem.

Gerry Dulac: Part of it is the players. Look, I don't agree the Steelers lack talent on defense or they have to drastically change what they do, including switch to a 4-3. They were, I'll poin t up, the fifth-best defense in the league, which means (in case you're not counting), they were 26 other defenses who were worse than the Steelers. You just don't happen to see them on a weekly basis or read about it on a daily basis.

sprouts: If I have a better roster than another coach, that doesn't necessarily make me a better coach. I'm a Tomlin fan, and don't think coaches should be fired all the time, but there is always another Cowher or Tomlin out there... coaches nobody knew until the Steelers hired them. I'm not discounting the value he brings, but he has to improve his management of details and the focus of his players and his staff. Just saying he went 13-3, who else would you hire, is not sufficient.

Gerry Dulac: The point you are missing in your argument is that the Steelers were the ones who "discovered" Cowher and Tomlin (coaches nobody knew, to use your verbiage). So it would follow then that those same Steelers are the ones who are qualified to evaluate whether Tomlin is a good coach or not. Agreed? So, in this instance, it apparently is sufficient to them, the ones who are imminently qualified to discover and assess. Right?

sprouts: Who are some of your favorite writers in other NFL cities?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Grossi in Cleveland. Hobson Cincy. Kuharski Tenn. McManamon Clev. Plenty

JR-FL: Gerry, I love Marcus Allen(PSU) as a late 1st round pick for the Steelers. I have seen him rated as a late 1st round and some say 2nd round. I know ILB will be tough to pass up in Round 1, but it is considered a weak draft for ILB this year so I am not sure I would invest a RD 1 pick there. What are your thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: I like Marcus Allen too, but not sure I would pull the trigger on a safety in the first round if I could find an ILB. But I wouldn't argue w the pick at all.

SteeleinSF: Do you see the Steelers having cap issues this year? Anything they can do to regarding Shazier's salary. I definitely think he should paid, but if he is going to be out a few years..8 million is a lot to against the cap.

Gerry Dulac: There is nothing they can do about Shazier's salary. It counts against their cap, regardless if he ever plays again. And, if they sign Bell, it will really hamstring them against the cap, especially if they use the franchise tag on him.

Advertise with us

Guest: Bell's a very good back. Maybe the best. But this offense can be tweaked in its scheme to score points without him ... possible now with Haley gone. Let Bell walk, draft a good back (the draft is reportedly rich in backs this year), and use the money saved to sign some quality free agent safeties and ilb's. If they don't do this, they have 0% chance of getting to another Super Bowl. Agree or disagree?

Gerry Dulac: I don't agree with the latter part. They not only not have a zero chance of getting to the Super Bowl, they have an excellent chance of getting there in 2018. Basically their entire group of starters return. I doubt Mike Mitchell will be back and obviously they have do something about a replacement for Shazier. As for Bell, with the players they have on offensse, I think they can find another back to come in and average more than 3.9 yards per carry and rush for 1,000 yards.

JR-FL: Gerry, What is your gut feeling on Bell? 1. We pay him long term 2. He walks and we use the money to help the defense 3. We tag him one more time

Gerry Dulac: According to Bell, sounds like they want to sign him. I'm not sure that's a good thing.

Fare Whether Fan: What can the Steelers do to fix the secondary? And do you see them signing any big name free agent? It’s been almost a decade or more since we’ve had a competent secondary who all seem to be on the same page and don’t give up big plays. Really thinking it’s coaching/development. Thoughts?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Nope. Did that last year with Joe Haden. Look, they have good young players with Burns, Davis and Cam Sutton, even Brian Allen, at corner. This isn't William Gay, Ross Cockrell and Antwon Blake.

jim: Why is it that Tomlin Colbertand Rooney are unable to admit our defense stinks? It is so frustrating to have such a great offense and to be stuck with the exact same defensive coaches heading into next year! Can you please enlighten me?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure I can to that point

JP: Hi Gerry, which play did the Steelers season fate change more - shazier's injuring tackle or James's catch but non-catch? Agree with Coach Tomlin that they did lose the "moments" this season.

Gerry Dulac: Shazier's injury without a doubt

Advertise with us

ALB: Good morning, Gerry. Are you personally rooting for either team in the Super Bowl? If so, why?

Gerry Dulac: Nope

PJW : With the mega-deal that Smith just signed, do you believe it less likely that Bell returns? While I understand that Smith is a QB, his deal shows how stupid teams are in acquiring players, making it likely that someone will pay Bell $17 mill per year, or so. Steelers indicated they will not franchise him again by my understanding.

Gerry Dulac: I've always maintained I could be an NFL GM when I see the stupidity of some teams who offer contracts such as those.

Dj Cain: Hey Gerry! You think Bell made the statement he made to diffuse a distraction while at the Pro Bowl or do you think he and the Steelers are talking as he stated?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I'll believe when I hear it.

Josh from SoCal: With ILB most likely being their top priority going into the draft, what's their 2nd biggest area of need? I've read a lot stating that it's at FS but would you be surprised if they went after an OLB? Dupree has been thoroughly disappointing thus far and, according to Steelersdepot, had ZERO high quality sacks this last season.

Gerry Dulac: Yes, Dupree has been disappointing, but I think, in an ideal world, they will draft ILB first, S second. Doesn't matter if it's free or strong. They will probably move Sean Davis into Mike Mitchell's spot.

Coachjpat: On defense would you say there is a middle of the field problem? That seems to be the area where teams attached the defense this year: Short, middle and deep

Gerry Dulac: Yes, and the reason is the loss of Shazier.

Advertise with us

Putuporshutup : Hi,Gerry, I love Bell and agree he is best RB in NFL but...The 2 SB teams have good running backs but not great backs. Point is the defense is close to needing a complete overhall and that means money that won't be there if Bell is a Steeler. Fix the D! Really, I am 56 years old and never thought I would see a Steeler defense that can't tackle! Time to start over on D.

Gerry Dulac: I don't think they have to start over. Again, they are not that far away. As I said, they were the fifth best defense in the league. You just dont see the other 27 teams and the problems they have.

Bill: How do the Steelers feel about Haley going to Cleveland?

Gerry Dulac: They shouldn't feel anything. They were the ones who released him.

Al in NJ: Do the Steelers coaches still see Davis and Burns as the defensive starters of the future?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Yep. Why? You had enough of them after 2 years??

Matt: Gerry, how many wideouts we drafting this year? From the look of it now, we have 84,10,19,88 & that’s the list.

Gerry Dulac: They always draft a WR.

Jake: I know it was only 1 game, but I thought Cam Sutton looked very good against New England, with another year of preparation, hopefully injury free during training camp. Can you see the Steelers having an open competition between Sutton and Burns?

Gerry Dulac: Doesn't matter. They need three good CBs anyway for all their sub packages.

Advertise with us

Matt: Everyone wants them to draft cb early but I disagree. You got haden,burns,hilton,sutton,gay,sensabaugh,allen on the roster. How would they get on the field?

Gerry Dulac: They are not drafting a cornerback early, so whoever is intimating that doesn't know what they are talking about

Matt: any chance Spence comes back?

Gerry Dulac: Probably not. If so, strictly a backup.

Jake: The last I've heard about Shazier was that he got feeling back in his legs, that was a few weeks ago. Any more updates?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Not sure who is providing you with info

Bob: did you find it as funny as i did that ben contemplated retirement last year, but this year after he assumed/knew haley would be gone, he said he'd play 3 more years

Gerry Dulac: Chuckle chuckle

chuck: off topic here but what did you think of tiger last weekend?

Gerry Dulac: That he shot 3-under with where he hit it is amazing. His short game stood out most to me. It was very good.

Advertise with us

Brett: The defense isn't nearly as bad as people make it out to be. Shazier going down was HUGE. On runs inside the tackles Steelers allowed 2.90 yards/carry (1st) with Shazier and without him allowed 4.81 yards/carry (31st). Can't overlook how big a difference it made replacing a special talent in Shazier with a guy off the street.

Gerry Dulac: Finally, some common sense. Pay the man

latrobe guy: thinking about L. Bell. The Steelers didn't make it to the Super Bowl with him in 16 & 17, but they did show they could make it to the playoffs without him in 14 & 15. He is replaceable.

Gerry Dulac: Yes he is. So long as you have 7, 84, 19 and that O-line

CoachOCB: Any FA ILBs to fit in the Steelers scheme?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Haven't looked yet

Matt: Do you believe Shazier will be back on the field next year for the Steelers bc he is hinting it on social media. & if he is do they still draft a mlb early?

Gerry Dulac: I think they draft an ILB with their top pick, so long as one with a first-round grade is available.

Jim Francois: Jason Worilds Jarvis Jones Bud Dupree Linebacker scouting could be the issue your thoughts

Gerry Dulac: Jason Worilds looks like Von Miller compared to the other two right now

Advertise with us

Guest: Hi Gerry, How do people keep saying AB is the 'most irreplaceable player' on the Steelers? When Ben got hurt in 2015 with is knee AB was basically invisable for 4 games. Then AB gets hurt against the Pats, the Steelers WIN (It was a catch) without him for 3/4s of that game and THEN torch the Texans. summation it's all 7 or nothing.

Gerry Dulac: Again, people who say that don't know what they are talking about. It is very simple -- 7 most irreplaceable on offense, 50 most irreplaceable on defense. End of discussion

Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, that's all the time we have today. See you next week