POLL: Will the Steelers re-sign Lawrence Timmons? A. Yes (65%) B. No (35%)
BishkekSteeler: Given the state of the #2 WR position and the Green health questions, would it be prudent for us to draft a top TE prospect early in this draft? It has become and remains a passing league and this could only help long term.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd rather draft a No. 2 receiver. I understand Green does things in the passing game that others on the roster cannot, but at this point in the process you have to assume he's coming back. So I wouldn't spend a high pick on one of those pass-catching TEs that will go high in the draft. The guy I like in round 5 or so is Jeremy Sprinkle out of Arkansas. He is a good blocker and a good receiver. Nothing fancy, just a good player.
WARONTheRock: Will Sidney Jones be there @ 30 and if so do they take him? And is there a Dooooooooooook Riley in our future?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sidney Jones is a first-round pick in almost every mock draft I've seen. Most have him going before No. 30, but I saw one today that had him going to New England at No. 30. He's an outside corner and specializes in press man coverage. So the Steelers would have to be comfortable drafting him with that knowledge. He doesn't have extensive experience playing off coverage. The Steelers would like to incorporate more man coverage, but they're not going to abandon their zone schemes either.
BishkekSteeler: With the signing of Brown and the tag of Bell there is now a very large part of the cap directed at the offensive side of the team. How will this affect us going forward for the next several years if we don't draft starter capable players on the defensive side of the ball?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you'll see that even out over time. Guys like Shazier and Tuitt will get paid. But it's lopsided for now because the Steelers have a franchise QB and they've done a good job of drafting and developing Brown and Bell. It wouldn't make good football business not to sign/franchise them. You want to have them on the roster to make a run at another Super Bowl this year.
Guest: Any truth to the rumor Pitt will sign FA CB from Cinn?
Ray Fittipaldo: I've seen that rumor a few different places. I'm not a big fan of Kirkpatrick. He's the guy who got called for consecutive defensive holding penalties in the game in Cincinnati on the Steelers' winning drive and then loudly complained about the officiating on a profanity-laced postgame session with reporters. He's also the guy who got into that slap fight with Antonio Brown two years ago. He's a CB who can play in man coverage so I understand the link to the Steelers, but two things: this draft is loaded with good CBs and Kirkpatrick won't come cheap.
JerseySteel: I have seen reports that the Steelers are prepared to let Ross Cockrell walk and are interested in Bengals CB Dre Kirkpatrick. Would Kirkpatrick be a major upgrade particularly in man coverage and would he be affordable?
Ray Fittipaldo: See above answer on Kirkpatrick. As for Cockrell, yes he received his original round tender. It's less than $2 million for the coming season if no other team makes a bid to sign him.
Scott in Amsterdam: Do you think the extra 3rd round pick (that can now be traded) may entice the Steelers to move up in the first round? If so, which OLBs should they be looking at?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about moving up in the draft, but it is nice to have that option. This is the first year compensatory round picks are allowed to be traded.
As for the OLBs, there are a lot of guys who could be in their range at No. 30. Off the top of my head: Charles Harris out of Missouri, Takk McKinely out of UCLA, T.J. Watt out of Wisconsin, Carl Lawson out of Auburn.
Out of that group I like Harris first and then Lawson.
I don't like McKinley although I seem to be in the minority on him. I just don't see the hype.
And I see Watt as a second-round guy. Don't know if he's a good value at No. 30.
Byron in Snowy Utah: Any free agent DB's or pass rushers we could be looking at. Biggest issue IMO. Bonus part 2, what is with the continued fascination with Landry?
Ray Fittipaldo: On Landry Jones, he's a competent backup QB. Not every team has one. He's not great, but he knows the system and he's been serviceable when called upon.
I'd rather see the Steelers draft an OLB and CB in the draft than spending on either position in free agency. There are a lot of quality players at both positions in the draft.
BishkekSteeler: Do coaching, trainer, and related positions count in any way against the cap, or is that strictly players on the roster?
Ray Fittipaldo: Strictly players and it's the top 51 players until September.
JerseySteel: Thoughts on the OLB out of Temple - Haason Reddick?
Ray Fittipaldo: He played OLB and ILB at Temple. His body type reminds me of Lawrence Timmons. He's only 237. Big questions on how he'd hold up in the running game. I watched two of his games. He held up well in the run game, but that was against Memphis and another team from the same conference he played in. You see his athleticism and burst when rushing the passer. And he backed that up with a very good performance at the combine. So it's not a matter of him being a good player, it's a matter of where would he play in the Steelers' scheme? Would they make room for him as a hybrid player somewhere in their defense? It would surprise me if they view him as the long-term replacement for James Harrison at ROLB because of his weight.
Scott in Amsterdam: Judging by the original round tender, the Steelers don't seem too concerned about losing Cockrell....Are they unhappy with his performance this past year? Or are they just betting that there is no market for him?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a little bit of both. They'd like to have him back at less than $ 2 million for next season, but they don't value him at much more than that. Perhaps that's why we're hearing about the Steelers and Kirkpatrick. Both are outside CBs. The original round tender on Cockrell is confirmation on what I wrote in the days after the AFC title game. The Steelers have to change things up with their pass defense if they ever want to beat the Patriots. The way you do that is by throwing in some press man coverage schemes every once in a while. They need to find players that can do that well. Cockrell was OK for the way they've played the past two years but probably not if they're going to make some changes, which it seems like they're going to do.
Lambert Lunatic: Hi Ray, I absolutely stand behind the Steelers philosophy of building through the draft. But it's hard to argue the success other teams have that have a similar approach yet occasionally add a big ticket FA who has a huge impact. The Ravens do it year in & out with Weddle, Dumervil, Steve Smith, Boldin, etc. Would it hurt the Steelers philosophy to do this occasionally? This year seems to the perfect year for a move like that.
Ray Fittipaldo: They signed Green last year. It just didn't work out for them the way it did for The Ravens and Weddle. Kevin Colbert said more teams every year are building through the draft and not taking part as much in free agency. I doubt the Steelers will change their approach all that much. They'll add value when they see it, even starters, but they don't do it as often as other teams.
Jacque Strap: Is there anything you saw in the combine coverage that impressed you or has improved your opinion on any particular player(s).
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, as Colbert noted last week, it was important for the college DEs who might transition to 3-4 OLBs. I thought Taco Charlton looked like he could make the transition when I watched his game. But he only ran a 4.92 at the combine. So maybe he'd be better suited as a 4-3 end and not a 3-4 OLB. Then you see guys like Reddick running in the 4.5s. You can see why teams covet the speed and quickness around the edge. For the most part, teams are just trying to confirm what they see on tape, but it's nice for them to assign numbers to players so they can put a grade on their athleticism.
Ben: Hi Ray, where in the draft would you expect the Steelers to pick a QB? TE?
Ray Fittipaldo: Fourth or later for QB. Same for TE.
Pepe.: How does Senchez missing his first 2 years compare to Sean Spence?
Ray Fittipaldo: Different cases. Spence had a catastrophic knee injury and there was serious doubt he'd ever play football again. Golson had a shoulder injury his first season and a foot injury last season that kept him out. Kevin Colbert said missing two years of football is a big concern for him and it seems like anything they get from Golson will be gravy.
BishkekSteeler: I believe the last FA signing of a Cincy player was James Harrison...who they never should have let go. You really think Kirkpatrick is any sort of benefit to the Steelers? Penalties and missed tackles galore.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't like Kirkpatrick. But I do see the need for a CB that can play in coverages other than zone. I just don't see why they'd sign a guy like Kirkpatrick in free agency when this draft has so many good CBs.
Pepe.: I read that the Steelers missed out on two compensatory picks for some reason. Couldn't they be awarded those pick next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: The compensatory process is very convoluted. Kevin Colbert said as much last week. He said he doesn't understand it, and he's a GM. I read the NFL's statement on the matter and it sounded as if those two picks would have been seventh-rounders. And the way I read it they had to draw the line on picks somewhere so the Steelers and a few other teams were not awarded those late-round picks.
TK: Do you know if the Steelers have paid any special attention to Chidobe Awuzie from Colorado? Can play inside or outside at CB, good speed (4.43 in 40 at the combine I believe), good tackling and good instincts. Just read he could be an early Day 2 pick.
Ray Fittipaldo: Those smaller CBs under 6 feet don't usually get into the first round, but guys like Awuzie and Jourdan Lewis of Michigan and Cameron Sutton of Tennessee could be second-round options for the Steelers. They're mostly guys who project in the slot.
KJ: Ray, Jabril Peppers had an impressive day at the combine yesterday working out with the LBs and will also be working out with the DBs today. I saw a mock draft that projects the Steelers selecting him with the #30 pick. As much as I like and admire Peppers, I don't see him as a "need" type of player for the Steelers. Do you?
Ray Fittipaldo: No I don't see that either. I could see them going after a safety later in the draft because Mitchell is turning 30 this year and they have to think about his replacement at some point. But not in the first round.
KJ: Ray, last week I unfairly compared Jarvis Jones to Huey Richardson, but that was more a statement to show that he wasn't the bust a lot of fans believe he is. I believe a fairer comparison for Jarvis may be Ziggy Hood. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. That's a better comparison. Both started games but weren't offered second contracts.
ALLJACKEDUP: Brandon Marshall or Pierre Garcon would be great number 2 receivers and veterans to help our young receiving squad.....your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and they'll command a price. Good year for WRs in the draft. That's where I'd get my No. 2 WR.
Adam: Will the steelers be able to leverage exclusive rights with Villanueva to get a team friendly extention for him?
Ray Fittipaldo: I tried to figure out last week what Villanueva's price might be. I don't think he should make more than Gilbert, who is making $6 million a year. But he is a left tackle and good ones command big money on the open market. I was thinking in the $5 million a year range for Villanueva, maybe approaching $6 million because Gilbert's deal was signed in 2014.
Adam: Will Harrison be the starting OLB for the foreseable future?
Ray Fittipaldo: For next season, for sure. I think they'll draft an OLB in the first or second round and groom him to take over for Harrison. That's what they tried to do with Jarvis Jones. It just didn't work out as they envisioned.
Killer B: Haven't the Steelers learned their lesson about acquiring cornerbacks from other teams already? Ex: Gilbert and Boykin?
Ray Fittipaldo: For now, this Kirkpatrick thing is just a rumor. I suspect it's his agent trying to drum up a market for his player. We'll see soon if there is anything to it.
BishkekSteeler: As to Cockrell and his tender, when do they get that pick if another team poaches him? This draft, right?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll look that up for next week.
WARONTheRock: McKinley announced that he's having shoulder surgery...out 4-6 months...FYI...
Ray Fittipaldo: Right. I saw that yesterday. Explaining more why I don't like him. I watched him against Stanford and Utah, the two best teams I could find. He didn't stand out in either game. The Utah left tackle is a first-round pick and McKinley didn't do enough for me to think he'd be a good option for the Steelers at No. 30. The same with the Stanford game. If you're going to be a first-rounder you should do well against other players of the same caliber. That's what he'll be facing in the NFL. But other people seem to like him more than I do.
JerseySteel: With Ryan Harris retiring, does that change their approach to Free Agency and/or the draft? Need another backup tackle now unless Hawkins is ready for that role
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Hawkins will be fine in that role, but if not they'll probably have Chris Hubbard back. He's a restricted free agent and they offered him a tender.
Guest: Is William Gay back next year? He was a weak link in the SB.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. Played well for many years, but he fell off last season, especially in the AFC title game.
Kolbassi Kid: How do the Pro Days work? Can each team ask the players they're interested in to do a certain number of reps or perform certain drills, or does someone at the college collect all the interested pro team requests and combine them for each player?
Ray Fittipaldo: NFL assistant coaches are there to run the drills. So the coaches run drills every team would like to see.
LM: If Peppers is available to you think they take him?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think they need a safety in the first round. If you're going to take a DB in Round 1 take a CB. That's the need.
KJ: Do you think Trevor Knight, Texas A&M QB who had great "measurables" at the combine, will be available in the 5 round or later? Would the Steelers consider him in the late rounds?
Ray Fittipaldo: Measurables at the combine don't mean much for a QB. It's all in his tape. And I didn;t see A&M play enough to tell you one way or the other.
Christopher: I know the steelers don't like to sign free agents but Ben coming down to his final years do you think the team will start to get some veteran players to help get over the Patriots hump rather than with rookies who will take 2 or 3 years to become solid contributors?
Ray Fittipaldo: That hasn't been their approach. And Kevin Colbert said last week why it hasn't. He thinks teams overpay for free agents. That's why you see so many of them cut after a year or two.
Pepe.: You ssid Haason Reddick reminds you of Timmons. Wasn't he drafted to play outside, but wound up fitting inside better.
Ray Fittipaldo: No because he came in the same draft as LaMarr Woodley. Woodley was always the outside guy to be paired with Harrison. Timmons had flexibility to play outside, but they drafted him to play inside.
Ken Ward: Do you think the weakest position next year will be cb, wr or olb, thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, that depends on what happens in free agency and the draft, doesn't it? That's why they draft. To shore up needs. And all three positions you mentioned are big needs.
Andy from Montana: Greetings. I'm liking TJ Watt. I know he doesn't have the starting experience compared to the other OLB's, but he had no injury or off the field baggage like some of the other prospects. And who better to learn from than Harrison. And you know his big brother isn't going to let him not succeed....
Ray Fittipaldo: He has had nagging injuries that have kept him out. He's OK, but I don't see him as a first-rounder. Good player though.
Dex: Who do you think would be a better fit if available.Hasson Reddick or Derek Rivers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Reddick if you're committed to letting him play multiple positions and take advantage of his skills. As I mentioned previously, there are doubts about how he'll hold up at OLB int he NFL at such a light weight. Rivers is a good prospect, but he's not a first-round pick. I think you'll see him go on Day 2, a second or third rounder.
KJ: The Steelers, like most every team in the NFL, value speed. That said, which WR do you see fitting better with the Steelers? Washington's Ross or a bigger guy like USC's JuJu Smith Schuster who isn't anywhere near as fast but had a solid collegiate career in a pro-style offense?
Ray Fittipaldo: They do like speed. Mike Wallace wasn't big, but he was a nice fit in the Steelers offense. On the other hand, Martavis Bryant was bigger and just a shade slower than Wallace, and he's a great fit for the Steelers when available. I do think they need a player to threaten deep in order for Antonio Brown's value to be maximized so finding a player who can stretch the field and make plays is probably favored over possession type receivers. They already have a few guys like that.
Barry: Ray, with W. Gay and M. Mitchell and a DB heavy draft, is it possible the Steelers could spend early picks on both positions, CB and safety?
Ray Fittipaldo: My first Steelers four-round mock draft is coming out tomorrow morning. I don't want to scoop myself, but you might be onto something.
Rich: With all the big $$$ contracts the Steelers have signed on the offensive side of the ball, have we hamstrung ourselves with not being able the resign our defensive players coming up?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. The Steelers are about $22 million this offseason.
Dex: What WR's in the draft could you see Steelers target?
Ray Fittipaldo: Guys that can stretch the defense. And if you watched the combine Sunday there should be plenty available for the Steelers to draft.
JFRY: How can the Steelers count on Harrison as a starter for next year. Once the season starts Harrison could be one play away from retirement. And who knows if his body can hold out for the whole year even as a part-time player?
Ray Fittipaldo: They'll draft a player that hopefully will be able to spell him early in the season and maybe even split time with him in the second half of the year. At least that's what my plan would be.
Killer B: Charles Harris is a guy I really like for the steelers at 30. Great counter spin move and looked really fluid in the combine drills. Do you think he will be available for the steelers at 30?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like him too. I've seen him in that range in mock drafts. He'd be a nice pickup for the Steelers. He's an NFL ready pass rusher. They'd have to work with him on his run defense, but the Steelers need to apply more pressure to QBs and Harris can do that.
Guest: Do you think BR is the type of QB that can carry the team? He throws a fairly high number of picks and as you have written, often misreads the defense. Ironically, it seems like he actually played better when the oline would break down and he could improvise.
Ray Fittipaldo: Even with his mediocre 2016 season I think he's still among the top 7-8 QBs in the game. Now I would like to see Todd Haley grab the reins from him in certain situations and not give him so much freedom, but that's tough to do when you have a two-time Super Bowl winning QB. The great ones have egos.
Guest: Lets say you're GM of the current team. Do you draft Bens replacement before he retires, when he retires, or a year after he retires (figuring you'll get a higher pick)?
Ray Fittipaldo: Before he retires but not with three years left on his contract. I think this will be a much more legitimate topic next winter, or most certainly in the winter of 2019.
AD: You think the Steelers kick the tires on a Mario Williams or a Julius Peppers? I think either could come at a discount price and both have the chance to help the pass rush and add DLine depth.
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers already have an old edge rusher in James Harrison. They have to get younger at the position, not older.
BishkekSteeler: The Steelers need a #2 RB as much as they need a#2 WR in my opinion. Will they go and get one this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they will. Plenty of good ones available. Still not a need like WR, CB or OLB in my opinion because you have Bell under contract next season. I'd say fourth round or after, maybe third round with that comp pick.
KJ: Mike Wallace. Great speed and had great seasons with Roethlisberger. Any chance the Steelers look to try and bring him back next season? That could potentially pay off in huge dividends. Have you heard his name being mentioned by anyone in the Steelers' organization?
Ray Fittipaldo: Of all the free agent WRs (Marhsall, Garcon, etc) I'd favor Wallace because he knows the system and has a rapport with Ben. That being said, I think they draft a WR.
Scott in Amsterdam: What do you expect the market for Timmons to be?
Ray Fittipaldo: Will be interesting. If I'm the GM I'd sign him for $5-6 million a year but not much guaranteed more than the first year base salary. He is getting older.
Steeler Joe: Would be nice to see Terrell Pryor in his hometown jersey, just saying.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they had a chance to get him a little more than a year ago for the league minimum when he was a street free agent. Too late now. I read somewhere the contract for him will be in the $10-12 million range.
Guest: I know your mock be who you think the Steelers will draft but you should also include a draft with who the Steelers SHOULD draft.
Ray Fittipaldo: There will be plenty of mock drafts between now and the end of April.
Scott in Amsterdam: How can you say RB is not as big of a need? Bell gets injured every year and D. Williams may not be back.
Ray Fittipaldo: It is a need, just a bigger need than OLB, CB or WR in my mind.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the great questions this week. We'll do it against next week. And look for my first four-round mock draft Tuesday morning.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.