POLL: Who is most to blame for the loss to the Dolphins? A. Mike Tomlin (52%) B. Todd Haley (2%) C. Ben Roethlisberger (11%) D. The defense that allowed 222 rushing yards (35%)

Steve: Any chance Steelers start Zach Mettenberger? Proven starter, really was replaced on;y when Mariotta was drafted very highly out of Oregon. He’s got to be better than Jones....

Ray Fittipaldo: I just don't see that happening. Jones got the majority of the work as the backup this summer. Mettenberger didn't come until a few days before the regular season began. I just don't think he's up to speed with the offense. But if Jones struggles or gets hurt he's the next man up so they have to make sure he's ready to play regardless.

Steve: The Steeler defense revived a career (Tannehill) SI called hopeless last week. Tannehill was sacked 17 times thru first 5 games. Sunday, w/ whole O-line together for 1st time, not sacked once, hit just 2x. What happened?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It looked to me like the Steelers defenders were either out of shape or woefully unprepared to play in the sweltering Miami heat. Either way, it's not a good look for the staff that is tasked with making sure the players are highly conditioned. Beyond that, the tackling was poor and the pass rush was nonexistent. But my opinion: those two things happened because the players weren't prepared for the conditions. Just my two cents.

Steve: Why do the Steelers systemically appear to lose motivation or just play horribly at least 2-3 X a year under Tomlin? Prior decades (80s, 90s, 00’s) Steelers would lose, but beat up the other team defensively, now every few weeks they just look “soft” .. Who should take responsibility?

Ray Fittipaldo: Everyone deserves blame from the top of the organization on down. But Tomlin said it should come to rest with him yesterday at his postgame news conference. It's happened too many times for it to be a fluke. Something is amiss with their operation or their mental approach and they'll never reach their goal of winning another Super Bowl as long as they continue to lose to teams they should beat. It hurts their seeding year after year after year. They've had to play in the wild card round in 2011, 2014 and 2015 because of these types of losses. And unless they find a remedy it looks like that will happen this season.

Dude_From_Cali: Ray, do you predict Landry Jones or Mattenberg (sp) starting?

Ray Fittipaldo: Landry Jones.

Advertise with us

MT steel: Hey Ray, thanks for the insight. So Gerry D graded pretty much every unit an F for yesterdays performance. That being said, should we be pretty worried as a team, even if Ben returns after the bye week?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure, there are plenty of reasons to be concerned after that performance. Ben played poorly before he was injured. It doesn't appear as if anyone on the offensive staff has any idea on how to defeat the wide nine rushers. The defense gave up 204 yards to a rookie running back named Jay Ajayi, who did a fair impersonation of Larry Csonka on Sunday. You want me to be optimistic after Sunday? No way. The season's not over, but they have problems and they are many, as Chuck Noll once said.

Steve: The defense made running back Jay Ajayi look like O'J Simpson. Should the Steelers invest in a sports Psychologist 1 day each week to cure the apathy they seem to show ever few weeks of the season?

Ray Fittipaldo: They could use something or someone to cure their ills when it comes to playing bad teams.

NJSteel fan: Hi Ray, thanks for the chat.! With all the injuries, some extended time wise, do you see any signings, or a trade, to bolster the roster?? Thank you

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: We'll see, but they have the bye week after New England so a lot of those guys could be ready for the Baltimore game in early November. They're always looking to upgrade their roster, but I think they bye week will help them with regards to their health.

SteveStone: Poor tackling , bad positioning by the linebackers, or coaching scheme? Which caused the poor run defense to rear its ugly head again?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin and the players blamed poor tackling after the game.

Steve: Timmons said performance was "just not the Steeler Way" . Not really true anymore the penchant for losing games to inferior teams has become a signature for Mike Tomlin (Dulac), but I don’t blame Tomlin, I blame the players, am I more right or wrong?

Ray Fittipaldo: As I said before, everyone should get some blame. The problem is Tomlin has overseen the ineptitude and the players change. Of course, it's going to rest with him because he's been around for all of them. It's his job as a head coach to figure it out. That's why they pay him $7 million a year.

Advertise with us

WAROnTheRock: My biggest worry out of this is not only how DeCastro has, in my Armchair Yinzer opinion, grossly under-performed all season but Pouncey as well...they seem to be getting beat up the middle quite a bit...

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not defending the offensive line. I wrote this morning on the Steelers blog at post-gazette.com that it's time for them to step up their game. But I also think Todd Haley can help them out by running the ball more, especially against teams that use the wide nine rushers. If you establish the run early against those types of teams they can't just tee off on your quarterback when you get behind. Plus, I think it can help in other ways such as setting up play-action passing and maybe get some of that double coverage away from Antonio Brown.

Joey: what do you suppose would happen if this injury trend with shazier continues each and every year of his rookie contract i.e. the misses maybe eight games every season at least. What would the Steelers options be, let him walk, sign into a smaller contract, move him to safety? what's your guess on what they would do?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he's a guy you want to keep because of his potential, but they'll point out his injury history in negotiations and tell his agent why he's not going to make top dollar for an inside linebacker. Then it'll be up to Shazier and his agent to decide if they want to test the free agent market. But if I'm the Steelers there is no way I'm giving him a top contract for an ILB. He just doesn't play enough snaps to warrant that.

Mikey: How does Haley not want to feed Bell the ball? And why does Haley insist on coming out in exotic formations to begin the game. Just let your "Jims and Jimmys" play. Too often does he outsmart himself

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He certainly outsmarted himself on that third-and-1 call. He had a bad game Sunday along with everyone else.

nevsky187: What is the Steelers' record if Roethlisberger misses a significant amount of time? I know they weathered 4 games last season alright but the next three games are very tough. If he misses the who year I'm thinking 5-11; 4 games, 9-7.

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure he misses more than one game. They have the bye week after the Patriots. He had surgery this morning so it'll be three weeks by the time they play the Ravens. But if he misses two games I'd say they need to find a way to win one of them. Go 1-1 and get him back for Dallas and you'll be fine.

WAROnTheRock: Who was the Stillers' 3rd QB yesterday? DHB?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they would have used Le'Veon Bell in the wildcat. Antonio Brown can play some QB too.

Advertise with us

Will Mettenberger ...: Why do we lose to teams that we should beat? Every year we lose to 2-3 teams that we should beat!

Ray Fittipaldo: Injuries contributed to the loss in Miami, but it's been a problem for years when injuries haven't been as prevalent. It has to fall on the coaches to prepare the team better.

Jim: I know injuries have played somewhat of a role but the defense seems worse this year does it not?

Ray Fittipaldo: Against Philly and Miami, yes. They bent but didn't break against the others and they managed to win the games. But that run D performance was discouraging to say the least.

Matt: Hi Ray. Is the conversation between Tomlin and Keith Butler any different after this game, i.e MT getting in his face a bit, or is this chalked up to another loss in the NFL and it happens?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No one had a good day for the Steelers, but at least the defense held things together into the third quarter. They forced field goals early in the game and gave the offense time to turn things around.

Frank: This looks like a totally different defense than last year. I expected some growing pains with the new players but not this. Is this the worst defense in the league?

Ray Fittipaldo: No it's not the worst defense in the league, but it can look bad at times when there is no pass rush and teams are gashing them in the run game (Miami) and screen game (Philly).

JamesinNYC: Just run the D@mm ball! Am I the only one to blame Haley? Seemed like a bad game plan...other than the DHB run.

Ray Fittipaldo: In hindsight, yes. But Roethlisberger had been playing so well in the previous two games. I have a hard time blaming Haley for building a game plan around his star QB. I think where the blame lies is in the play-calling. When Haley sees things go awry with his QB he has to change the game plan on the run. It was obvious Roethlisberger wasn't playing well before the injury. He had a chance to modify the game plan at halftime and didn't so some blame has to fall on him.

Advertise with us

Bill: So the Steelers are playing Tom Brady without Ben at home. Nice! How big of a loss are you predicting? I'd say at least 20 points.

Ray Fittipaldo: You might be generous there.

vasteeler: there are rumors going around that players were vomiting and fatigued as a result of partying/drinking while in miami. do you think there is possibly any truth to this? it's been known to happen to mlb and nba teams.

Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't heard anything along those lines. And the team didn't stay in South Beach.

Sam: This is a 9-7 or 10-6 team just like last year. Injuries played a part but the defense looks worse this year. What happened to them? I thought they looked good in last year's playoffs

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They've actually looked OK in four of the six games. Yeah, they give up yardage, but they've clamped down and kept teams from scoring touchdowns in the other four games.

Ike Steelheart: Do you see The Steelers still having a chance for a top seed in the AFC? Should we be ready again for a Wild Card Spot since all injuries?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think playing on wild card weekend will happen again and it's because of losses like the one Sunday. The Patriots simply don't lose to teams like that even when they have injuries to their best players.

Alan: Injuries aside, I think the biggest issue with the steelers is the lack of playmakers on defense. They can't get pressure and their DBs can't catch. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Might have been a different game if Will gay didn't channel Ike Taylor and bat that ball down like a volleyball player in the second quarter.

Advertise with us

Tom88: How in the world does Haley not hand off to Bell but has Jones throw a pass on 3rd & 1?

Ray Fittipaldo: One of the more baffling calls of the century. Maybe Tomlin can shed some light on the subject tomorrow at his news conference.

Rich: I've always been wondering why we haven't brought in any veteran DB help (before the season started). I get the whole develop the young guy mind set. But they (Burns/Davis) just arent ready for the pro game, tackling is terrible! Team is too good to experiment with starting rookies, Agree Ray??

Ray Fittipaldo: They don't commit free agent dollars to the CB position. They haven't in a very long time. They like to keep their own and develop the draft picks. You can criticize that decision, but you also have to acknowledge the lack of a pass rush is a big reason teams like the Dolphins do well versus the Steelers.

guest: any update on Ben? also read a wild and I mean wild rumour that because the injury is relatively minor and arthroscopic there's an outside chance Ben 'could' play sunday.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Highly doubt it. The bye week should allow a complete heal or close to it by the time of the Baltimore game.

Guest: The officiating yesterday seemed pretty bad or is that just me?

Ray Fittipaldo: Some missed calls, but not the reason the Steelers lost.

Troy: Ray, Do the Steelers even have a snowball's chance in heck this Sunday? Give us something to feel good about.

Ray Fittipaldo: If Le'Veon Bell rushes for 275 yards they'll be in the game.

Advertise with us

Guest: everyone wants to blame tomlin for not beating teams they should beat, however, that trend has occurred since the defense went from being one of the tops in the league to mediocre starting in 2011. I think they have 1 playoff win since the defense went from being one of the tops in the league. To me the trend is that the offense and especially Ben, is not consistent enough to take this team deep into the playoffs. In the past the defense could shut the other teams down, but that doesn't happen anymore. We need to outscore teams but we cant do that consistently.

Ray Fittipaldo: Fair take. The offense has been very good, but not consistently good enough.

Steve: Do you think DeAngelo should be used more consistently in this offense. I admit I'm a fan of DeAngelo in general, but he seems to be more of a grind it out back, positive yardage , not big chunks then nothing type back like LeVeon more often is..

Ray Fittipaldo: Can we concentrate on getting Le'Veon Bell more involved and then worry about Williams? Sheesh.

Will: I do not understand this defense. Granted they are good in the redzone but it seems like every drive ends up in the redzone. With that opposing teams can keep the ball away from our offense. Can they make any improvements at all?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose they can blitz more and take more chances. I suppose they can play press coverage on receivers when it's third-and-2 instead of giving a six-yard cushion. I see some really questionable things like everyone else, but they've decided the bend but don't break is their best option to win. It's been six weeks now. Maybe they'll change some things up after the Miami loss, but it's quite evident they believed it was their best course of action before the season.

Ike Steelheart: How guilty is Garrett Giemont for all these injuries and bad conditioning?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think people will certainly take a closer look at him and his methods after this game. He already had the injury thing working against him and then the players came up with cramps and heat-related illnesses on top of it. It doesn't shine a very good light on him and his staff.

Will: Patriots are going to win by 40 on Sunday.

Ray Fittipaldo: Do I hear 50?

Advertise with us

Guest: The defense only do so much and we know they are not that good. But the offense is supposed to be one of the best in the league. 30 points a game is laughable.

Ray Fittipaldo: It wasn't laughable the past two games. But they sure are inconsistent, aren't they?

Guest: Can someone tell Ben that he can't play like he has the best defense in the league anymore. When he makes dumb plays and turns the ball over, the other teams scores now! He needs to play smart and play to the huge contract he has

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he already realizes that. It very well could be he thinks he has to do too much because the defense isn't up to the old standards.

PaulL: Do you agree that our defense is more vulverable because the younger OLB's aren't holding the edge and able to get to the QB?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the lack of a pass rush is a huge problem, but what about Stephon Tuitt? Why is he absolved from blame? What about Javon Hargrave. It was two defensive linemen who led the team in sacks last season. Where are they now? We all knew the OLBs were average. The starting defensive ends were supposed to carry this team. I understand Heyward has been injured, but that still doesn;t explain why Tuitt hasn't been very good.

JamesinNYC: Funny Ben complains about hard practices then they run out of gas in Miami...maybe the practices were too easy?

Ray Fittipaldo: I thought the same thing. Maybe not the hard-hitting part that he complained about, but the lack of conditioning was really noticeable. How does that happen? How does an NFL with professional players show up for a game so woefully unprepared to deal with the conditions?

PaulL: I know it will take time, but is a 4-3 defense an better option? We haven't fixed teh secondary in years,m and the quality of defense continues to slide

Ray Fittipaldo: They don't play base 3-4 a whole heck of a lot now. Only a handful of snaps a game. They're in nickel most of the game.

Big Mike: Hi Ray - Tomlin is consistently considered one of the best coaches in the league (although I disagree). However, we constantly play down to opponents and players are undisciplined (i.e. Mitchell's penalties). These issues are really starting to hurt us. Why does Tomlin and the rest of the staff always get a pass??

Ray Fittipaldo: The Mitchell stuff is ridiculous. But you're right. The head coach allows that stuff to go on. No one else is going to police it. But it's tough to argue with the job Tomlin has done overall. He finds ways to get into the playoffs more often than not. That's not good enough for this fan base, but you have to take a look around at what other teams are getting out of their head coach. Would you rather have Marvin Lewis?

Bob: just being quite optimistic here but is it totally out of the question that ben channels his inner willis reed and plays this weekend?

Ray Fittipaldo: Would be surprised.

From the Poconos: It seems that for whatever reason MT can't solve the issue of losing to teams like Miami. It also seems that the Rooney's value the good things he brings to the table higher than winning these games. That being said, we probably just need to get used to it, no?

Ray Fittipaldo: You mean you're not used to it already? I am.

Bob: any update on Ladarius since he's off the pup now?

Ray Fittipaldo: He can practice Wednesday. But the Steelers have a three-week window to decide if/when to activate him. It doesn't have to be this week. The guy hasn't practiced yet with the Steelers. I don't see how he'd add a bunch of value in this game, especially with Landry Jones at QB.

Chuck: last years D wasn't great but they were able to get sacks and turnovers. This year neither is happening. 1 sack from OLB and no INTs by secondary this year. What gives w the dramatic drop off in those 2 areas?

Ray Fittipaldo: They work hand in hand. A pass rush would help the secondary and the secondary covering better would help the pass rush. But both aren't holding up their end of the bargain and you're getting games like yesterday when Ryan Tannehill looks like Bob Griese or Dan Marino. (OK, maybe David Woodley).

gregg: I know he's an aggressive player, but why does Mitchell continue with the unnecessary roughness penalties. Didn't need to make it even easier for Miami.

Ray Fittipaldo: Again, you're not used to this nonsense either. It continually happens under Tomlin's watch. It's up to him to put an end to it.

Brandonn: Should the steelers take a page from the cowboys and draft a quarterback for the future? Ben cant seem to say healthy and the Steelers have a good young running back, strong oline, and good receivers. Very similar to the Cowboys situation.

Ray Fittipaldo: It's never a bad idea to develop a QB. Perhaps they'll consider that in the spring, but I had no problem with the way they approached this year's draft. They needed help in the secondary and they addressed the lines in the third and fourth rounds.

WAROnTheRock: IN RE officiating, the Stillers' series died after the missed horse collar that everyone minus the one person who mattered saw...

Ray Fittipaldo: Ed Hochuli was to busy rolling up his sleeves to see it.

Chuck: if Shazier comes back, any chance on subbing Vince Williams in for LT some as LT just isn't what he use to be?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's a possibility, sure. Timmons obviously didn't deal well with the heat on Sunday.

Big Mike: If Ben only misses 1 or 2 games I do not completely think we are out of the picture to get a first round playoff bye. After the Patriots, much of the AFC is up for grabs. Do you agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: To a point. But Denver's defense is capable of carrying that team for a portion of the season. And a team like Houston can stack some wins in its weak division and get a high seed. And don't forget about the Raiders. If they can straighten out their defense they have a chance to win their division.

Acero: is all about the QB in the NFl to be succesfull .. I cannot believe having Bell & Brown we dont have any chance to win Sunday.

Ray Fittipaldo: They're playing the Patriots, you know.

PaulL: Should the Carnell Lake experiment over? If Coach Tomlin is know's the cover-2 scheme so well, why have they struggled? Thee are vets that play well, speed isn't an issue. What is the issue?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if it's all Lake's fault, but I'd like to know why they're playing well off receivers on third-and-2. It's never that easy for the Steelers to convert in those situations. It seems like the Steelers almost invite othe teams to catch 3-yard hitches for first downs.

JIm: Am I reading too much into his comments, or is there an issue between Ben and Antonio ?

Ray Fittipaldo: Antonio is never really happy unless he's putting up big numbers. But there might be something there behind the scenes as well.

Chuck: The 3rd and 1 call in 2Q w Jones making first pass attempt was a critical play in the game. Since LB's return we have gone away from the run. Majority of Jets game was in shotgun. Yesterday vs bad run D we never gave it a chance. Is Haley getting too cute and pass happy? Oline issues too are usually helped when you can establish run just ask Miami. Get the ground game back right?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, you ready my blog this morning. Good job.

bill: Get real people you all said the same stuff after the Philly game.There were very few complaints for you fans after that.RELAX

Ray Fittipaldo: We have an optimist in our midst.

Ike Steelheart: I really think that when James Farrior left the team, the Defense has never been the same, we don´t need a special player like Shazier, we need a Captain and real leader on the Defense! We don't have any and certainly we haven't looked for somebody like that on the Draft!

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Heyward is a fine leader when healthy. After him, I'm not sure.

Butch: If pundits around the league don't realize it now, Cam Heyward is one of the best Dl in the NFL, glaring absence, especially in stopping the run, hope he is back soon, teams will gash this D on the ground.

Big Mike: Any thoughts to Brown being relatively quiet on and off the field the last couple weeks (compared to the first few)?

Ray Fittipaldo: They're not consistently figuring out ways to make defenses pay for double teaming him. They did in a few games and won those, but they looked really bad trying to beat Philly and Miami.

Dave: I love Ed and his work but respectfully disagree with his article basically saying football is violent and it's unfair to label guys as injury prone. Ben is the definition of injury prone. It's something new every year with him. He's only played 16 games 3 times in his career. 3! His draft counterparts he is often compared to- Rivers and Eli- have never missed a game. Not one. I know Ed's opinion. What is your opinion?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ben has had knee problems so you might be right about chronic injuries, but there are so many other quarterbacks who are not as tough and reliable as he is. There are 28 or 29 other teams in the NFL that would kill to have him on their roster.

Ike Steelheart: Let's imagine The Steelers with all these injuries (including Ben) have Belichick as a coach, and The Pats have Tomlin, who wins the game?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't have a crystal ball, but Belichick didn't win in Cleveland without Tom Brady.

Mark: Assuming Ben comes back for the Ravens game, what is your prediction for the Steelers record?

Ray Fittipaldo: Impossible to predict with all the injuries they've had and might have in the future.

Acero: Where did we play worst? At Philly or Miami. Just imagine Belicheat enjoying the videos.

Ray Fittipaldo: It's a tie!

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. I wasn't able to get to all of them, but come back tomorrow and Wednesday for Ed and Gerry's chats. I'll do another next Monday.