POLL: Which play(s) from the Steelers-Cowboys game infuriated you most as a fan? A. The game-winning 32-yard TD run (40%) B. The 83-yard screen pass TD (31%) C. The 50-yard TD pass (2%) D. Antonio Brown running out of bounds on final play (6%) E. The two-point conversion decisions (21%)

Steve: Based on the post press & the performance(s) of the team it seems Tomlin may be on the verge of “losing’ this team. They lack “discipline” and have motivation issues (inconsistent play) with a sprinkle of divas due big contracts. Is this a reasonably accurate analysis?

Ray Fittipaldo: Losing the team? I'm not sure, but things are not rosy here. Anytime two of your best players talk about the team lacking accountability and discipline that's not a good look on the coach. The difference between this four-game skid and the ones in 2013 is this team was considered a Super Bowl contender. That '13 team was in a rebuild. This is more reminiscent of 2009, the year after the last Super Bowl win when they lost five in a row. That team finished strong and went 9-7. There are no signs this team is about to turn it around. In fact, it's just the opposite. They keep making the same mistakes. How many times are they going to let an offense execute a long screen pass for a touchdown? How many times are you going to get gashed in the run game? These problems are not being fixed. It's on the head coach and all of his assistants to get it fixed and they are running out of time. That doesn't mean Tomlin is getting fired, but we could look back on this stretch a year from now or two years from now when there is a change and mark this as the beginning of the end. I admit that is possible.

Steve: Who is first responsible for the two point conversion decision? Haley or Tomlin? I need to know so I can blame the right person at the coffee machine today at work…

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin. Haley just draws up the plays.

Steve: Shazier looked fantastic on a few blitzes…well, until he was either blocked or overran the QB & took himself out of the play altogether. Who is underperforming the most at this point, the D-Tackles, Ends, or Linebackers?

Ray Fittipaldo: D. All of the above. I've pointed out the lack of depth along the D line for a long time now. Tuitt played every snap and Heyward played all but four. I'm not absolving them, but would anyone be surprised if they wore down late in the game? Not me. They signed Ricardo Mathews to a free agent contract and barely play him. Why? Probably because a tired Tuitt or Heyward is better than a fresh version of him. The outside linebackers don't pressure the QB other than an occasional sack or pressure.

As for the D tackles, Hargrave and McCullers, they're on the field 20 or 25 snaps a game. They might not be playing well, but I can't bring myself to point them out as the problem. It's a group effort stink that's going on right now.

Daquido Bazzini: Hi Ray....I'm not so sure the same patience is going to come into play with Steeler ownership, as this team is no longer solely owned by the Rooney's. What do you think a guy like Thomas Tull thinks about what he's seeing from the team AND hearing from his 2 time Super Bowl winning QB?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They're minority owners and leave the Rooneys to run the team. Do they have some input into decisions. Yes, to a degree but not in the day-to-day operation. The Rooney still handle that.

One interesting aspect of this season is Danny Rooney, the 27-year old Dartmouth grad, being a member of the coaching staff for the first time this season. Art II is a frequent visitor at practice and is very involved. But Danny knows everything that's going on throughout the day. I wonder what those private conversations are like between father and son away from the facility when some of these questionable coaching decisions are criticized. Things such as a low percentage onside kick vs. Baltimore or the two-point conversion fiasco.

Race: Ray - With five first rounders and two second rounders in the starting defense, how can you be that bad? And, a Tomlin proclaimed "splash" free agent signing in Mitchell....who can't cover anyone and can only hit someone after they are out of bounds? Thought Shazier was one of the fastest in the NFL....did he blow a tire on the Elliot run?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wrote about the 2015 draft class on the Steelers blog at post-gazette.com this morning. They're getting next to nothing out of that class. They've received precious little in return from their offseason free agent signing. It's hard to win when you don't land impact players in your drafts or free agent classes.

Jimmy V: What ever happened to the "Defense wins Championships" mentality

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe "defense does win championships" which is why Seattle might win it all again this season.

SteelerCanuck: Whats it going to take for Tomlin AND Colberts seats to get warm?

Ray Fittipaldo: A 4-12 season with 11 consecutive losses?

SteelerCanuck: NFL is very much a copycat league, when you're doing something smart and innovative, teams take notice and follow suit, You see any other teams going for 2pts early in games?

Ray Fittipaldo: No, I do not.

Advertise with us

SteelerCanuck: How long does it take to fix a defense and find a semblance of a pass rush, I believe its time for a change where Colbert/Tomlin are concerned, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Both were signed to extensions before the 2015 training camp. Being the head coach in the same place for a decade is a long time in the NFL. It doesn't happen in many other places beside Pittsburgh. The Steelers have had success with continuity, but there is a right time to make a change. I don't think 10 years will be it for Tomlin unless they lose out, or close to it. But as I wrote earlier, perhaps a year or two down line in Year 11, 12 or 13 we'll look back on this stretch as the time when things started to crumble.

RodinIndy: Team is very reminiscent of the 0-4 team in regards to guys trying to do too much, not in their gaps, penalties, etc. BB has seen this movie before, and is calling for more discipline and accountability! Young team then, too. Captains and Coaches have to get them to stop saying they're a SB capable team!! How about winning a game, first! Stiller says are not a good front running team-better when backs against wall (like now?)

Ray Fittipaldo: Good point

SteelByDesign: I like to fancy myself a pretty level headed fan. I'm not one to want heads to roll after EVERY loss. I've been a supporter of most of the staff for some time but I'm really losing patience with this defense. At what point do you stop watching the same thing week in and week out?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. Big plays are killing this defense and the offense, by the way, isn't getting many big plays to offset that even though it scored 30 Sunday.

SteelByDesign: Is it me or does this defense just have no idea what they want to be? They have 4 down lineman most of the time now, yet they play these 250 lbs. OLB's at end and they just get mauled in the run game. I'm just struggling to see the vision long-term.

Ray Fittipaldo: There are a lot of people questioning scheme and personnel after those final two Elliott touchdown runs. Players said afterward they were in the right calls, but failed to execute. I'm not quite so sure. Most short-yardage defenses cover up the offensive linemen and fill the gaps with linebackers. The Steelers left the left side of the Cowboys offensive line uncovered and allowed them time and space to execute their blocks to precision.

Tx_Steeler: Based on the late substitutions, the look of confusion pre-snap, general under-performance, etc. , is Butler gone/scapegoated at the end of the year?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about that, but there could be changes to the staff.

Advertise with us

SteelByDesign: If the concern is that team is wasting Ben's last years, wouldn't a change (such as at D-coordinator) be better to make sooner rather than later? It's going to take time for a new guy to get his system really in place.

Ray Fittipaldo: Do you know for sure it's the scheme that's holding this team back? I admit there are some things that don't make sense, but he was here under LeBeau and knows what it takes to win on defense. How much of this falls on Tomlin and Colbert not knowing how to identify the players they need to execute the defense?

RodinIndy: Rewatch Dez TD. 23 makes a decision to intimidate an OL instead of pressuring Dak, who he may have gotten before the throw, or at least altered the throw...disgusting!!

Ray Fittipaldo: OK, I'll watch it. Thanks.

SteelByDesign: So, if the Cleveland game looks anything like the Dolphins game do they go into full-blown panic mode and start making heads roll?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: That would be interesting, but I don't think this team is that bad to lose to the Browns. Or are they?

Bill: Everyone talks about how the pressure is on Tomlin but what ab out Colbert? Does his seat get hot? I'm sure Tomlin has a big say in draft picks but still he is the GM. Obviously they are not scouting well on defense.

Ray Fittipaldo: Dupree and Golson, their top 2 picks from 2015, have been hurt. Burns and Davis have struggled as rookies, especially at crucial times. But if you go back to 2014, Shazier and Tuitt are two relaly good picks. Jones in 2013 not so much. I agree. They have to do a better job, but you can't hit on every pick.

SteelByDesign: Do you foresee any changes in the depth chart to try and shake things up? Justin Gilbert gets more work? Mitchell sits some in favor of Davis/Golden?

Ray Fittipaldo: They're looking to replace Golden with Davis so I'm not so sure Golden is better than Mitchell. Did you see the angle he took on that 83-yard screen pass? It was Mitchell-esque.

Advertise with us

JIm: Yes Shazier is fast. However, I'm not expert but it sure seems like he is easily blocked a lot. Any chance they get a bigger linebacker to pair with him next year?

Ray Fittipaldo: I do think they'll take an ILB relatively high in the draft to replace Timmons. But you have to be careful in today's NFL. Big run-stopping LBs are fine, but what do you do with them when the offensive coordinator goes four-wide and throws the ball all game.

John From VA: Is it time to look for a new defensive coordinator, the defense is terrible ?

Guest 6Rings: If the game was 40 seconds shorter, we're talking about Ben clutch, beating a good team that was on a roll, etc. I understand it is a 60-minute game, but give us one positive to take away from yesterday please!

Ray Fittipaldo: Nope. I blame Ben. He scored too early.

Advertise with us

Just kidding.

UsedToDefendTomlin: How bad can it really get?

Ray Fittipaldo: Isn't it bad enough already? Not to make you feel worse but this defense still has to deal with Eli Manning, Andrew Luck and Andy Dalton. Maybe the offense's goal should be 40 points per game from now on.

Bruce: Why not let Justin Gilbert play CB, It's too big a job for Artie on his own. I felt sorry for Gilbert just observing from the sidelines watching the DBs getting beat all day

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm assuming he hasn't shown enough in practice to warrant an opportunity. But judging from the way the others are playing I am starting to get just a little curious about what an outsider might bring to the equation.

Advertise with us

Chuck: Great point on 2015 draft - outside of a few great finds (Bell, AB, Tuitt) Colbert / Tomlin drafts the past five years have been collectively bad top to bottom. We know Tomlin isn't going anywhere even though I'm sure this chat will voice the opposite so is it time for a new GM?

Ray Fittipaldo: As I mentioned a little while ago, they signed Tomlin and Colbert to extensions in July of 2015. Don't see it happening anytime soon, but I could be wrong.

Ryno: Yesterday was a loss, but would you look at the game as possibly being the turnaround point? Most faces look better than we have seen recently. They still need a bit of work on getting stupid penalties though.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah that and giving up big plays and getting gashed in the run game and running out of bounds when you need to score to win the game.

John From VA: IS it time that the Steelers give Butler walking papers since the defense has played so poorly and can not hold leads?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Who do you replace him with?

TeddyBallGame14: Glaring deficiencies of defense have fans and media condemning coaches and GM. Clearly, this defense needs a complete overhaul. If you're the new GM, where do you go this offseason to piece this together enough that Ben's window doesn't close before the Steelers get back to the Super Bowl?

Ray Fittipaldo: Pass rushers. In the old days, the ball at the 25 with 42 on the clock meant sacks or bad throws because of pressure. Now the QB is sitting back there and picking the secondary apart. Until their edge rushers begin to apply more pressure I'm not sure this defense is designed to work.

Jim: What do you think Ben was implying with his comments about not being disciplined and questioning if the could be the players and coaches? Is there a divide in the lockeroom? Maybe offense and defense?

Ray Fittipaldo: All players are frustrated after losses. But if he meant it, I honestly don't know what he was referring to because he didn't specify. He just kind of put it out there and now everyone is dissecting it.

Advertise with us

Weeg: I think the issue with our defense is philosophy and personnel. We have always been dedicated to the 34 defense, which requires a mammoth 350 lb. nose tackle to plug the middle and converted athletic defensive ends to rush the qb. We don’t draft this personnel anymore, so do we play 34?

Ray Fittipaldo: You're only in a true 3-4 25 or 30 percent of the snaps. The rest is nickel of dime or quarters.

UsedToDefendTomlin: Even if we draft higher - meaning this year ends badly, can we draft enough good defensive players to mean anything? Do we still know how to draft effectively? Will "good" rookies make a difference?

Ray Fittipaldo: I go back to 2014. It looks like they know what they were doing with Shazier and Tuitt. They have to get players like that every year though. They've had too many high-round picks bust out or underperform. So to answer your question, I'm not quite sure. Other teams make mistakes in drafting. We're all looking at the Steelers because they're scuffling now, but plenty of other teams have struggled to find players. It might not be a coincidence some of the new blood in the AFC in places such as Oakland is because they're drafting higher every year because they were bad for so many years. I do think you have to look at that.

Chuck: Advil or Alcohol to watch Pitt games? What do you recommend? In all seriousness on this "doom and gloom" Monday, 10-6 easily wins North as Balt and Cincy play each other 2x and both have tough schedules. Do you see enough in Pitt for them to still win the North?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No. Just not consistent enough. I could see them winning a few in a row and then stumbling later in the season. They just have too many holes to cover up.

Graham: I'm not very discouraged after yesterday's game. I thought Dallas beat us, as opposed to previous games where I felt we beat ourselves and/or the game plan kept us from having a shot. But looking ahead, we have 4 of the final 7 on the road. Considering the AFC North will not get a wild card, how confident are you we make the playoffs? And what is the #1 key in winning the division?

Ray Fittipaldo: On a scale of 1-10, with 1 being the lowest confidence level I'm at 3. And the recipe for wining the division would be sweeping the final four games plus winning one in Buffalo or Indy. And beating the Giants at home. Sorry, I just don't see all of that happening.

Steelcitygirl: Tomlin must go - 4 losses in a row, team totally unprepared week after week, bone head play calls & a non-existent "D" , they couldn't stop a JV team. In the days of Cowher, these guys making stupid penalties that cost us field position then eventually the game would be pulled aside on the sideline & he would be in their face. I blame Tomlin & Haley needs to get with it to with the play calls, Steeler fans can sit on the couch & make his calls week in & week out so the other teams certainly can too. It took 3 quarters vs Baltimore for the coaching staff to realize we were not gonna RUN on the Ravens what a joke. Steelers will never win another SB with that coaching staff - we have tons of offensive talent but the D & our draft picks are horrible. Another disappointing season

AJ: Why was James Harrison not in the game on the last series. Seemed like he was the only one who was able to stop the run/apply pressure to Prescott

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. I was wondering the same thing when I saw the replay and saw Jarvis Jones get singled blocked by a skinny tight end.

Carlo Gambino: Would you share the opinion that the undisciplined performance of this team is directly correlated to the coaching staff ? Who is held more accountable for the poor defensive performance - Keith Butler ?, Mike Tomlin, ? Carnell Lake ? - who takes accountability ?

Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose they all do, but the head coach always should get most of the blame. He's at the top. It all starts with him.

ryan: Ray with all the cap space they have this coming offseason do you think that they'll go against the "Steeler Way" and actually sign some help on defense? Even after locking up Bell and AB I think they can still sign a real impact player.

Ray Fittipaldo: They might want to try something different. Eric Weddle might look good in a Steelers uniform right about now. Maybe they signed the wrong Charger.

Zack B: I know the Rooney's wont fire Tomlin, but the Pens last season is a good example of an underachieving tem that fired the coach and had great success. Why not use them as an example?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's just not how the Steelers operate. And you jjust don't see that in the NFL in places other than Cleveland. And no one wants to follow the Browns' lead.

Weeg: With Ben’s window closing do you think at this point, if the Steelers want to make a Superbowl run, will need to address the weaknesses on the defense created from poor drafting and pick up free agents? I’m not talking about blowing up the team, but ridding the team with those that can’t stay on the field, or provide the poor value.

Chuck: worst unit CBs or S? As much as Pitt fans have cried for CBs over the past decade I see some promise w Burns and Ross. I think the S play has been horrendous this season. Mitchell needs to go back to junior high math to learn angles. Safety play is the result of a lot of the big chunk plays allowed this season.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. The safeties have been disappointing especially the past few weeks.

UsedToDefendTomlin: Why is Sammie Coates struggling so much to take over the 2 spot for receiver? I know he had is finger injury recently, but he still has consistency issues. Without Bryant and Wheaton this year, Coates should have had an easier chance to shine.

Ray Fittipaldo: It's a mystery. He was so good early in the season, but he's had one catch in the past four games. Cobi Hamilton appears to have passed him on the depth chart.

Andrew: What position do the Steelers target in the early rounds of the draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just about anywhere on defense.

TomOH: Which do you think is more to blame -- the poor selection of defensive players in the draft these past several years, or the inability of the coaching staff to develop them?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a little bit of both.

CanadianSteelerFan: Given we are playing this week on the road (which this team is terrible this year) and against a sub .500 team (which Tomlin is horrible against) what are the odds we lose against Cleveland?

Ray Fittipaldo: I give the Browns about a 10 percent chance to win the game.

UsedToDefendTomlin: I whole-heartedly thought Big Ben would lead us to another Super Bowl win before he retires. I'm getting scared that he won't have that opportunity. Do you think the defense could be salvaged enough (most likely not this year) to make a legitimate Super Bowl run while Big Ben is still around? After Big Ben, in this league's current era, having no quarterback is a very scary thought.

Ray Fittipaldo: A legitimate Super Bowl run this year? No. But things change quickly in the NFL. Maybe they'll have better luck next season and better play.

Daryl: I see no emotion from our sideline / coaching staff like I did under Cowher. I like Tomlin, but I think he needs to get the troops fired up pre game and keep them fired up during the game. Do you see this as well or am I imagining things? I understand this isn't college, but even Pros need some fire.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers don't need fire. They need players who can cover and tackle and play the game of football better.

ittybitty: James Harrison got a half Sack. Correct me if I am wrong but is he now the Steelers Sack Leader and if So why didn't anybody notice it?

Ray Fittipaldo: He is. That's a nice record, but you have to remember the sack didn't become an official statistic in the NFL until 1982 so that's a shorter history. Still a nice accomplishment for James.

ittybitty: how would you rate Ladarius Greens first appearance?

Ray Fittipaldo: He only played 12 snaps. He didn't look very explosive to me. When he did catch the ball he was a possession receiver. He was billed as a YAC guy and I saw no YAC Sunday. I saw catch and get tackled.

JamesinNYC: Is there really a good team in the North? I would say no, and Steelers can still win it.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Ravens and Bengals aren't very good either, but what gives you the confidence the Steelers can take advantage of them?

AJ: What changed so much that the defense can't stop the run

Ray Fittipaldo: The personnel isn't as good as it once was.

ittybitty: is D Williams done has a Steeler? He only signed a 2yr deal and now he is hurt. do you think they will bring him back or move on?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they will move on.

mkakos: No confidence at all that the Steelers can take advantage of a poor division

Ray Fittipaldo: No. They'll have to prove me wrong.

ctmascaro: I would replace Butler with Darren Perry and hire Kevin Greene to coach the LBs...and I would do it on Wednesday.

Blitzburgh817: Steeler fan here living Dallas/Ft Worth and all I'm hearing now is how the Cowboys will win the Superbowl. Who do you feel are the strongest contenders in the AFC and NFC ?

Ray Fittipaldo: Patriots and after last night the Seahawks. I have some serious concerns about the Dallas defense.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for taking part in the chat. Sorry I couldn't get to all the questions. Ed has his chat tomorrow and Gerry Wednesday. I'll do another one next week after the Cleveland game.