
Gerry Dulac: Hey kids, we will be starting our chat in less than 20 min so get those questions ready...though I see you already have.
Gerry Dulac: OK, let's get our chat started....Go!!
Guest: Hey Gerry, I'll be attending the divisional game and it will be my first time in Pittsburgh, any good places to eat that you recommend
Gerry Dulac: Close to stadium is Hyde Park Grille, Burgatory and Jerome Bettis Grille. Downtown is Ruth Chris, Eddie Merlots, Eddie V's, Meat & Potatoes, Capital Grille, Lydia's. All very good.
B in Va: Can you believe the Bungals Gave Marvin Lewis a contract extension??? Thats a welcome headscratcher if you ask me
Gerry Dulac: Seven playoff appearances. This isn't Jeff Fisher stuff here.
Read More
eMo: Hey Gerry. When are people going to realize the Steelers are frauds and so is their coach? They may be 13-3 but they didnt play anyone good.
Gerry Dulac: You will see later in this chat where a questioner wants to know why Ed and I sometimes treat our "customers" with sarcasm and disdain. This is a perfect example.
SteelersFaninNYC: Criticism of Mike Tomlin often seems irrational and even...something much worse. What legit criticisms, if any, do you have of MT heading into the playoffs?
Gerry Dulac: I got none. He is 22-4 in the past 26 games, has the best record in the NFL this season amid a lot of drama. Hard to nitpick
JJ: Is Haley's and Roethlisberger's relationship as bad as people say? Results are great but people hate him. Why?
Gerry Dulac: Hate is a strong word. I will remind you the players didn't exactly love Lombardi and Noll when they played for them, either
greg in lewisville, texas: Jerry, Any idea what the status is of James Conner for the play-offs?
Gerry Dulac: He is on IR and done for the season
Ben Roethlisberger talks about playoff preparation
Ralph: Do you think coach Tomlin will learn to live in his fears and take the points. Three points are better than none early in a game.
Gerry Dulac: I agree
NPG2003: Gerry, Even though the Steelers won't stand in the way of Munchak leaving for a HC position elsewhere, would they sweeten the pot to get him to stay? (He is one hell of a line coach- we NEED him!)
Gerry Dulac: Of course not. He has a chance to be a head coach again. They would NEVER deprive a person of that opportunity. Plus, they could "sweeten" any pot for an assistant to match a head coach's deal.
Guest: I think Tomlin really screwed the pooch in alienating James Harrison by not giving him the playing time he was promised and merited. His first game for the Cheatriots showed he still has it (2 sacks), and they even dropped him into pass coverage! Tomlin hasn't shied away from playing has-beens or never-will-bes (I'll withhold names to spare them embarassment). This treatment of an all-time Steeler great will bite him if it comes to another AFC championship game!
Gerry Dulac: That's what everyone fears. He looked good in his first game with NE
NPG2003: Based on information you have available, do you think we will see the dynamic Antonio Brown that we know and love in 2 weeks, or will we see a slower, hobbled version of AB in the playoffs?
Gerry Dulac: Trust me, if he is hobbled and slower, you won't see him because he won't be playing
NPG2003: Ed, what's your 5 keys to the Steelers getting to the AFC championship game?
Gerry Dulac: I
Gerry Dulac: l'll ask Ed
SMF: Thanks for the great chats Gerry; Curious about the Steeler luck in getting J2S2. Was that an inside job from Lynne Swann? He was never ranked that high on the draft boards. Fans should also credit whoever found AV and Bos--two Pro Bowlers off the street as well.
Gerry Dulac: No, Lynn Swann had nothing to do with it. And JuJu was ranked as a second-round pick and that's where the Steelers got him. Fans tend to remember draft picks who failed. But they don't always consider the street pickups such as Villanueva and Boswell.
jIM: This is not meant for the chat, I'm not into being a public scold. I am 76 years old and been a Steeler and PG fan since high school and season ticket holder since 1973. I enjoy your articles in the paper, but have an issue with the chats. The people who participate in these are fans, although some have a limited knowledge of the game. I don't think that your sarcastic and insulting answers to some of their questions are becoming. It is obvious that neither you or Ed enjoy these chats and would be doing something else, but these people are your "customers" and should not be treated rudely. Thanks for reading (If you still are).
Gerry Dulac: Jim, I read the whole thing and this is my favorite question of the year. The "limited knowledge" part I get, but there is a difference between limited knowledge and unfair, scathing, misinformed, smart-aleck (would like to use another word) and sometimes crude questions based on gossip or social media diatribe. See above example, for proof. You should see some of the questions we don't answer. In any event, thanx for reading and participating. And I never mind a public scold.
SteelyD: James Harrison's debut vs. Jets. Proof he's "still got it" or taking advantage of a bad team with a bad QB?
Gerry Dulac: We will have to wait and see. What I noticed most were the quick, textbook open-field tackles.
SteelyD: Cam Sutton or Will Gay as dime back in playoffs?
Gerry Dulac: Hopefully Cam Sutton
SteelyD: I'm more worried about Harrison's intel than performance. In theory is there anything the Pats could get from him that they couldn't get from film? (Belichick's "advanced" film/scouting methods notwithstanding).
Gerry Dulac: Haha. I think the intel will be Harrison's instincts in knowing what certain players might do in a given situation. I'm not sure there is much he can impart that will make a major difference
SB or Bust: Munchak interested in Arizona job? Better than 50/50 chance he is offered it?
Gerry Dulac: Of course he's interested. I don't know the level of Ariz's interest.
Ike Steelheart: Happy New Year Gerry! If Munchak becomes the new HC of Arizona, what about Faneca as the new OL coach of The Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: Gopd suggestion. He has spent the past several training camps working with the players.
SteelyD: If Munchak goes is there anyone that comes to mind as a replacement? Externally, or an internal "Butler" to his "LeBeau?"
Gerry Dulac: I would imagine they would go outside. See above perhaps
Ike Steelheart: Gerry, How different is for a 3-4 DL to play a 4-3 defense? Does he need to be faster/bigger? Once you play 3-4 you can't play 4-3? My question regarding Cam Heyward not making the Pro Bowl.
Gerry Dulac: It's a disgrace that a 3-4 end who has done what Heyward has done is not in the Pro Bowl. He plays the equivalent of a defensive tackle, and no defensive tackle had more sacks than 97 (12). Closest was Geno Atkins w 9. To answer your question, a 4-3 defensive end has to lighter so he is quicker
Bince: Good Morning Gerry, How do you view Harrison's performance up here in NE? Proof that he's still got it or just the right circumstance playing late against a weak team that had given up?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think Kelvin Beachum was giving up
Nathanael Hirt: Will Antonio Brown be back for the Playoffs
Gerry Dulac: There's a good chance, especially by AFC title game if they get that far
Ike Steelheart: Hey Gerry, Which college player(s) from the ones that played on Monday would you like him/them to become a Steeler?
Gerry Dulac: The RB (No. 24) from Oklahoma in a couple years
jim: What are the odds we move on from Todd Haley after the season? Does it depend on of we win the SB?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the odds are very good. You have a problem with that offense that produced the No. 1 receiver, would have been the No. 1 RB and the No. 2 QB in the league?
T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Hubbard clearly had problems with the shotgun snap. Why not bring Jones to the line of scrimmage at that point? Not just thinking about Cleveland; if Finney stays hurt and something happens to Pouncey, could be a playoff issue.
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't worry about the third team center and his snaps.
SteeltownSmackdown: I know its secondary to living a normal productive life wherein he can still walk, but do you put Shazier's chances of playing football again at 0%
Gerry Dulac: I can't answer that. Idk
Buzz: Morning Gerry, I know QB is a hot topic. In reality is it even possible, where the Steelers Draft position is, to get Ben's replacement this Draft?
Gerry Dulac: For one of the "marquee" QBs, no, but you never know where a team will find one. Brady was 6th round, Montana was 3rd round, Favre was 2nd round. I realize those are exceptions, but you never know.
Ike Steelheart: Hey Gerry, I like the attitude of the Steelers about resting players sending the message that is Ok to play at NE and the words of Ben about wanting to play vs JAX. Let's face the best teams in order to be champions, agree?
Gerry Dulac: With ya. Eventually you have to play and beat the best.
Tucson: You look at all of the weekly awards that JuJu has won so far this year (Offensive player of the week, Special teams player of the week) and then Steelers rookie of the year. Is he really that good and what can we expect next year?
Gerry Dulac: I think you answered your own question.
Thiago: Do you see they moving on from Mitchell and Davis after this season? Davis has kinda underachieved and Mitchell's not a gamechanger at safety and hes aging
Gerry Dulac: You're not watching the same game if you think Sean Davis is a problem
SteeltownSmackdown: Do the Jags really think their 5 int performance was anything but anomaly? If they make it to the divisional round vs. Pitt what do you think the line would be? Pitt - 3.5?
Gerry Dulac: It will be bigger than that -- 6 to 7 for sure
jim: I though Jesse James has had a pretty good season, any idea why the coaches seem to like McDonald more? I think James's hands are better.
Gerry Dulac: What they like about McDonald is his athleticism and ability to run. Watch his routes, they are more on the move and down than the seams than James. But Jesse James has been more than dependable and rarely drops a pass.
RiverRat: Please give me your assessment of Bud Dupree. I have seen some good plays recently, but very little this season. Seems to be out of position on run plays all the time, but of course, it is not like I study game film. He does seem lost at times. What is the truth about Bud?
Gerry Dulac: I think your assessment is not far off. Too many times he is not a factor at all, especially against the run. If QBs took seven-step drops like the old days, he'd have more sacks because of the wide arc he takes on pass rush. But they don't
SteeltownSmackdown: How many of the secondary's deficiencies against Cleveland were due to free-lancing (in hopes of breaking the sack record) and how many were a result of horrible safety play?
Gerry Dulac: I am not dismissing their big-play gaffes, which have been occurring w regularity, but it was Cleveland in a meaningless game
Mtsteel: Hi Gerry, Happy New year. Do you feel the poor play by the secondary Sunday was due to the "relaxed attitude" for that game or just a continuous issue that will hurt us again going forward? Thank you sir
Gerry Dulac: See above answer. But it is something they can't allow to keep happening.
Thiago: I'd say Shazier is critical to beat the Pats, without him KB cant play man coverage against Gronk, davis got toasted. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: You can't lament not having Shazier because nothing is going to change. And, until that final drive, I thought Davis did OK against Gronk. But there is no question they are going to have to do more against him, especially in the second half
ALB: Todd Haley injured in an altercation almost a year to the day after Joey Porter was arrested. Should Steeler coaches stay out of bars after games?
Gerry Dulac: That's a good starting point...
jim: I think Tomlin was 100% justified in resting some starters. I am of the opinion that a couple of good hard practices will shake the rust off, thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: He was justified, for sure, good move. But you don't have to worry about hard practices. There is no such thing this time of year, or really at any point once the regular season starts.

Bill Frazier: Terrell Watson proved himself in preseason that he is the real deal and could carry the offense if Bell is out, and is a short yardage machine as well for tough yardage in red zone. Why didn't he get to fill Conor's spot?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think he ever proved he could carry the offseason. But I was surprised they didn't re-sign him when Conner was injured. However, after seeing Ridley run against the Browns, I can see why they did what they did
Damien from Port Arthur Tx: If a mean streak is all big Dan needs why can't he just move in with coach Porter?
Gerry Dulac: Haha. He will be moving out before he moves in.
RiverRat: Other than Bell, does the Steelers have any big contracts to sign next year?
Gerry Dulac: Not really
TXSTEELER : Why is everyone losing their minds about 92 signing with NE & them getting Pittsburg’s signs/tendencies/game plan? 1) Steelers can easily change signs/approach & they probably do so frequently anyway 2) All this can already be seen/heard and thus deciphered on video 3) 92 likely doesn’t know the offensive side well 4) Brady doesn’t need the help?
Gerry Dulac: Right on all accounts
jim: Do you think the NFL will ever admit that the Steelers got jobbed in the Pats game and changed the playoffs. There was NO indisputable evidence to overturn, NONE.
Gerry Dulac: No
Gerry Dulac: That's all the time we have today, kids. See you next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.