Gerry Dulac: OK lets get our chat started. I see bunch of questions already....

JC : Gerry, A lot has been said of the lack of discipline in multiple areas this year. How does this compare with previous years?

Gerry Dulac: I think it's probably the same, just some made more public this time. That happens after a frustrating end to the season.

Moose: Were you surprised at all about Tomlin's lack of discipline when all of this stuff came to light? Things such as missing practices, meetings, Harrison behavior, etc?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think some were more egregious than in the past, but your question was am I surprised there was no discipline for their behavior. No, and you can interpret that any way you choose.

JC : Gerry, Do you think this current defensive coaching staff can get the Steeler D back on top? I say no they have had a few years and not much changed. Hopefully FO can enlighten Tomlin something has to change.

Gerry Dulac: And he doesn't want to make any changes on the defensive side of the ball...???

mrbig: Do you think Ben said, "I'll play 3 more years.. if you lose Haley"?

Gerry Dulac: That is a case of making any assumption you want and you might not be wrong

Advertise with us

mrbig: Isn't it ironic they they let LeBeau go so they could start younger players on d and now the younger players are blowing assignments?

Gerry Dulac: Younger doesn't always mean smarter

Guest: The once proud Steelers are become the joke of the league. Joe Starkey asks which Steeler will be playing for the Patriots in next year's Super Bowl and gives odds that it will probably be Martavis Bryant. Last year it was Blount; this year it will be Harrison. Has Tomlin lost control or did he never really have any control? I don't think the old man Rooney would have put up with Tomlin. Yes, there are worse coaches; but I think there are at least 10 better ones! Certainly there are none that are a greater embarrassment.

Gerry Dulac: I would venture to say the league does not consider the Steelers a joke. If so, they should all hire jesters

mrbig: Haley got 42 points in the playoffs, now he's gone.... is there a rift with him & Ben or not? If your o coordinator gets 42 against a great defense, maybe Ben should suck it up?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Maybe you're right

Moose: 2018 we face Ryan, Newton, Rivers, Brady, Brees, Carr, Winston, and the Jags. Little different than Keenum, Brissett, Savage, Hundley, and Kizer x2. Would you pick the over or under for a 10 win season with Bell playing.

Gerry Dulac: With or without. And haven't you learned by now injuries happen.

Jax: Gerry, If the Steelers franchise Bell how will this impact their cap for 2018? Mitchell and Dupree look like good candidates to go.

Gerry Dulac: Of course it will. It will count $14.5 million roughly. Mitchell is a given at $8 mill cap hit.

Advertise with us

Max: Have you ever written "Tomlin outcoached [coach's name] in such and such game"?

Gerry Dulac: Probably somewhere in those 13 wins this season. Or the 26 over the past two years. Or the 116 during his tenure. I imagine so.

NPG2003: Gerry, If Bell and the Steelers cannot workout a multi-year contract, which RB in the 2018 draft would be ideal to replace Bell's production? Any RBs stick out in your mind?

Gerry Dulac: I haven't studied the draft yet, Will do that at the combine and what people are saying. But, to me, the Steelers could find several RBs in the draft who they could plug in that offense and behind that line and still win 13 games.

Moose: There is no I in Team, but there is a M and an E. Too many "me" players allowed to do too many "me" things this year without consequences. Tomlin seems stubborn, will he change his coaching style as far as discipline?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: He might have to because that is today's athlete. Trust me, their behavior and attitude sickens players from the past, and I'm not talking the 70s, 80s, or 90s. I mean the recent past, like since Ben has been here. Not all of them, but enough of them.

Tprod: Gerry, do the Steelers need to invest in a true zero technique nose tackle for games against the Jags, Ravens and other teams that see a weakness up the middle of the Steeler defense?

Gerry Dulac: They have one -- Hargrave. They just don't employ him enough. They didn't as much as they would have liked against Jax because he had a lower-back injury and wasn't very effective because of it. But they did use a lot of 3-man fronts vs Jags and it didn't matter. They got blown off the line of scrimmage, all of em

Tprod: Gerry, how serious were the injuries to Tuitt and Hargrove? Expected a tough battle in the trenches, but not the outright dominance of the Jag’s O-line.

Gerry Dulac: Enough that it mattered. Like I said, Hargrave's lower back madwe it difficult for him to play. And Tuitt hyper-extended his elbow in practice, effectively making him a one-arm player. Still, they get blown off the ball, very simple. No excuses

Advertise with us

BishkekSteeler: Another season wiped out by a poor finish. Continuity sometimes gets old. What do the Steelers do to put an end to the collapse witnessed over the last 2 years?

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't call getting to the AFC title game and losing to Brady in NE last year a collapse. I would call the end to this season frustrating, disappointing and unexpected.

Troy: Hi Gerry! After losing to Green Bay in our last Super Bowl, the 're-build' of the defense began. Well that's been almost a decade ago...and our defense is basically worse. Are you as depressed as I am?

Gerry Dulac: No

Doug in Raleigh: Gerry, do you have any sense of what the team will do with Bell, franchise him again, or let him walk and use the money elsewhere (I'm assuming Bell will turn down a long term as not sufficient)? Seems like no matter what they do it will be the wrong thing.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't sign him, and I think they are starting to lean in that direction. I wouldn't be shocked if they didn't franchise him, given his suspensions, camp holdout (which will happen again) and social-media nonsense. In fact, I'd be in favor of it. I'd put the exclusive tag on him and if someone offered two No. 1 picks, I'd get the party room ready.

BishkekSteeler: Hello Gerry, thanks for the chats and your expertise on the Steelers. I've been a fan since 64 and don't think I've seen as much circus around the team as has occurred this year. With the CBA is it just that the team has less control over the players or is social media the root of the immaturity that seems to be pervasive throughout the league?

Gerry Dulac: The latter is the case. That is today's athlete and, to me, it's the number 1 reason the fans are turned off. It's not the game. Oh the inconsistency of the officiating is annoying. But it doesn't cause the same distaste as the nonsense of the player on social media and in the game. Immaturity is a good word, but not strong enough

Tprod: Gerry, How much did the loss of Shazier and his adjustments to the defensive calls affect the defense?

Gerry Dulac: 150 percent, and don't discount that!!! They know it and what are they supposed to do when it happens in December? Have another Shazier on the bench to replace him?

Advertise with us

Zack B: Sign and trade, or just not resign Bell, cut Mitchell. Can use saved money to sign: a released Demarco Murray, Demario Davis, and Kenny Vacarro. Can draft the Alabama ILB in rd 1, rb in middle rounds. Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Too many thoughts for me. Mitchell will be gone. You have heard my feelings on Bell. I think they will sign an ILB in free agency and draft one on the first round.

Jonny Quest: Gerry - does no changes to the defensive coaching staff mean the Steelers feel there can be no improvement in the coaching and the weaknesses in the defense are all player related? If so, does that portend a large number of defensive player changes before next season, or just more of the same and hope for the best?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think enough people understand or begin to comprehend what the loss of Shazier did to that defense. It was fifth in the league overall, fifth against the pass. So just tell youself there were 27 other teams who gave up more yards than and a lot more points than the Steelers.

Emilio: As the defensive coordinator for the Vikings Mike Tomlin had the worst ranked defense against the pass in 2006. Now that he is so involved in the defense, what do you think he has learned since then that can give us hope for 2018 season?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: To not be last against the pass. They were 5th in the league this year.

Gerry Dulac: Also, what you don't mention is I think they were No. 1 against the run and very close to the top overall.

Ralph: When will coaches learn not to go into the not to lose mode when leading the Patriots in the fourth quarter? Run,run short pass Punt. does not work.

Gerry Dulac: I'll tell them

Eddie G: Thanks for the chat Gerry. So, we are stuck with Tomlin for one more season. But, if we have another failure, especially on the defensive side of the ball, in the playoffs, do you think they will finally realize it isn't going to get any better and fire Tomlin?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think you will be "stuck" with him longer than that, but who knows. Tampa Bay fired Tony Dungy in 2001 because he kept losing in the postseason

Shay: Gerry, what is your take regarding no defensive coaching changes? Does this have anything to do with Tomlin allegedly taking on a greater role in the defensive meetings? Thank you

Gerry Dulac: Tomlin has been taking a greater role in defensive meetings the past 2-3 years. Nonethless, I'm surprised one def coach hasn't been let go.

Duke from Jersey: Fan bases, if not teams (OAK, SF), are lining up for Bell's services. Do you see him calling anyplace but Heinz Field home next year?

Gerry Dulac: I could

Advertise with us

Skip: Should be an easy transition to Fichtner as OC...let Ben call his own plays and run a lot of no huddle?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think that's happening

Duke from Jersey: Gerry, the difference that a Tom Coughlin made in Jacksonville by imposing discipline on the organization is something that a copycat league should want to emulate. Could you see the Steelers adding a head of football ops in a similar capacity?

Gerry Dulac: They have one -- Kevin Colbert. Let's just hold off on Jacksonville. One winning season should be compared to decades of success. Like Oakland this year, let's see them do it again. And again. OK???

greg in lewisville, texas: Gerry, What do you think the Steelers do with Stevan Ridley? thanx

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Bye bye probably

Gerry Dulac: All failures go back to the head coach. Therefore, all successes go back to the head coach. Let me enlighten y'all, you're not going to win the Super Bowl, or even go to the Super Bowl, every year. Unless you're Tom Brady of course

Todd - Three Rivers, Michigan: Is Faneca the best guard in Steelers history? Do you think he will get in? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: Probably. And yes

JerseySteel: Hi Gerry - are the headaches the LeVeon Bell brings (holdout, contract demands, skipping meeting before playoff game) worth franchising him again or let him walk/draft a RB?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Nope

Florak: Why are you/ed and other Steeler writers always such a Tomlin homer? Always pointing to his record as your only defense? Every year Tomlin himself is responsible for 2 to 3 LOSSES costing them either a bye, division championship, or a playoff appearance due to his poor in game management, failure to make adjustments, drama, or the team is not ready to play against inferior opponents. These are Tomlin traits year in and year out. Tomlin should have 30 more wins on his record and 2 or 3 more SB appearances if he was as good as you think. Fittipaldo is the only writer in Pitt willing to say what many fans think. And before you say who should be the coach... Why not Munchak?

Gerry Dulac: I'll tell Ray

Ryno: I can't imagine Bell sitting out next season if the Steelers tag him again, but if he would, does that mean the Steelers would have something like 14 million dollars that they would not be allowed to spend on other players, or could they spend that on other players because of Bell not being on the team, but being tagged?

Gerry Dulac: No, because if he doesn't sign the tender, he isn't under contract. So there is no $14.5 million spent. They can spend it other ways if they choose

Advertise with us

008: Gerry, William Gay at week 18 blows assignment for 40 yard Splash play. Who's blame?

Gerry Dulac: You answered your own question. Plus, 98 wasn't where he was supposed to be on that play

Ryno: What happens with Ryan Shazier's salary next season if he is unable to play? Will the Steelers still have to pay him, will they put him on some type of injured list, or will they give him some kind of financial settlement and release him?

Gerry Dulac: They still have to pay him and he still counts against the cap, just as if he had a torn ACL or shoulder surgery and missed the season.

Ryno: Gerry, is it possible that the Steelers were not playing James Harrison BECAUSE of him sleeping during meetings or going home as soon as he found out he was inactive for a game? Or did he start doing that stuff AFTER the Steelers decided to never play him? After seeing him play for New England, I can't imagine why the Steelers were not getting him on the field. He sure looks like he is still able to play.

Gerry Dulac: No. After. That is, if you want to believe a couple players

Diggermc: Low first round draft picks generally need to be developed. Were Jones, DuPree and Burns bad picks or are they just not being developed by poor position coaches?

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't put Burns in that category, not at all

Guest: Gerry, should the Steelers cut Mike Mitchell and will they cut him?

Gerry Dulac: Yes and yes

mtsteel: Hi Gerry, thanks for the chat. So after watching the many defensive breakdowns and "lack of communication" this season, would it be a stretch for Art Rooney to tell Tomlin "hey why dont we make a change or 2 on your defensive staff? Doesn't appear to be a crazy idea. What say you? Thank you sir

Gerry Dulac: I say you're right

NPG2003: Gerry, I've read and heard more than a few reasons why the Steelers should NOT offer Le'Veon a high salary long-term deal, but could you offer reasons why the Steelers SHOULD?

Gerry Dulac: Nope.

TXSTEELER : Doubt you’ll respond but last week you were incredibly rude and short (without answering the question) when I asked a simple question about how much cap room they had and if it was possible they could create enough space to sign an ILB or S. That’s exactly all I asked but you shockingly seemed to think I was criticizing the team’s past handling of cap issues from that. Want to try to answer this legit question again?

Gerry Dulac: I didn't think you were criticizing, all I was saying was to relax, they know what they're doing. Recent history would suggest that. They are the best at keeping their core players and stars intact. They will do what's necessary again. And I'm not short. I'm 6-2

lsb: Good afternoon Gerry, After it has been revealed that Mike Tomlin has been very hands on with regard to defensive play calling in games and taking charge during defensive team meetings, do you believe that he is saving face by not replacing any of the defensive staff ? His DNA is so deeply embedded in the defence that he would be forced to publicly look into his own failings if he were to now fire any of the defensive coaches ?

Gerry Dulac: If fundamentals and blown assignments are at the root of the problem, which in many cases they are, they hire fundamental assistant coaches to correct the problem. Do not keep coaches who have no background in coaching.

Moose: Why wouldn't we put the non exclusive tag on Bell? We would have the opt to match any offers, and if we didn't, we would get 2 first rounders. Teams have given up more, I.E. Hershel Walker, Ricky Williams, etc...

Gerry Dulac: Bingo

Moose: Why not try and move Sutton to FS? Maybe even Allen who is 6'3" and 215#? Keep Haden and Burns as your corners. Mitchell is gone next year if not this one.

Gerry Dulac: Allen is the prototypical corner, so I wouldn't do that. But some scouts thought Sutton could play safety in the NFL. That's not far-fetched. I think you will see the Steelers move Sean Davis to Mitchell's spot next season. He has much better range than 23.

Gerry Dulac: Well, that's all the time we have today kids. Thanx for the questions.