It’s easy to get lazy when it comes to the NFL draft. It’s not anybody’s fault, either — unless it’s your job to know in-depth specifics about prospects, or you’re passionate/obsessive enough to seek it out on your own, we’re all throwing spaghetti against the wall.
That goes doubly so for the 2017 draft in general, and the Steelers’ pick at No. 30 specifically. There were a whole lot of potential selections and about four hours of chaos leading up to the moment they chose T.J. Watt. If some initial assessments were superficial, they were understandably so.
Now that it’s the morning after, though, it’s worth quickly clearing up a couple popular misconceptions about the pick. This isn’t to say that Watt is an obvious slam dunk; he slid to 30 for a reason, and he only started for one (11½-sack) season at Wisconsin. Still, there are two lines of thinking that you should probably ignore.
Steelers Report: 2017 NFL draft Day 1
Misconception No. 1: He’s a product of grittiness and bloodlines.
That’s not unexpected; when your brother is J.J. Watt, the Texans’ D-line terminator and favored son of “this guy loves football” fetishists around the country, you’ll get some of that. After the pick, Mike Tomlin, Kevin Colbert and Watt himself talked about how much he wants to be great, and how much time he spends watching tape. That’s great for them.
That could be a trap, though — call it Danny Woodhead Syndrome. The old narrative — white players work hard, black players are naturally athletic — still has a major foothold across sports and with the NFL specifically. It’s equal parts stupid and hilarious, and not worth getting too far in-depth with here. Point being: T.J. Watt is deeply, impressively athletic across the board. He has the raw tools necessary to succeed, and that’s reason enough for the Steelers to be excited about him.
Read More
Take his SPARQ score. Originally developed by Nike, SPARQ gained traction back in 2013 as a single composite number, taking in key categories like the 40-yard dash and vertical jump, designed to measure a player’s athleticism. At 3sigmaathlete.com, Zach Whitman continues to publish what he calls a “[back-calculation] of a reasonable approximation of the metric.”
Colbert and Tomlin tend to like players who score well there, and Watt is nearly as good as it gets. Whitman’s version of SPARQ places Watt at fourth among edge rushers in this draft. Here’s the top 10, but there are full lists from every position that are worth your time.

Now, what should stand out there are the last two columns; a z-score of 0.0 and a percentile of 50.0 would represent league-average athleticism for the position. Watt, obviously, grades out way ahead of that — all his measurables put him in the 95th percentile.
Three of the other top six, including top pick Myles Garrett, were taken ahead of him. Other potential Steelers targets who were already off the board are behind him — Takkarist McKinley was 30th. Charles Harris was 25th. Taco Charlton was 22nd.
If you’d rather see that information communicated differently, look at this table from mockdraftable.com.
The only possible areas of concern are his 40 time, which is less important for a linebacker and made even less relevant by his shuttle times, and his bench press, which is relatively easy to improve. That’s where the Watt bloodlines could help — but again, if you don’t have the physical gifts, all the work in the world isn’t going to make you a good NFL player.
Misconception No. 2: Watt is Jarvis Jones redux.
If you’re a Steelers fan, it’s tough to blame you for being gun shy here; to say things didn’t work out for Jones, the first-round pick in 2013, would be charitable.
That shouldn’t be much of a concern, though. First, you have observations like this:
Watched more film of Watt. Jarvis Jones' college sacks were almost all extended time/effort sacks. Watt beats guys at LOS. So there's that. https://t.co/wdmVk2GNcz
— PittsburghSports (@PittsburghSport) April 28, 2017
Then, you have the simple fact that the two, athletically speaking, aren’t comparable at all. This is a different visualization of their measurables, based on percentile ranking at their position. The more shaded area, the better.
Watt’s weaknesses are basically on-par with Jones’ strengths. Not much else to say there. For posterity, here’s Bud Dupree’s chart from 2015. Watt has him beat, too.
None of this is to say that Watt is a guaranteed world-beater — but if the pick looks bad in hindsight, it’ll be because Reuben Foster gets his act together, or because one of the cornerbacks (Kevin King or Chidobe Awuzie) turns into star. It won’t be because Watt lacks athleticism or turns out to be “Jarvis Jones 2: Wisconsin Boogaloo.”
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.