Gerry Dulac: Ok, we're going to start our chat in a few minutes cause I have to catch flight for Charlotte for final preseason game.

Gerry Dulac: OK, i see i have plenty of questions lined up already so lets get started.....

Scott in Dallas: Is adding McDonald a vote of no confidence in James or as a complementary player to James with no one else on the roster viewed as a viable starter in case of injury to him?

Gerry Dulac: Maybe a little of both. He was not brought in to replace Jesse James as the top tight end, at least not right now. It was more so to give them a second tight end to pair w James

Advertise with us

Josh from SoCal: Good morning, Gerry. Your thoughts on V. McDonald? Do they keep 4 TEs now? If not, who's the odd man out?

Gerry Dulac: A fourth-round pick sounds like a lot for a guy who has a history of dropped passes. But the Steelers like to use a lot of two tight-end sets and this move helps them be more flexible. I think to start the season they will keep 4 tight ends, at least until McDonald gets up to speed. But the 53-man roster they pick to start the season is always ever-changing, and I think the odd man out among the TEs will be Xavier Grimble.

TeddyBallGame14: Please assure me that this new TE isn't bringing lingering injuries with him... And, help me to understand why a team that just extended his contract would be so eager to get rid of him so soon. Are we buying someone else's lemon like we did with Ladarius? And, counting Ladarius' remaining contract, how much of the salary cap is being given to TE's now???

Gerry Dulac: I don't think this guy is damaged goods. To answer your question, the 49ers had a regime change after McDonald was signed to that big extension and this regime wants different people. Hey, we'll have to see what happens. But the Steelers recent history of making trades for mid-round picks -- Josh Scobee, Brandon Boykin -- is not very good.

HARD HEAD: Anything on cornerback Joe Haden maybe coming to the Steelers? Thank you.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Lot of gossip.

Ronnie: So Joe Haden, any realistic shot with him? Would you be more pressed to get Tuitt done?

Gerry Dulac: That won't have anything to do with it.

Gerry Dulac: Oh, and speaking for trades that haven't worked out, I forgot one -- Justin Gilbert.

DaveinCentralPA: Any truth to the rumor that NO NFL teams were willing to send any players to Cleveland, even players they did not like, want or need, out of concern for those players mental anguish?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: No.

Steele Don : I'm worried that the Steelers are believing all of the hype and thinking all they have to do is beat the Patriots in the play offs to get to the super bowl. We need to focus on every opponent, especially the teams we are "suppose" to beat! What do you think?

Gerry Dulac: Relax. I think that's their approach. They don't think the same way fans do

Kevin in Punxsy: People are calling for the Steelers to try to sign Joe Haden. For 2 reasons, one is his cost, and two is his injury history. Your thoughts? Also, the Steelers are getting the 49ers 5th round in return, so not a straight 4th for him.

Gerry Dulac: That is correct. Steelers also getting a 5th round pick with McDonald. And, yes, Haden comes with a big price tag.

Advertise with us

Dude_From_Cali: does Ladarius Green have more or less than 5% chance to be on NFL roster this year or next?

Gerry Dulac: Odds aren't very good

Dude_From_Cali: Had BIG BEN been drafted by Cleveland, do you think Ben's stats would've been decent or wash out?

Gerry Dulac: It depends. Depends on if the Browns were smart enough to put offensive weapons around him. But, my guess is they would have been at best.

mark in rochester: how is Williams going to produce compared to Timmons?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: We shall see. Vince Williams will make a lot of tackles.

Ronnie: Any indication as to how the coaching staff felt in regards to Cam Sutton's performance? Any consideration at him as a starter?

Gerry Dulac: Not yet. They liked what they saw against the Colts. He will get a lot of time tomorrow night

David: Gerry, do you think that Haden is much more of a star "name" at this point than an actual star "player"? Seems like he is a shell of the CB he was 2-3 years ago

Gerry Dulac: Hold your cards!

Advertise with us

Steele Don : Every time I watch a Patriots game, I see Coach Belichick on the sidelines huddling with players and even using a white board to instruct players. I don't see a lot of other head coaches doing that! I think that's part of his details that helps make them successful.

Gerry Dulac: Actually I think a lot of coaches do that, certainly their coordinators do. For example, Brady huddles with Josh McDaniel on the sideline, not Belichick.

Kevin in Punxsy: Any truth to the rumors that Foster has an injury that could keep him out of the opener, and possibly more? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: Dont know where that rumor started

Steeler in Charlotte: Think we see the Steelers try to deal one of these WRs before cuts to get that fourth round pick back?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: If they do, the only one with any trade value would be Sammie Coates, and I'm not sure they would do that. Otherwise, teams will wait for the waiver wire.

Ronnie: Can we talk about Terrell Watson? Has he done enough?

Gerry Dulac: I think so. It just depends how many backs they decide to keep.

Justin: Any chance we deal Hunter / Ayers / Hamilton for Travis Cadet

Gerry Dulac: None

Advertise with us

chris: Which RB's after Bell and Conner do you think will make the roster?

Gerry Dulac: That's a tough call. I think any one of the other backups would be fine. I wouldn't be surprised if they kept either Davis, Watson, Toussaint or Williams. I'm not sure I remember a year where they had so many candidates at backup RB where, no matter who you picked, they'd be fine. I think it will be Davis, tho.

Taz: Re: Haden price tag. Presuming no team is going to beat the man's previous contract ($11M/yr) as evidenced by unwillingness to trade, couldn't he be signed at a pretty modest price, with the Browns making up the rest in offset language?

Gerry Dulac: Yes thats true.

Josh from SoCal: Going into the final preseason game, are there any players in jeopardy of losing their starting spot?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Only Ross Cockrell.

TShip: Should we deal with the reality that any help the secondary is going to get at CB this year is coming from a healthy Sutton?

Gerry Dulac: Yes, and maybe Sensabaugh. Sutton, though, would be the biggest upgrade potentially

Souprnaut: Hi Gerry. Lots of people have compared expectations for Sutton to those of Burns from last year. I think with his "above the neck" aptitude it may be reasonable to expect Sutton to contribute in at least half the time it took Burns. Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: I don't know that "expectations" is the right word. I think the comparison comes more from the fact Sutton, like Burns in 2016, missed a lot of training camp with injury. And Burns eventually became the nickel back early in the regular season and then the starter in Week 8. I think it's reasonable to see Sutton follow a similar path. Certainly that is their hope.

Advertise with us

Dude_From_Cali: Senquez Golson might be the unluckiest guy due to injuries to put his talent into use, thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Yes he is. I feel sorry for the guy. Never injured in college and now this. It's not his fault. And it's unlucky for the Steelers, too, who were counting on him when they drafted him to upgrade their secondary

Kevin in Punxsy: Has OL Hawkins looked better in games 2-3, after looking really bad in game 1? thanks

Gerry Dulac: He has looked better. I think he makes the roster as 8th OL

Ronnie: Alot of smoke and mirrors will be tossed out on Haden, but isn't Cle on the hook for 4 million so steelers sign him on a 1 year for 6..they really only pay 2 mil..is that correct?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure of his exact contract status

lsb: From what you have seen in training camp do you believe Sammie Coates has regained the form he showed early last season or are his fingers and ability to hold on to the ball still a major concern ?

Gerry Dulac: I have not seen that form, but I don't think the fingers have anything to do with it. They are fine.

Dude_From_Cali: Do you think Lis-Franc foot injury ruined any chance Senquez Golson might'vd had, thought?

Gerry Dulac: Yeah, that and being out of football for two years. Never played an NFL game, never practiced in pads other than 2 days.

Advertise with us

Taz: 4TEs, 4RBs+FB, 6WRs.... at some point, even if more special teamers come from O, the harsh reality of roster limits is going to hit this offense. Who misses the cut that's otherwise done enough to make the team?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think there will be four RBs.

Sush: Steelers have been aggressive trying to get CB help, but only for cheap, mid-tier CBs. Joe H won't be cheap, but can he still play at high level?

Gerry Dulac: That's kind of the gamble they took on Justin Gilbert, who had a similar, if not greater, skill set than Haden. How that turn out?

Dude_From_Cali: Gerry, love your writing style, a bit less formal than your comrades, I enjoy it. Thank you.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Check's in the mail

Matt: If Golson doesn't get on the field on Thursday is it a safe assumption he gets cut?

Gerry Dulac: Really safe.

dave: Watt made a big splash in the first preseason game, but hasn't been as noticeable in the last two games. Are they still planning to start him ahead of Harrison?

Gerry Dulac: Yes they are, and rightfully so. I think they have been asking to do other things -- run support, drop into coverage -- to get him acclimated to that and see how he responds.

Advertise with us

Dude_From_Cali: Jesse James missing that key block led to BB strip sack prompted the Vance trade?

Gerry Dulac: No.

TShip: Is Mitchell going to be able to go opening weekend, if not what do they do? None of the backups really give you a lot to have faith in?

Gerry Dulac: At this point, I'm not sure. They won't through this a couple years ago when Mitchell missed the entire preseason and had trouble assimilating with the other DBs once the regular season started. That's their concern this time, too. He has a pretty nasty hamstring tear.

JF: I know Joe Haden will be a popular topic, but in all seriousness for a team that has had problems developing and getting good CB play is he not somewhat of a no-brainer upgrade over Cockrell and Gay?

Gerry Dulac: He is, but there's more to it than that.

AD: Million dollar question: do you think steelers take a legit run at haden? If so how do you like fit?

Gerry Dulac: Remember, Haden got cut, so other teams will have a chance to sign him before Steelers.

Sush: Will the Steelers keep Senquez on practice squad? Injuries not his fault, but Coach T seems quite annoyed by him (or questions about him).

Gerry Dulac: I would think not. There is no reason to do so because they have no evaluation of him at this point.

Kevin in Punxsy: Is this the year that Gilbert finally makes All Pro, after getting passed the past few years?

Gerry Dulac: He should, i can tell you that, but not All-Pro. Pro Bowl. He's been one of the best, if not the best, RT in the league, as far as I'm concerned, the past 2 years.

MB: I believe the odd are better than 50/50 steelers lose to browns in week 1 due to DBs and steelers penchant for losing to bad teams. your thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Save your money. Rookie QB

TK: Do you think Coates and DHB are in a battle for the 6th WR spot?

Gerry Dulac: No. I think its DHB and Justin Hunter

Steeler in Charlotte: Who is the hardest cut today, if you were making the call?

Gerry Dulac: One of the RBs, or even 6th WR. Otherwise, pretty easy

Josh from SoCal: Which of our division rivals challenges us for top dog in the North this year? I'm leaning towards Cincinnati...

Gerry Dulac: I'd agree

JF: In fairness, how much of the Steelers cutting Gilbert was about his impending suspension--which is now a full year?

Gerry Dulac: That may have been another reason. Not the only one

David: Gerry - there have been several Steelers players over the years that had careers like shooting stars - fast, promising starts derailed by injury/poor commitment/poor luck (Woodley, Foster, Green, etc.) Which player over the past 2-3 decades are you most disappointed did not fulfill his full potential?

Gerry Dulac: First off, I don't get disappointed over such things. But I think Foster and Woodley especially have to be at the top of the list.

Sush: You think Ayers can earn a spot with good showing on punt returns? Hunter hype is dying down, and DHB is only a special team guy, not WR.

Gerry Dulac: All I can tell you is I like Ayers and I wouldn't be surprised if he were sixth WR.

GSK: Haden is free to sign with any team since he has more than 4 years experience.

Gerry Dulac: Correct. I forgot how many years he had. Thanx

Bill: haden doesn't have to clear waivers. a lot more steam is picking up

Gerry Dulac: yes. See above

JerseySteel: Hi Gerry - don't know much about DeShaun Phiilips. Does he have the potential to be in the CB rotation/picture or merely here for depth and his ceiling is as a backup?

Gerry Dulac: He's a kick-the-tires kind of guy. See what he has. If you cut him, so what. You only traded him for a guy you were going to cut anyway

TShip: What's your best guess on when Sutton plays regularly and who does he replace? My guess is as early as week 2 and in the slot for Gay.

Gerry Dulac: I don't know about week 2 but it won't be long. And you have the right guy he will replace.

Kevin in Punxsy: I haven't heard any more from the DE the Browns drafted in the 1st Rd who said that he wanted to tear Roethlesberger apart when the teams met in game 1.

Gerry Dulac: That's Myless Garrett, and from all reports he's the real deal.

JTB: do we even have cap space to sign Haden or CB from the rams?

Gerry Dulac: Haden yes.

Sush: For new depth guys, I favor Watson at RB, Hilton for slot CB, Hagen vs Golden for Safety. Justifiable and realistic based on game performance?

Gerry Dulac: Yes, but I don't think Robert Golden is in danger of not making the 53

Michael9305: T. Watson looked great against Indy, however, how do his pass pro/special teams skills compare to K. Davis or Fitz ??

Gerry Dulac: That's going to be his problem.

T-man: The Steelers have been very successful in getting good Running Backs, Wide Receivers, O-Linemen and Linebackers on their teams. Why is it that they seem to struggle on evaluating good quality Cornerbacks?

Gerry Dulac: Lack of pass rush can make a lot of corners look average

Scott in Dallas: Will the Steelers consider signing Haden? What kind of contract do you expect he is looking for?

Gerry Dulac: I'm sure they will look into it. Mike Tomlin loves guys with pedigree. See Hunter, Alualu, Justin Gilbert, for reference

Jacque Strap: Surprised about Bill Nunn, Rocky Bleier omissions from Hall of Honor? If they are holding people back for inclusion in a future class, it's not like anything will have changed between now and then.

Gerry Dulac: Not at all. You can't put everyone in immediately. It's not a slight. There are other years. Look, they could put 50 in if they wanted to right away. Relax.

TeddyBallGame14: Help me understand why a team so desperate for CB help would trade for a TE and not a CB?

Gerry Dulac: Maybe because the price was better. They didn't trade for Vance McDonald to be the starter, just a complement with Jesse James. If you sign Haden, you sign him to be a starter, not a backup, and that will cost a little more. Who knows? Look, I'm in favor of the move, but I don't call the shots, in case you didn't know that.

Jon: Mike Tomlin has stated there will be consequences for L Bell not reporting. Do you think Tomlin would or should bench him for week#1?

What’s your take?

Gerry Dulac: No I don't, but I would really have even more respect for Tomlin as a coach if he did that. I would applaud him.

Jon: Hi Gerry. Thanks for chats as well as your Golf coverage. I was curious.

Do you agree with making a trade for a TE instead of making a trade for a CB?

Everyone keeps saying how good this O could and should be. It’s the D that scares me

(And I’m sure many others).

I was wondering your thoughts on this move by the team and did it surprise you?

Gerry Dulac: Well, they won't have to trade for Haden now that he's been cut. They can just sign him. I hear you about the defense, but I think they have a chance to be pretty good if they can stay healthy and get production from Dupree and Watt. I was a little surprised by the trade for the TE, but not shocked. They don't exactly have a trio of Pro Bowlers there

Dude_From_Cali: Does Senquez make roster as IR with or without return, PS or cut?

Gerry Dulac: No

Ronnie: Who is Cockrell's biggest competition for the spot?

Gerry Dulac: Right now, Sensabaugh. Eventually it will be Sutton

DMC: Any chance we kick the tires on Clev DB

Gerry Dulac: Sure. They would not be doing their job if they didn't look into it

Simon in the Uk: Do you think that DHB will make the team as a receiver? At this point he must be seen purely a special teamer? His ability as a receiver is almost none existent now.

Gerry Dulac: Not going to argue

CoalRegionJeff: When will negotiations with Tuitt end?

Gerry Dulac: Next week. I'm sure they will reach a deal.

Ronnie: I think huge year for M.B. personally and helping out Antonio. How encouraged is the staff with him?

Gerry Dulac: They are encouraged.

Zack: Schefter says we are the favorites for Haden

Gerry Dulac: I see that.

Neil: Will the gentle giant Big Dan get cut?

Gerry Dulac: He could

Jonathan: Think there's any chance we see any two RB backfield sets with Bell and Conner?

Gerry Dulac: Oh maybe a play or two, but that's it. They rarely did that with Bell and DeA Williams.

lsb: I really believe the Steelers need a power back for goal line and short yardage situations, Watson fits the bill and should be on the roster. He brings something a little different and carries that 'chip' on his shoulder well. Unfortunately I believe they will go with Davis who is the safe if somewhat less strategically clever choice. What say you Gerry ?

Gerry Dulac: I think Davis is the choice, but nothing would surprise me.

Kevin in Punxsy: Your sidekick, Eddie said this about "Halls of Fame". "People don't talk about those who got in, but complain about those who didn't".

Gerry Dulac: He is correct

RF: what's the latest on the long snapper situation? is there a potential issue?

Gerry Dulac: None

Mtsteel: Hi Gerry, thanks for your time. I say it's a no brainier to bring in Joe Haden at this point. What say you? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: Yes, but depends on his price and what he wants. I think he is friendly w AB

Jonathan: Think there is any chance of Harrison starting over Watt at any point this season (without consideration of injuries)?

Gerry Dulac: Probably not. Plus, doesn't always matter who starts. But they want Watt to develop. They don't want to make the same mistake they did with Jarvis Jones.

Josh from SoCal: How steep of a learning curve is it to learn a new team's system/playbook? Can we expect the new TE(and possibly CB?) to contribute immediately?

Gerry Dulac: Soon enough. He's a veteran. He knows how to read defenses. Just terminology

Gerry Dulac: Ok, kids, thats all the time I have. Plenty of good questions. See you next week