Of the 23 modern-era quarterbacks enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, only two have gone out as champions. Otto Graham of the Cleveland Browns won an NFL championship and retired after the 1955 season and John Elway of the Denver Broncos did the same after the 1998 season. For the 21 others, it was an assortment of sad or anticlimactic endings.

Colts legend Johnny Unitas played his final season for the San Diego Chargers in 1973. In his final NFL game, he relieved rookie Dan Fouts in a 19-0 loss and left the game after a shoulder injury. New York Jets icon Joe Namath, on damaged knees, finished his career with the Los Angeles Rams in 1977. He threw four interceptions in his final game against the Chicago Bears.

From the sad to the horrific, Dan Marino exited with his final memory being a 62-7 playoff loss against the Jacksonville Jaguars after the 1999 season. He threw for 95 yards and two interceptions, falling three victories shy of the Super Bowl title that always eluded him.

Terry Bradshaw, who had hopes of winning a fifth Super Bowl ring, could not finish the final game he started Dec. 10, 1983 against the Jets at Shea Stadium, because of the pain in his injured throwing arm. Bradshaw didn’t go out a champion, but his final pass was a touchdown to Calvin Sweeney.

Advertise with us

Storybook endings don’t happen often, but Denver quarterback Peyton Manning is in position to have one.

Manning, a shoo-in to be enshrined after he retires, has a chance to follow in the footsteps of Elway, now the Broncos general manager and executive vice president. The Broncos are the No. 1 seed in the AFC and have homefield advantage throughout the playoffs.

The end is near for Manning, who will quarterback the Broncos against the Steelers in an AFC divisional-round game at 4:40 p.m. Sunday at Sports Authority Field at Mile High. He is 39, had to take a $4 million pay cut in March to remain with the team and spent the second half of the season on the injured list.

All signs point to this season being his final one in Denver. Manning has thrown nine touchdowns and 17 interceptions. His completion percentage is the lowest it has been since his rookie season in 1998. In his most recent start in November, he was 5 for 20 and threw four interceptions in a loss against Kansas City Chiefs.

Like Unitas late in his career, Manning was sent to the bench in favor of a younger player while he tried to rehabilitate foot and rib injuries. He missed six games and didn’t play again until the regular-season finale against the Chargers, when he relieved an ineffective Brock Osweiler and led the Broncos to a 27-20 victory that secured the No. 1 seed.

Advertise with us

Though it could be his final trip to the postseason, Manning said he does not feel any more pressure.

“In the playoffs, you certainly just want to do your job to help your team win, no matter how old you are or how long you’ve been playing,” Manning said. “There’s no difference. This year has been a unique year with the injuries and not playing the entire time. I was pleased to be available in the last game of the season against San Diego.

“I certainly am glad to be available to play and looking forward to being out there. We feel fortunate to be one of the eight teams still playing. It’s an exciting time and I never take for granted this opportunity.”

Was his performance in the fourth quarter against the Chargers, when he was 5 for 9 for 69 yards, a short spurt or a prelude to a special ending?

It sets the stage for a dramatic Sunday afternoon. Manning is 11-13 in playoff games, including a 2-3 with the Broncos. He twice lost home games after the Broncos secured byes to the divisional round, losing to the Baltimore Ravens in 2012 and the Indianapolis Colts a year ago.

Advertise with us

A decade ago, Manning did the same when he was the quarterback of the top-seeded Colts. The sixth-seeded Steelers went to Indianapolis and beat the Colts en route to the Super Bowl XL title.

Former Colts Manning and Unitas have much in common. Their golden arms won championships and delighted fans. But injuries took their toll late in their careers and both swallowed their pride to serve as reserves.

Five years before Unitas played his final season in San Diego, he served as a backup to Earl Morrall for the Baltimore Colts in 1968. In Super Bowl III against Namath and the Jets, the Colts trailed, 16-0, in the fourth quarter and coach Don Shula replaced an ineffective Morrall with Unitas.

“Similar odds had been conquered before with John Unitas at quarterback,” Steve Sabol wrote and John Facenda famously narrated for NFL Films. “But now, with his famous passing arm no more than a tattered memory, he could only offer a fighting heart and a will to win. With only three minutes to play, all the hopes and dreams of an entire season rested on the shoulders of one man, one old pro.

“One last moment for the master.”

Advertise with us

Unitas led a late surge, but the Colts lost, 16-7.

What moment awaits Manning?

The Broncos prefer another iconic Super Bowl moment. There were two for Elway. His helicopter landing after diving for a first down in Super Bowl XXXII pointed the way to victory against the Green Bay Packers. Following the dramatic, 31-24 victory, Broncos owner Pat Bowlen announced: “This one’s for John.”

Elway came back the next season and led the Broncos to another Super Bowl victory before retiring.

Now the Steelers will play a part in what could be Manning’s final playoff run.

Advertise with us

It could be the beginning of dramatic three-act play that concludes in California for Super Bowl 50. Or it could mark a sudden and sad ending to a Hall of Fame career that football fans have witnessed many times before.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.