Back in the quaint old days, the NFL would hold its college player draft in January, two weeks after they played the Super Bowl.
The greatest team draft in history was conducted Jan. 29-30, 1974, when the Steelers picked four future Hall of Famers in the first five rounds. They did so without benefit of the Indianapolis combine, without pro days, without 30 prospect visits, without digital tapes and analytics — and without three extra months to kick things around. They did not even have the advice from not just one but four Mel Kiper mock drafts.
It’s a wonder NFL teams make mistakes any more in the draft with all the information and time available to them. But they do. You have to look no further than Cleveland, where in 2014 the Browns were prepared to turn things around, starting with two first-round draft choices, and chose cornerback Justin Gilbert with the eighth pick and quarterback Johnny Manziel with the 22nd.
As Chuck Noll often said, the draft is no science, and the Browns are not alone in upholding that notion.
Starting Thursday and continuing through Saturday, many NFL teams will prove it again as they work their way through seven rounds of the draft (eight, really, counting compensatory picks).
One thing they almost all agree on, however, is that it will be difficult to go wrong by drafting a defensive lineman this week, because that position is brimming with quality and quantity.
Read More
“I don’t know if it’s super deep anywhere, but I think defensive line is where it goes,’’ said Tom Modrak, the executive director of the Blesto scouting service, of which the Steelers belong. “Yes, it’s deep and there will be some good players at those positions, defensive tackle and defensive end. Put that together and it’s pretty damn good.”
Six or seven defensive linemen could be drafted in the first round Thursday night, although some may be listed as outside linebackers for 3-4 defenses.
“I think you’re still going to get good [defensive linemen] in the third and fourth round,’’ said Tom Donahoe, who headed the drafts of the Steelers and Bills and is now Philadelphia’s senior personnel executive. “There’s usually not that many of them because they go pretty quickly. There’s good depth, especially defensive tackle.’’
Two defensive ends, Joey Bosa of Ohio State and DeForest Buckner of Oregon, could be among the first five players chosen Thursday night when, for the second consecutive year, the draft is held in Chicago.
For those who prefer their battles in the trenches, dig in because it’s also loaded on the other side, especially with offensive tackle talent.
“The strength of the draft is both offensive and defensive linemen,’’ said Gil Brandt, senior analyst for NFL.com and the Dallas Cowboys’ player personnel director or 30 years. “There are some very good players.’’
Tackle Laremy Tunsil of Mississippi was projected by many to be the first pick in the draft before Tennessee traded it to the Los Angeles Rams. Now, he may fall as far as sixth to the Baltimore Ravens. Nevertheless, he will be the first of perhaps four tackles, a guard and even a center to fly off the board Thursday night.
That means there could be 12 or 13 linemen, offense and defense, drafted in the first round, which leaves 18 or 19 spots on the first day (New England lost its first-round pick to Deflategate) for other positions.
Leading off will be the glamour position. The Rams traded a boatload of draft picks to Tennessee for the right to move from 15th in the first round to first and they did not do so to draft a tackle. They will select almost surely one of the two quarterbacks seen as head-to-head in the competition to go first — Carson Wentz of North Dakota State or Jared Goff of California.
Cleveland traded the No. 2 pick to Philadelphia for more picks, and the Eagles will select the quarterback the Rams do not take.
Paxton Lynch of Memphis is generally rated No. 3 and should go somewhere in the first round.
After that?
“I’ll tell you this,’’ Brandt said, “another strength in this draft is second echelon of quarterbacks.’’
Rarely, however, does a second echelon hit it big. There is only one Tom Brady, who was drafted in the sixth round. More typical is a Landry Jones, the Steelers’ fourth-round pick in 2013 who is still trying to establish himself as a No. 2.
Opinions seem to vary on the strength of wide receivers available.
Said Brandt, “It’s not very good, wide receiver-wise. Yet there are some guys who can come to the top, like Will Fuller from Notre Dame. He ran [the 40-yard dash in] 4.32 [seconds]. It’s amazing, when you run 4.32 you somehow become a better player and more important to a team.”
Said Donahoe, “I think it’s a decent wide receiver group.’’
The position has become more important in the NFL as the passing game continues to dominate, so teams that need wide receivers may reach a little higher. For example Kiper, who needs no introduction, picked four wide receivers in the first round of his most recent mock draft and six more in the second round.
And the other positions? Not great for guards and centers; good for outside linebackers; so-so in the defensive backfield, both at cornerback and safety (get them early or wait to get a good one next year), and poor for tight ends. One running back sticks out, Ohio State’s Ezekiel Elliott, and then there’s a dropoff.
It’s not a draft anyone would label as “sexy,’’ but Brandt has an idea as to why. There were 96 underclassmen granted eligibility for the draft, second-most in history and only two behind the record number of 2014. That is 22 more than last year.
“Why do people question this draft?” Brandt asked. “Because there’s not a lot of [identity] in this draft. When a lot of guys come out early, we don’t see them play three years of college football and consequently we don’t get the name value out of them.
“There are some very good players in this draft. I’m just going over my list now. I’m in the 40s now — these guys in my 40s are going to be good players.”
And some will not. After all, it’s no science.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.