The old adage in the NFL used to be defense wins championships. The new adage is if you don’t have a quarterback you don’t have a chance.
In 2015, the NFL remains a quarterback-driven league. Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger and Peyton Manning are playoffs and among the favorites to lead to their teams to a conference championship. But other Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks such as Eli Manning, Drew Brees and Joe Flacco are not.
Having an elite quarterback still gives your team the best chance to advance in the NFL playoffs, but Houston Texans are going to make a run at the Super Bowl with Brian Hoyer. The Kansas City Chiefs and the Washington Redskins are going to try with Alex Smith and Kirk Cousins. And the Cincinnati Bengals, at least at the beginning of the tournament, are going to try to win with backup AJ McCarron.
So how have teams with quarterback problems become Super Bowl contenders?
It’s quite simple really. They’ve turned back the clock to an era when defense mattered most.
Eleven of the 12 teams in the playoffs are among the top 12 scoring defenses in the league. The only outlier is Washington, which ranks 17th in the league in points allowed.
Read More
Compare that to last season when only six of the 12 teams in the playoffs had top 12 scoring defenses. The Steelers made the playoffs with a defense that ranked in the bottom half of the league in points allowed. So did the Broncos and Panthers.
All three had franchise quarterbacks and only the Panthers won a game. And they only won one before getting knocked out in the divisional round.
While no one will confuse this Steelers defense with the ones from 2008 or 2010 Super Bowl teams, it has improved dramatically when it comes to yielding points. The Steelers allowed 49 fewer points this season, or what averages out to three points per game. They allowed 19.9 points per game and finished just outside the top 10 in scoring defenses at No. 11.
“Last year we definitely put some stuff out there that we weren’t very proud of,” linebacker Arthur Moats said. “We understood what we did that was good, and we tried to maximize that. This year, we’ve improved a lot in that area.”
The Steelers have kept their offensive identity and made small improvements to their defense in hopes it will be enough for a Super Bowl run. Another prominent AFC team has completely changed its identity over the past two years in hopes of bringing home the Lombardi Trophy.
The Broncos are a perfect example of a team that’s changed to a more defensive-minded approach. They set the NFL record most points scored in a season in 2013, but the Seattle Seahawks, with the league’s top defense, beat them in the Super Bowl, 43-6.
After that loss, Broncos team president John Elway went out and signed high-priced defensive players to strengthen his team. Top-notch defenders such as Demarcus Ware and Aqib Talib were added in free agency and future Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning had to take a pay cut to remain with the team.
The Broncos are the No. 1 seed in the AFC this year with home-field advantage throughout the playoffs, and their team is built in a completely different way than it was two years ago. They finished the regular season with the No. 19 offense and the No. 4 defense.
There had been a growing trend in recent years for Super Bowl champions to be better offensively than defensively. From 2006-14, the average defensive rank for the Super Bowl champion was 12.1 while the average offensive rank was 8.7.
The 2011 New York Giants won the Super Bowl when they were 25th in points allowed, the lowest defensive rank ever for a Super Bowl champion. In 2009, the Saints won it all with the 20th-ranked defense and in 2006 the Colts won with the 23rd-ranked defense.
The Steelers bucked that trend in 2008 when they won it all with the No. 1 defense and the 20th-ranked offense, the lowest-rated offense to ever hoist the Lombardi Trophy.
For the first 40 years of the Super Bowl era from 1966-2005, the opposite almost always held true. A top 10 defense won the Super Bowl in all but two years in those four decades. Only the Raiders bucked the trend in 1976 (12th) and 1983 (13th).
This season the offenses in the playoffs are strong, but the defenses are stronger. The average offensive rank for teams in the playoffs is 9.3 while it’s 7.1 for the defenses.
One season of the top defenses composing the playoff field doesn’t mean the trend is going to reverse completely, but it could signal something of a change in philosophy when it comes to building contenders.
“I don’t think that will ever change,” Steelers linebacker Sean Spence said. “You always have to have a good defense to win championships and win games. Offenses will score points, but somebody has to stop them. You have to get stops to win games, especially in the postseason.”
That’s why teams with quarterback problems have a fighting chance in the playoffs. Cincinnati is No. 2 in the league in scoring defense and allowed just 17.4 points per game during the regular season. If the Steelers advance, the Broncos, with the fourth-ranked defense (18.5 ppg), are the next opponent.
And if they are good enough to advance to the AFC championship game the three possible opponents are Kansas City, Houston and New England, all top 10 scoring defenses.
Ben Roethlisberger and the Steelers offense really do have their work cut out for them.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.