As Le’Veon Bell begins his assault on the 2017 season, as he piles up statistics rarely matched in the history of the game and collects accolades as the best halfback in the NFL, the reasonable question must be asked: Could he be the best running back in Steelers’ history?
It may be blasphemous merely to ask because of the accomplishments of two Pro Football Hall of Fame backs who put their considerable stamps on the franchise, Franco Harris and Jerome Bettis.
Harris played 12 seasons for the Steelers, Bettis 10. Bell has played four, none of which he was able to go wire to wire without being derailed by two suspensions and four injuries.
Nevertheless, Bell has gathered impressive statistics in a short time. Among them:
• Single-game team rushing records in the regular season (236) and top two in the postseason in consecutive weeks (167 vs. Miami and 170 vs. Kansas City a season ago).
• The top two team receiving seasons for a back (83 and 75 catches), shattering the old mark of 51.
Read More
• A 157-yards-per-game average from scrimmage in 2016, the third-highest in NFL history.
• A Steelers record 357 yards rushing in the 2016 postseason.
• Fastest in NFL history to reach 3,000 yards rushing and 1,500 receiving.
There is much more, but now we bring on our panel of experts with their opinions about Le’Veon Bell regarding his ability, his accomplishments, his place in history and what the future might hold.
Bell ended his “holdout” and signed his one-year, $12.12 million franchise tag Monday. Will he be physically and mentally ready to start this season at full capacity when the Steelers open in Cleveland? Will he have longevity as his carries and catches add up and take their toll?
Our three experts were elected to the Steelers inaugural Hall of Honor class:
Dick Hoak, a halfback with the Steelers for 10 seasons who then coached their running backs for 35 more until his retirement after the 2006 season; linebacker Jack Ham, a six-time All-Pro with four Super Bowl rings and a gold coat from Canton, and Bettis, who is sixth on the NFL’s all-time rushing list and is also in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Bettis’ take
“He’s an incredible football player. I spent a little time with him, talked football, talked running and got a chance to see how he thinks and he thinks the correct way as a running back. I always felt as a running back my biggest and best attribute was my brain and how I approached running the football. And I felt I could manage myself around the football field regardless of my speed and that kind of thing. Well, he thinks the same way but he’s a lot faster than I was. It’s a chess game being played so he’s always 1-2-3 steps ahead, which will serve him well as he gets older and he gets craftier.
“So I just think the sky is the limit for him and his ability.”
Is he worth the money, whether it is what the Steelers will pay him this year or what Bell wants to be paid?
“Oh, he’s definitely worth the money,” Bettis said. “You have to look at it from a defensive perspective. And so here’s the question: Do defenses work to defend against him? For instance, when I was playing, defenses had to come into the game saying we’ve got to stop 36. All right? So with that comes value. So now defenses say, we’re willing to go one on one on the outside because we have to make sure we stop 36.
“Well, guess what? That takes a lot of pressure off your wide receivers and your quarterback. If you have a guy like Le’Veon Bell and Ben Roethlisberger, the question becomes as a defensive coordinator, who do I stop? Well, you’ve got to stop Le’Veon. Now I can’t double team Antonio Brown. Then you take him out of the backfield and now you get a different threat. Now I have to put somebody in there who can defend him. I can’t put a linebacker on him. So now you’ve stretched the defense even more, where now you put him in motion, who goes with him? Does that inside linebacker go with him? Now you create a mismatch with regular personnel and that’s rare.
“The value is there because of what he has the ability to do, No. 1, and also what the defense has to do to defend against him.”
Bettis foresees no problem for Bell to assimilate quickly back into the Steelers offense after missing the preseason. What concerns him is the possibility of a muscle pull early-on, like a hamstring.
He also believes the Steelers should be a little more discerning how they use him.
“You have to be conscious of how much work he’s getting because he’s so vital in the passing game as well. So you have to be careful that you’re not overusing him on the field because when you get fatigued and tired, that’s when you get the greatest risk and chance for injuries to happen.”
Ham’s take
This man knows a thing or two about tackling and covering running backs.
“I ran a 4.6 as a linebacker. I’m covering these running backs because they’re not all that nifty or athletic,” he said of his years from 1971-82. “Today . . . [Bell] is too quick for a linebacker to cover and too physical for a safety to cover in a nickel package.
“That’s where the game has changed and that’s why a guy like Bell, those guys are now the No. 1 option on a lot of these routes.
“It puts tremendous amount of pressure on a linebacker. If you can’t handle that, it’s an easy throw for a quarterback. That’s why a guy like Bell is so valuable to this football team. You can put him out there as a wide receiver. You going to put a linebacker out there or a safety? If you do that, it opens it up. It dictates a lot to a defense when you have a guy like Bell. It changes what defensive coordinators can do when you know a linebacker can’t handle that. It’s a lot of pressure.”
Ham said, “Bell is the best route runner I have seen for a running back in a long time” and added Ezekiel Elliott of the Dallas Cowboys “can’t hold his jock as a receiver or route runner.”
“Running a flare out of the backfield is not running a route. There’s a huge difference. Elliot is a flare guy, not a route runner.
“Bell understands this. He didn’t do that at Michigan State. They didn’t use him like that. Here they found out he was such a good receiver. It’s a big weapon when he’s in there.”
Hoak’s take
Hoak coached both Harris and Bettis, among many others:
“He can do everything — catch, split out, runs well. I’m not a big fan of the way he runs but he gets it done. It’s a little different from what we used to do. It’s him. A lot of guys couldn’t run the way he does, with patience and then the burst. He’s a great player, no two ways about it.
“If you take him out of the offense, it’s going to hurt.”
Bell is a bigger back like Harris, who also was adept at catching passes. Hoak says their styles do not compare.
“Franco was a one-cut guy. He would start somewhere, put his foot on the ground and go back the other way. But he wasn’t a jump around guy the way Le’Veon is. I spoke with Franco in Canton [this summer] and I asked him about it, he said, ‘He’s a little different than I am. He makes more cuts than I do.’
“The other thing, he’s a great runner and I guess he has great speed. I haven’t seen him make the real long runs — 70, 60, 50 yards -— and I know the game is changed a lot and you don’t see it much anymore.
“He averages 4.8 [yards per carry] or something like that. He’s amazing.”
Bell actually averages 4.5 yards per carry over his four-year career, but his average has climbed from 3.5 as a rookie, to 4.7 in 2014 to 4.9 in each of the past two seasons.
As with Bettis, Hoak worries about Bell’s injuries and suspensions.
“It would be a concern, yeah, injuries and the other part of it as a concern, I guess. You always feared that. Even with Franco, you feared the injuries, and Jerome also.”
As the Steelers saw a possible trip to the Super Bowl vanish when a groin injury caused them to shut down Bell in the first quarter of the AFC championship last season, so too did Hoak see injuries to Harris, Rocky Bleier and Frenchy Fuqua derail a possible third consecutive Super Bowl for the Steelers in the 1976 season.
“They crop up on everybody and you don’t know when it’s going to happen. I don’t think he’s injury prone. He carries a big load. He catches the ball so many times, those things will happen.”
So does Bell compare favorably with Franco Harris and Jerome Bettis? Hoak paused before he answered.
“I don’t know. Give him a few more years. Let’s wait a little while. You’re comparing two Hall of Famers, two great players. I’d wait a little bit before I draw that comparison.”
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.