Jerome Bettis was one of the lucky ones. He got to go out on his terms, and the way he wanted, too – winning a Super Bowl in his hometown of Detroit.
But the Hall of Fame running back knew some disappointment along the way, too; losses he never forgets. Both of them to the New England Patriots, both of them in the AFC championship game, both of them at home at Heinz Field.
No matter what he and the Steelers accomplished in 2005 — winning their final eight games, becoming the first No. 6 seed in history to go on the road and win the Super Bowl — it doesn’t erase the memory of those losses to the Patriots.
“They sting,” Bettis said. “When you look back, we had an opportunity to win multiple championships and, for whatever reason, we didn’t get it done. It definitely still hurts.”
Bettis was a member of the 2001 and 2004 Steelers teams that lost to Tom Brady and the Patriots in the conference championship games. He remembers the two special teams touchdowns by the Patriots in their 24-17 victory in the 2001 title game and the 87-yard interception return by Rodney Harrison and four turnovers in the lopsided 41-27 defeat when the Steelers were 3-point favorites after a record 15-1 regular season in 2004.
Pouncey and Roethlisberger discuss offensive line, Patriots
Maybe that’s why Bettis and some of his teammates from those games have a special anticipation for what could unfold today in Foxborough, Mass., when the Steelers (13-5) face the Patriots (15-2) in this season’s AFC championship game — the first time the franchises have met in the postseason since that 2004 game.
Read More
Should the Steelers win, it won’t change what happened to them more than a decade earlier or ease the disappointment of those defeats. But, from an organizational standpoint, it will be a fitting way to advance to another Super Bowl — beat the team that potentially deprived them of two more Vince Lombardi trophies and finally manage to beat Brady in New England, something they have never done in four previous meetings.
“It’s significant because they’ve been a team in these big games we haven’t been able to beat,” Bettis said. “It’s significant because you got to get in this position and win, and it hasn’t been the case against them.”
And if the Steelers finally do exorcise their demons against the Patriots? And against Brady in New England?
“Absolutely it would be extra special because you know you went the long, hard way,” Bettis said. “It wasn’t that you lucked out and got through it, you went the hard way and you played the best teams and you won. There’s something to be said for that.”
A satisfying scenario
The Steelers would have to go back to the 1974 season and a 24-13 victory in Oakland against the arch-nemesis Raiders to find an AFC championship game so satisfying, so vindicating, so cleansing, should they manage to beat the Patriots.
Probably not to most of the players who will be competing in the game. Only Ben Roethlisberger and James Harrison were around for the loss to the Patriots in the 2004 championship and, as such, are the only players on the 53-man roster who know what’s it like to come so close to the Super Bowl and not get there.
“Shoot, you get a chance to play in the AFC championship game, it’s always gratifying, no matter who you are playing,” Roethlisberger said. “It’s an awesome challenge that we get to go play them, kind of ‘the team’ to beat.”
But, to nearly everyone else associated with the franchise, getting to their ninth Super Bowl with a chance to win their seventh Lombardi Trophy couldn’t come with a more delicious scenario than this.
“It’s a special moment, I think, from a historical standpoint; it would be great from an organizational standpoint,” said former quarterback Kordell Stewart, who played in the 2001 game. “But the team that’s there now, they don’t have to carry that burden to erase history. They need to create their own history. They don’t need to take on the life of the unfortunate times we had. I don’t buy they have to carry the load of what I didn’t do or what Bill Cowher didn’t do.”
The Steelers were favored in the 2001 AFC championship game, but the Patriots scored a pair of special-teams touchdowns — a 55-yard punt return by Troy Brown and 49-yard return on a blocked field goal by Antwan Harris — and Stewart committed four turnovers, including three interceptions. With the ball in his hands with 2:54 remaining, trailing by seven, Stewart overthrew Hines Ward on a crossing route that Stewart said could have easily gone for the tying touchdown. The ball was intercepted by defensive back Tebucky Jones. “It took the air out of our sails,” Stewart said.
The Patriots went on to Super Bowl XXXVI and won the first of four Super Bowls with Brady, beating the St. Louis Rams.
“My worst game that year was that game,” Stewart said. “It was an empty feeling. It was a great year, but the end result was nothing. It was a hard pill to swallow. It’s one I will always remember for a long time. We were so close and I had chance to go home and play [the Super Bowl] in New Orleans. It was so close yet so short.”

Turnovers doomed Steelers
After the 2001 defeat, Stewart said “the best team didn’t win,” a comment that was replayed the following year in the week leading up to 2002 season opener in New England. The Patriots won that game, 30-14.
Stewart wasn’t alone in his belief that the best team lost in the AFC title game. But the reasons were the same in 2004, when the Steelers again committed four turnovers — one an 87-yard interception return by Harrison — and sent the Patriots to their third Super Bowl victory in four years. “That was a rough game,” inside linebacker James Farrior said the other day, remembering the moment. In those two games, the Steelers committed eight turnovers, the Patriots none
“Those two games they had three returns,” said former coach Bill Cowher. “Certainly you give up two touchdowns on special teams, that usually doesn’t bode well. Turnovers seem to be a common theme in those games.”
Even though Cowher won his first and only Super Bowl in 2005, he said, “You always remember the losses. Both of those circumstances were such we didn’t get it done.”
Since beating the Steelers in the 2001 AFC championship game, the Patriots have been to six Super Bowls with Brady, winning four. The Steelers have been to three, winning two. The winner of today’s meeting will make it to the Super Bowl for a ninth time, more than any other team.
It could have been so different, if not for the Patriots.
“You remember all of them, you remember all the playoff games, especially the championship games, they hurt the most,” Farrior said. “You get so close and work all year and come up short. It was very disappointing.”
That’s why this game drips with so much meaning to the Steelers as a franchise.
“Organization wise, from a fan perspective, from a former player’s perspective, you always have that in the back on your mind,” Farrior said. “But, from a team standpoint, they look at it as the next game they have to play. None of the other games they played will matter at this point. They’re looking at it from totally different eyes than the fans and the staff.”
Said Cowher, “You’re going against a team that has been the hallmark team of the AFC. To me, I honestly believe these are the best two teams in the AFC.”
Just like in the past.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.