Let’s go through a possible scenario over the next three months or so.
The Steelers pick up steam, finish with the AFC’s No. 1 playoff seed, sweep both postseason games at home, advance to the Super Bowl and win it.
One month later, after much soul-searching, Ben Roethlisberger announces his retirement on his 36th birthday. It at least gives the Steelers free agency and the draft to pursue his replacement.
Who would be their quarterback for the 2018 season?
It says here, their starter would be Landry Jones. Stop with all your moaning and your disbelief. There is no other good alternative.
They could sign a free agent quarterback such as Kirk Cousins, 30 next season, or Drew Brees, who turns 39 in January. Damaged goods Sam Bradford or Teddy Bridgewater anyone? There is Josh McCown, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Derek Anderson, Scott Tolzien and many more veteran quarterbacks available as free agents in 2018.
Read More
Any of them get your blood pumping?
There’s always the trade route, and Kansas City’s Alex Smith could be available. He turns 34 next May and is signed through next season with a $10.8 million salary.
There’s Colin Kaepernick, Johnny Manziel and Robert Griffin III who can be had. The Houston Texans last week released Matt McGloin.
Of all those, Cousins might be the only good alternative. He will have suitors lined up in March with wheelbarrows full of cash, and he’s no Roethlisberger.
In case you haven’t noticed, many NFL teams will look for quarterbacks next year. There aren’t enough good ones to go around, which is why those who can chew gum and throw a forward pass at the same time keep circulating from team to team. Ask the Cleveland Browns what it’s like to find a decent quarterback; they’ve failed at it for nearly 20 years.
There always is the draft, and 2018 is supposed to be good for quarterbacks. Only the Steelers can’t participate in that strong group. Even if the Steelers don’t win the Super Bowl, they’re going to draft near the bottom, and by the time their turn comes around, the quarterback talent is going to be picked dry.
Here are some of the best college prospects at quarterback for 2018, according to NFL Draft Scout: Sam Darnold of Southern Cal, Mason Rudolph of Oklahoma State, Josh Rosen of UCLA, Lamar Jackson of Louisville, Ryan Finley of North Carolina State and Baker Mayfield of Oklahoma.
Unless the Steelers make a bold move to jump high in the draft, they’re not sniffing any of them.
Ben Roethlisberger talks about Dick LeBeau
Not all of good quarterbacks go high, though. Dan Marino went 27th, Boomer Esiason in the second round and Joe Montana at the end of the third. Dak Prescott was a fourth-round pick. Tom Brady went in the sixth round. Ummm, Neil O’Donnell and Bubby Brister were third-round choices.
You can get lucky late in the first round or even in later rounds; it just doesn’t happen much. Plus, would, say a rookie drafted in the third round, come in and start for the Steelers in 2018?
Remember that they drafted a quarterback in the fourth round last year. Josh Dobbs did not look like a future starter in training camp or preseason games, but who knows? The Steelers also won’t stop there. If Roethlisberger retires, they will find another quarterback somewhere, maybe the draft, maybe a veteran pickup.
Whoever they find this side of Cousins, Landry Jones still is odds-on favorite to start for them next season sans Roethlisberger.
And what if Roethlisberger does not retire and returns to play in 2018, should they still draft an heir apparent?
That scenario may even be more difficult for them to add a quarterback. The same circumstances would exist for them in the draft — picking late, etc. — but they no longer would look to sign a veteran. They still would not have a shot at one of the top quarterbacks, and anyone they would draft would have to replace either Jones or Dobbs on the roster, or not make it at all.
The Steelers have had two great quarterbacks since the dawn of the 1970s: Terry Bradshaw, drafted first overall, and Roethlisberger, drafted 11th. They passed on another to their decades-long regret, Marino. O’Donnell is the only other quarterback who started for them in a Super Bowl, and he left as a free agent a month later.
The list of NFL teams who want quarterbacks next season are too numerous to mention. Add the New York Giants to the group. They reportedly will be looking for the heir apparent to Eli Manning, who like Roethlisberger came via the 2004 draft and has two Super Bowl rings. The Giants have one big advantage over the Steelers in their search for their next starting quarterback — they have tanked the season at 1-8 and are looking at a top three draft pick.
Among other teams desperate for their next starting quarterback are Cleveland, Denver, Arizona, Buffalo, Washington (if Cousins leaves as expected), New Orleans and the New York Jets. You might be able to add Indianapolis if the Colts don’t want to bank on Andrew Luck’s shoulder returning to form, Baltimore if Joe Flacco’s poor season and back problems persist, and Jacksonville, where Blake Bortles is not loved.
Don’t rule out the New England Patriots, who dealt away both backup quarterbacks this year and where Brian Hoyer does not appear to be the heir apparent to 40-year-old Tom Brady. The Green Bay Packers also have a history of finding their next quarterback while their current one is still playing well; Aaron Rodgers turns 34 next year.
The bottom line: It’s not a good time for the Steelers to find their next starting quarterback, whether Roethlisberger returns or retires. Landry Jones would appear to be their option if he does.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.