Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Matt: Ed, any chance Steelers bring back Doug Whaley in any capacity?

Ed Bouchette: A Pittsburgh native, he was their pro personnel man for a long time before he went to Buffalo. There could always be a chance because he left on good terms, but I've heard nothing regarding it and I'm not sure in what capacity he would work if they even did hire him.

Jim in Philly: Ed: I think the NFL is at its peak popularity. For the most part the league fields a quality product. Down the line though I think the product will begin to suffer as fewer young boys are choosing to play football. Fans will be turned off by an inferior game and invest their fall Sundays elsewhere. If you were an owner wouldn't you consider selling now to get the maximum price for your franchise?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I do not think the NFL is in danger of any big popularity decline any time soon.

gary@northernVirginia: For one game, everything on the line, who would you throw to, Swann, Stallworth, Ward, or Brown? Very tough choice, and I'll understand if you choose not to answer.

Ed Bouchette: Even if all four lined up in the same offense, I don't think I'd be able to get the ball to any of them.

SacramentoStilr: Hi Ed....Whats the current scoop on L Bell injury? Really excited about what I'm reading bout T J !!

Ed Bouchette: No scoop, really. He had a groin injury, he had surgery to repair it and I'm told he's coming along just fine.

Advertise with us

Joseph: I really hope Tomlin and his coaching staff take notice how the Penguins Head Coach Mike Sullivan changed, corrected, and adjust the Pens defensive and offensive schemes from Playoff series to series, Playoff game to game, and even in the middle of the Playoff games to win instead of doing the same old garbage and losing in the Playoffs. In particular the Patriots.

Ed Bouchette: When did the Penguins play the Patriots?

Will P: We as fans think it's so easy to fix everything. When in reality it takes years of hard world, great coaching, and a little luck to win Super Bowls. with no major injuries or suspensions how close do u believe this team is to winning a super bowl?

Ed Bouchette: They contended last season, they should contend again in this one

John: Will leveon get a new contract before the deadline? I'm getting worried.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: One way or another, it will be "new" because he will either play under a new one-year deal for $12.12M or they will sign him to a new multiple-year deal. I believe he will play under the one-year franchise deal

Ryno: Apparently AB is now best friends with King Roger, and is saying he's the best commissioner. Can we now expect a tweet from Harrison saying he isn't inconvenienced at all and loves taking drug tests?

Ed Bouchette: I would not hold my breath on that one, dear reader

Chris: Will steelers bring in daryl washington for a look, says he wants to play for cowboys or steelers... thank you

Ed Bouchette: I'd like to join the royal family, too, and that's not happening either.

Advertise with us

Ryno: I saw Big Dan has slimmed down a bit in the offseason. Have you noticed any change in his performance so far even though they have only been wearing shorts so far? Not sure if that has led to an increase in quickness or anything like that or not?

Ed Bouchette: That would be the second straight year that Daniel McCullers has slimmed down. He needs to pick his game up more than anything.

StillerFanInCleveland: I know it's early, but what will the Steelers' record be this year after 16 games? Need to get home field advantage.

Ed Bouchette: I haven't given that much thought, but will when we get closer to the regular season opener

Mark: A question about Justin Hunter. Since the Steelers signed him as a free agent, aren't they obligated to pay him a certain amount and thus less likely to cut him? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I believe he got a small bonus, and that is all he can count on.

NJSTEELERFAN: Hello Ed. If DeMarcus Ayers has a good camp and proves his special teams value does he have a leg up on DHB especially since Rogers is in the last year of his contract and AYers also being a slot WR? Thank you

Ed Bouchette: DA has an uphill fight to make the 53-man roster this year. It's not just him vs. DHB either. They added Martavis Bryant, JuJu and Hunter to the list of wide receivers and the first two have the roster made.

Ryno: What will it take to finally get Foster to a Pro Bowl? What more can he do to get recognized outside Pittsburgh?

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers put two players in the Pro Bowl last year, Pouncey and DeCastro. In my opinion, Marcus Gilbert also deserves it. It's rare 3 make it.

Advertise with us

NJSTEELERFAN: I think Le'Veon Bell's absence from minicamp and OTA's, in addition to not signing his franchise tender as of yet speaks volumes. As great as he is I just don't see him here long term. Your thoughts?

Ed Bouchette: As I mentioned, I believe he will play on a one-year deal in 2017 and go from there. There is not much longevity for many running backs as it is.

Big Beef: Hi Ed. What's your take on James Harrison's HOF credentials? I know his sack total doesn't come close to some of the top pass rushers in the HOF, but James didn't become a starter until later in his career and also had coverage responsibilities as a starter somewhat limiting his potential sack numbers. He was one of the most feared LB's for at least a good 5 year stretch.

Ed Bouchette: He also won NFL defensive player of the year in 2008, which is a big help. But you are right, his sack totals are not as high as others and he will always be fighting the fact that so many Steelers have made the HOF and a few more will be knocking on he door such as Faneca, who made the final 15 last year in his first try, and Polamalu, coming up in 2 years.

Curious G: Why only a four-year contract for TJ Watt instead of a five-year contract? Advantage: Watt?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: All draft picks sign 4-year contracts. The only difference is that first-rounders can have a fifth option year the club can pick up.

Sack Master Flash: Hello Ed. When was the last time the Steelers had both active starting OLBs achieve double-digit sacks?

Ed Bouchette: In 2010, when James Harrison had 10.5 and LaMarr Woodley 10

Todd - MI: What 3 TE's are your early predictions of making the final 53?

Ed Bouchette: Jesse James, Xavier Grimble and David Johnson

Advertise with us

MARK FROM SAUQUOIT NY: Its premature to say Senquez Golson won't make the 53. Reading so much of it lately. What do you think?

Ed Bouchette: He has a lot of work to do in training camp in order to win a roster spot

Tom: Is J. Hawkins practicing at LT or RT? What side do you think he ends up playing?

Ed Bouchette: I believe he will be No. 3, which means he needs to practice at both spots. But they believe his future lies at LT

Polish Apocalypse: How different will Williams be at buck compared to Timmons?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I believe he will be better at stopping the run, maybe not so much range or covering but he and Shazier should complement each other

Jamie: Ed I just finished the chuck noll book and was surprised to read about John Clayton writing about steeler practice habits that were illegal. As a team reporter have u ever felt conflicted on things to write about knowing it could hurt the team or image?

Ed Bouchette: My job is to my newspaper first, thus the readers. There are rules we have to follow in order to watch practice, but in the case you are talking about, Clayton didn't report that he saw them practicing in pads, one of the players asked him to help him pull off his shoulder pads in the locker room.

Ed Bouchette: Donnie Shell had 51 in the regular season. He played in 201 regular season games. Shell was a past finalist for the HOF as a modern player, now must be considered as a senior. He has a chance some day, as does L.C. Greenwood

Troy: Do you think Jesse James could be a 500-600 yard TE, with maybe 6-7 Touchdowns? Does he have enough upside to do that. I think he's a little better than most give him credit for.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: If James continues to improve as he did from year one to year two, there is no ceiling.

Ryno: Smart idea for the Steelers to tag Bell this year, then let the market adjust hopefully lower for next season and beyond since it is skewed a bit for running backs at this point?

Ed Bouchette: They either had to tag him or let him become UFA because they could not come to terms on a deal. And that may never happen. If they tag him again next year, he'll earn about $14.5 M

Flipsteeler BTSC: What 2017 free agent do you see having the largest impact?

Ed Bouchette: Either Coty Sensabaugh at CB or DE Tyson Alualu

Advertise with us

Flipsteeler BTSC: Davis or VW look hampered by their major offseason shoulder surgeries?

Ed Bouchette: No

Rapper's Delight: Bell's droppin' mad beats and spittin' dope lyrics. So, what favorite tracks of his are you looping? : P

Ed Bouchette: You talking about Archie Bell?

Polish Apocalypse: How different will Williams be at the buck position vs. Timmons?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Timmons in his prime was the mack, and that suited his talents better as a wide-ranging athlete. He moved to the buck when Shazier played. Williams is more the true buck-type linebacker. Think of Larry Foote.

Ed Bouchette: Ethan Cooper, OG from IUP

stu: What are your impressions of Dobbs as a leader? Does he command the huddle/ he seems soft spoken on TV

Ed Bouchette: I think he has the respect of anyone he's played with, but he is a rookie QB who has had just 13 days of practice in shorts in the spring. It will take some time

Ryno: Just curious how many questions you roughly pull in for these chats?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I will check with my accountant and issue the results the same time Trump releases his taxes.

MARK FROM SAUQUOIT NY: I love Ben and respect his game, no doubt. I asking you if he changes plays too much in red zone and we leave points out there.

Ed Bouchette: You have asked several times today and I finally will answer -- I have no idea.

me: How likely is it that Bell would hold out of training camp if he doesn't have a new contract?

Ed Bouchette: I think it is possible, not sure how likely though. He wouldn't lose any money unless he continued to hold out when the regular season begins

Advertise with us

kjacksonpgh: Hi Ed, don’t you think that the Steelers players and coaches should stop talking about beating New England in the off season and just go out and play the game since they have lost to them consecutively for the past few years?

Ed Bouchette: Maybe, but when they are continuously asked about New England, it's tough to avoid the topic

kjacksonpgh: Ed, you wrote that the Steelers may just decide to franchise L Bell instead of signing him to a long-term deal. I understand but isn’t Bell one of those special generational players because of his skill set?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, he is, but they've also had other special generational players who did not stick around long for one reason or another.

Bradford: I think they should A. Cut will gay or B. Put him on practice squad. He's past his prime and there are younger/ better players they are risking losing. Golson could still live up to the hype so why risk cutting Golson and keep a guy twice his age. If a guy gets injured then sure bring gay back to the 53 but I don't think any team will try and take him from PS to old and getting slow

Ed Bouchette: William Gay is not eligible for the practice squad

Bobby: When will Joey Porter stop trying to replace Deebo with another OLB. First Jarvis Jones (that didn't work..."Obviously") and now T.J. Watt. I seem like J.P. doesn't hasn't liked Deebo since he (Harrison took his starting spot. It seems as if J.P. is using his coaching position to get back at Deebo. What's ur take?

Ed Bouchette: I think you have it wrong and I think you must know that it is not Joey Porter's decision to draft Jarvis Jones or T.J. Watt. And at 39, James Harrison is not going to be around much longer.

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. Vacation time! We'll be back July 25, two days before the Steelers report to Saint Vincent College. Have a great summer