In the 17 years since the facility opened along the banks of the Ohio River, Paul Brown Stadium has been a welcome haven for the Steelers, a place where dreams came to flourish and careers came to an end. Only one other team in the National Football League has enjoyed more success in an opposing stadium than the Steelers in Cincinnati.
That has not been the case for the hometown Bengals, at least, not against their division rival. Oh, sure, they developed a game plan that proved to be an annoying template for several years to come for the Steelers. But mostly it has been the site for regular-season defeats and postseason heartaches, beginning with a crippling injury to their quarterback to start a 2005 wild-card playoff game and ending, at least for now, with an incredibly moronic conclusion an entire decade later.
The Steelers (8-5) head back to the surprisingly hospitable confines of Paul Brown Stadium today, riding a four-game winning streak and seeking to win for the fourth consecutive time on the road. The odds are in their favor, if recent history is any indication.
Since the stadium opened in 2000, the Steelers are 15-3 in Cincinnati, counting postseason, and have won six of the past seven games there. That is a better record than the Steelers have in Cleveland (13-4) since then. The only team with a better record in an opposing stadium in that same time frame is New England, which is 15-2 in Buffalo’s New Era Field, previously known as Ralph Wilson Stadium.
What is surprising about that is the Bengals have been a successful franchise more than 40 percent of the time, recording seven winning seasons and making the playoffs six of the previous seven years. It’s not like Buffalo, where the Bills haven’t made the postseason since 1999. Or even the Browns, who haven’t had a winning season since 2007.
“I would’ve never believed that,” said guard David DeCastro, who has been around since he was a No. 1 draft choice in 2012. “It always feels like it’s a hard-fought game. All the games are always tough, they’re always close. Guys are always playing tough.”
Read More
Memorable moments
Bill Cowher has had several memorable moments in Paul Brown Stadium, none sweeter than the 2005 wild-card playoff game that began their postseason run to his first and only Super Bowl title.
Right behind, though, is the 23-17 overtime victory in the season finale in 2006, a game decided on Santonio Holmes’ 67-yard catch-and-run touchdown. That proved to be Cowher’s last game as head coach. He announced his resignation less than a week later.
“My last game,” Cowher said. “I’ll always remember we won it overtime and hit Santonio Holmes on a slant pass.”
Cowher also remembers another landmark moment in Paul Brown Stadium, this one not as favorable.
On Dec. 30, 2001, the Steelers lost to the Dick LeBeau-coached Bengals, 26-23 in overtime, despite taking a 23-10 lead late in the third quarter on a 37-yard touchdown pass from Kordell Stewart to running back Chris Fuamatu-Ma’afala — Stewart’s third touchdown of the game. But Stewart threw three of his four interceptions in the fourth quarter and the Bengals forced overtime on a Shayne Graham field goal with 10 seconds remaining on a day when the wind chill was 9 degrees.
That was the only time in his career Cowher lost a game when the Steelers were ahead by 11 or more points in the second half. He was 108-1-1 in those games.
“The only game I ever lost where we had an 11-point lead,” Cowher said the other day on the phone. “It was so cold and we lost to Dick LeBeau. That’s when we snapped the ball and it went through Josh Miller’s hands. He dropped it, it was so cold.”
That game was significant for another reason. Bengals quarterback Jon Kitna threw a franchise-record 68 times in that game for 403 yards, using multiple-receiver formations to spread the Steelers defense and control the ball for a whopping 97 plays and 32 first downs. It was one of the few times the Bengals created problems for the Steelers in Paul Brown Stadium.
That game plan established a template how to penetrate the Steelers’ vaunted defense and was quickly copied the following year by the Steelers’ opening two opponents — the Patriots and Oakland Raiders.
Tom Brady attempted passes on 23 consecutive plays in the first half and threw 43 overall in a 30-14 victory in New England. A week later, Oakland’s Rich Gannon, threw on 38 of the first 40 plays and attempted 64 passes overall in a 30-17 victory.
“I still think it’s a rivalry game, but my sense is that Baltimore is still that team,” Cowher said. “They have won that [Super Bowl] title, they have been in [AFC] championship games. To Marvin’s [Lewis] credit, there was a long period where there was a down time. Marvin has fielded a much better team since [Andy] Dalton came. But the hurdle to win that first playoff game is still sitting there. That’s the biggest challenge they have.”
The Steelers are to blame.
Different approaches
The Steelers have taken different approaches to beating the Bengals, whether in Cincinnati or at Heinz Field. When Cowher was head coach from 1992 to 2006, they did it on the ground, posting a 100-yard rusher in 21 of the 31 games against the Bengals, according to the Elias Sports Bureau.
Since Mike Tomlin has been coach, the Steelers have had just four 100-yard rushers in 21 games against the Bengals. But, based on the way Le’Veon Bell has performed the past four games, especially a week ago in Buffalo, that number might be padded today. After rushing for a franchise-record 236 yards against the Bills, Bell is averaging 155 yards in his past four outings.
“Being able to perform when your quarterback is having a bad day at the office, other guys were able to step up and make things happen,” said quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, referring to his performance in Buffalo. “That’s what the team is about. That’s why this is the ultimate team sport. Guys step up for each other. At this time of year, whether it’s elements, the weather, the conditions, injuries, whatever it might be, you’ve got to be able to have other facets of the offense step up and rise up.”
Or play at Paul Brown Stadium.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.