Colin Cowherd was angry on Thursday over mistreatment of Mike Kryzyzewski or Tom Coughlin or whatever, so he went in on Mike Tomlin.

And now, because this is how the cycle works, we’re going to rehash what he said. We’re all pawns in Colin Cowherd’s game of chess, as played by angry men shouting about sports. What a world.

In any case, we now enter “Week 3” of Tomlingate, and Cowherd wants a piece of that sweet, sweet action. Tomlin, according to Cowherd, gets more media protection than more accomplished coaches like, you guessed it, Kryzyzewski, who’s deservedly taking heat right now for reinstating star guard/incorrigible opponent-tripper Grayson Allen.

It’s funny, Cowherd is saying, that the media en masse rushed to Tomlin’s defense while choosing to tear down Kryzyzewski.

Advertise with us

“It’s remarkable who you’re allowed to criticize,” said Cowherd. Yes, only he has the courage to defend Kryzyzewski from criticism. This is a break Mike Kryzyzewski, career-long media speedbag, desperately needed.

“[Kryzyzewski has] been a terrific mentor to kids. Has built a dynasty the right way,” Cowherd said. “But boy, if you criticize Mike Tomlin...”

Cowherd had the clip of Terry Bradshaw, from an appearance on another FS1 show, ready to roll. When Bradshaw said Tomlin didn’t “pop into” his head as a great coach, Cowherd agreed.

“Doesn’t pop into my head either. And Terry Bradshaw — oh, if you could’ve read those bloggers. If you could’ve read those beat reporters ...”

“So we’re criticizing this morning Mike Krzyzewski and we’re all OK with it. But Mike Tomlin? Hands off.”

Advertise with us

Cowherd sneered when he said “bloggers” and “beat reporters.” That’s what the italics are for. I sneer when I say “Colin Cowherd,” so all’s fair, I suppose. Mainly — and remember this — that’s due to his intellectual dishonesty. It’s the main reason he’s exceedingly rich and on television.

Intellectual dishonesty pays, and casting Bradshaw’s criticism of Tomlin as mild is a perfect example. It wasn’t just Bradshaw questioning whether Tomlin is great; Tomlin, if you believe that coaching greatness is a provable thing and not just an opinion, probably doesn’t qualify there.

The issue here, as ever, is that Bradshaw scoffed at the notion and wrote off Tomlin as a cheerleader. His heavy implication  — and you can hear it in his voice — is that Tomlin might be too far from greatness to deserve consideration. That’s a shaky wagon to drive. Tomlin won a Super Bowl and is about to coach his seventh playoff team. He’s won 103 games in 10 years. He, at minimum, is really good.

Cowherd himself seems to agree; later in the segment, he shared his actual opinion of Tomlin: “He’s fine!”

Right! He’s fine! The point is that Bradshaw doesn’t seem to think he’s fine. That’s why people paid attention in the first place; it wasn’t due to some sort of pro-Tomlin media conspiracy. It was because Bradshaw seemed to have an axe to grind. It was because Bradshaw came off as a weirdo.

Advertise with us

The media response, Cowherd said, was uniform; we crushed Terry Bradshaw for daring to say that Tomlin wasn’t great, and we rushed to Tomlin’s defense. All dissension, crushed by Mike Tomlin’s personal Pravda. Understandable — that makes for better television than “lots of people had different responses, some of them moderate, to an extreme, surprising, left-of-center opinion offered by one of my coworkers.” It might not be intellectually honest, but it works on TV.

So, with the straw man adequately constructed, Cowherd laid out a hypothetical theory in which the Dolphins beat the Steelers. It’s unlikely, Cowherd says, but as an expert on human behavior, he knows what will happen.

“If they lose, Monday, you will question Mike Tomlin. Every one of you columnists knows you will. You’re not gonna blame Big Ben. You’re not blaming that guy. You’re not blaming the offensive line, Le’Veon Bell, Antonio Brown, the Rooneys.

“So ask yourselves this. If you could at least admit, try to be intellectually honest that you would admit that if the Steelers lose to Miami, [that] Tomlin is going to be the question, how can you stridently defend him?”

“Try to be intellectually honest.” You may fail, but at least you tried. Try like Colin Cowherd tries.

Advertise with us

Then he launched into a weird, convoluted analogy about how you’d handle having a son who’s a bully. Then, he caped for Coughlin some more. The whole segment was 10 minutes long and he repeated himself a decent amount, so that’s enough for now.

The best part, though, was when Cowherd said, flat out, “the media is intellectually dishonest.” That’s true in a lot of cases. Some more than others, though.