Le’Veon Bell is good. But is he twice as good as many of the other top running backs in the NFL?
The Steelers are certainly paying him to be, for the short term. He’s set to earn about $12 million this season under the team’s franchise tag designation, and an analysis published Tuesday by FiveThirtyEight.com found that salary to be roughly double the average salary of the 16 highest-paid backs in the NFL.
The piece by Benjamin Morris explores how, league-wide, top running backs are paid less on average than their peers at all of the other non-kicking positions on both sides of the ball, including tight end and safety. It gets into a lot of numbers of the efficiency of running versus passing to explain why — all interesting if you’re into that.
But most of the findings are not perfectly applicable to Bell’s long-term value in ongoing negotiations with the Steelers because, as Morris notes at the end of the piece, Bell is “extremely versatile.” He caught 75 passes for 616 yards in 2016 on top of the 1,268 yards he gained on the ground.
Versatility is worth more. But how much more?
For his part, Bell likely thinks he’s worth north of even the $12 million on a per-year basis. Though he’s backed off the $15 million demand he seemed to allude to in a rap track last summer, it’s hard to imagine he’ll accept dramatically less.
It gets more complicated from the Steelers’ side, though. There is that league-wide trend of devaluing the running back position as the game evolves toward more efficient short passing games. There are the big contracts already signed with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger and receiver Antonio Brown. And there is Bell’s off-field behavior that caused him to be suspended twice.
Combine all of those factors with Bell’s unique skill set and it’d be hard to blame the Steelers for pushing off the question of a long-term deal for as long as they can.
That gap between the $6 million they could pay to an above-average running back and the $12 million they’re giving Bell this season is huge. It could pay for a lot of a pass-rushing linebacker like Dont’a Hightower, whom the Steelers pursued in free agency before he opted to return to New England for big money. It could pay for Adrian Peterson, the former MVP who the FiveThirtyEight post notes will make $7 million over two years in a deal inked recently with the New Orleans Saints. It could pay for any other need the Steelers find that they have over the next several years.
“Versatility” shouldn’t be the broad stroke used to dismiss that.
That’s not to say the Steelers should pass on keeping Bell here, even at a premium rate. It’s just easy to see a scenario where his value to another team could exceed his value to the Steelers when you really take a look at the numbers.
Put it this way. It’s hard to imagine the Steelers would suddenly fail to be competitive with a running back like Latavius Murray, who just signed with the Minnesota Vikings for an average of $5 million per year, or DeMarco Murray, who signed with the Philadelphia Eagles two years ago for an average of about $6.3 million. (He rushed for 1,287 yards with the Tennessee Titans last year.) Both of those running backs are also competent in the passing game, and they’re just two examples of backs who’ve been available in free agency in recent years.
As good as Bell is, there is a point of diminishing returns with him. Undervaluing his skills in the passing game would be a mistake, but so would overvaluing them in an environment where solid players can be had at a fraction of the price. Bell’s value shouldn’t be tied to league-wide trends, but it should certainly be affected by them to some degree.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.