Nick in VA: It feels to me like the official's are "short" spotting the football all year this year. That 3rd down catch that Brown made yesterday at the end of the 1st half, watching on TV, it looked like he caught the ball at the first down line. When they actually marked it, he lost a yard. And for some reason they held the spot on review. Have you noticed the same thing this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: There are always some questionable spots from officials. It's an inexact science. On the play you're talking about, the angle I saw in the press box showed he caught the ball near the first down marker. I didn't think it was conclusive. But I haven't noticed it being a problem more than any other season. They try their best and sometimes they make mistakes. It's part of the game, and coaches do have the ability to challenge spots.

Guest: After yesterday's game, would it be fair to say that the Steelers "broke" the Bengals? I've rarely seen a game where one team just so decidedly put a damper on another's playoff chances/season.

Ray Fittipaldo: It was a pretty grim Bengals locker room. AJ Green was talking about how you needed luck to win the Super Bowl. It's understandable they would be so down. But they're professionals and if Marvin Lewis is any kind of a coach he'll get them to regroup. They still have a great chance to earn a bye and get a home playoff game. They have to try to make that happen and then hope Andy Dalton is healthy enough to make it back for the playoffs. I have my doubts about that, but the Bengals can't let those thoughts creep into their heads as the finish the season.

Advertise with us

Nick in VA: Is it just me, or is the Browns game week 17 the scariest one on the schedule? That one feels like a big trap.

Ray Fittipaldo: Nah. For me, Denver. The Broncos have a very good defense. I might agree with you that the Browns might be more difficult than the Ravens at this point, but I just can't say that about the Browns and Broncos.

Guest: If the Steelers are in the playoffs if they win out, why are they shown as the first team out every time they show that AFC playoffs graphic on TV?

Ray Fittipaldo: Because the Jets only have two AFC games left and the Steelers have three. Once the Steelers catch up, assuming the win out, they'll tie the Jets with 8-4 conference records. Then it goes to record in common games. The Steelers win that tiebreaker.

Touchdown Joey: Dalton was moving the ball like a knife through butter before the somewhat flukey Tuitt pick. How do you think that game would have played out had Andy Dalton not gotten injured Ray?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Fluky? You mean when a 300-pound defensive does film study, reads the play and the intercepts a pass at his knees? That kind of fluky? Come on, give Tuitt some credit. That would be like saying what would have happened if Ben Roethlisberger didn't get picked off midway through the fourth quarter of that game at Heinz Field. It happened, and he took the responsibility. Dalton did the same.

Igor: Hi Ray, two questions about the officiating....should the officials have flagged Burfict for his pregame shoving to gain control earlier? Also, a crack back block was called that really confused me, was that a stretch or what?

Ray Fittipaldo: First off, I didn't understand the crack back call. I'll have to watch it again to see if I can figure out what they saw. As far as the pregame scuffle goes, the officials certainly could have done a better job of preventing that whether it was through penalties or simply keeping the players away from each other. They are supposed to be authority figures and they were nowhere to be found when that all started.

Juanus: I'm not one to complain overly about officiating, but do you think the NFL will address in anyway the zebras not throwing an excessive celebration flag on the Bengals player who "punted" the ball in the end zone yesterday?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a fine. Not sure if it's a penalty to be honest with you. I know the Steelers vehemently protested to officials and then officials explained to the coaches their thought process.

Advertise with us

Steeltyke: Hi Ray. The Steelers are currently the no. 7 seed in the AFC tied at 8-5 with the Chiefs and Jets who are seeds No.s 5 & 6. It is said that if the Steelers win out to 11-5 they make the playoffs. But if the Chiefs & Jets win out they also will be 11-5. What is it in the tie breakers that puts the Steelers ahead of either of those teams given that they are currently behind both.

Ray Fittipaldo: See above answer. Record in common games with the Jets. Steelers have the better record in such games.

Raymond: I thought Ben's decision to throw the ball on his lone interception was OK, but he made a bad throw (inside and short). Did he mention that play after the game?

Ray Fittipaldo: I went to the Bengals locker room to report on their players and their reaction to the game. I didn't get a chance to talk with Ben.

Moe Mentum: Trading field goals for touchdowns is becoming a hallmark of this Offense. Is it schemes or execution or?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They're middle of the pack in red zone offense. At least they were before the game against the Bengals. They need to be better in that area, but about half the league fares worse with their red-zone offense.

Ddog: When a wide receiver lines up and points to the sideline, is he just checking with the Ref to make sure he is lined up behind the line of scrimmage?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes.

Bernard: Denver loses vs Pitt and loses one of Cincy/SD, KC wins out (Balt, Cleve, Oak) and wins division (better division record). Pitt beats out Denver for wildcard (head to head win). Possible??

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about your scenario, but there is one out there where the Broncos finish 11-5 and miss the playoffs. In the scenario I saw the Steelers were the No. 5 seed, the Jets the No. 6 seed and the Chiefs the No. 3 seed and the champs of the AFC West.

Advertise with us

Hammer59: Do you feel that the refs cracked down on the wrong team yesterday? I seemed to me that the Steelers received more personal foul/unsportman's like conduct calls than the Bungles, even though it seemed that most of that activity was happening on the other side of the ball.

Ray Fittipaldo: Mitchell probably deserved a personal foul for striking Eifert in the head even though Eifert was sliding to the ground as contact was made. Mitchell could have led with his shoulder there and not his helmet. But there were plenty the officials missed on the Bengals, the most egregious of which was Vontaze Burfict diving into Roethlisberger's ankle two seconds after he released the ball. How a referee misses that is beyond me. It's his job and his job only to watch the QB for late hits.

Bernard: Hmm, this injury worked out great for Andy, he finishes with a stellar season, no ridicule from losing in the playoffs or to the Stillers.

Le Roi: Is it me or Boykan did not see that much snaps yesterday?

Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't seen the snap counts yet, but I thought he saw the field more after Green beat Blake for that 68-yard touchdown.

Advertise with us

Touchdown Joey: Was the Mitchell shot on Eiffert clean in your opinion?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just explained this a few answers above.

Nick in VA: Villanueva looked pretty solid to me again yesterday. Is this guy getting better and better or is just me? Also, I never did hear why they were looking at him on the sideline. What was the injury and is it going to be an issue next week?

Ray Fittipaldo: The report from Steelers PR was AV was ill though I saw some tweets from people suggesting he was getting checked for a concussion.

Leon: Please tell me we aren't buying into this defense yet. Their one big move was taking Andy Dalton out for the rest of the year, but if he wasn't injured he'd have picked them apart

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Good to know you have a crystal ball and can tell us what would have happened. How do you know it wouldn't have been a repeat of his Heinz Field performance when he threw two INTs and was generally ineffective until late in the game when the Steelers gifted him great field position with two turnovers of their own?

Zack B: Why is Blake playing at all? He was terrible again Sunday.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they like him on run downs because he is better against the run than Boykin, but they might have to question that decision now. Teams will begin to target him whenever he is in the game if he continues to give up big plays.

Guest: Why are the 'experts' saying the Steelers are a dangerous team. With that defensive backfield?

Ray Fittipaldo: They are a dangerous team because they can score with anyone in the league. If the offense is rolling there is no reason they can;t beat anyone in a high-scoring game. Not saying that can happen in four consecutive games and they'll win the Super Bowl, but "dangerous" doesn't mean Super Bowl or bust. It means surprise for a round or two in the playoffs.

Advertise with us

RLP: I'm a little surprised ALL of those calls went against the steelers yesterday, as the Bengals were certainly fighting too. Bias against the team or a directive from Goodell because he knows they'll win it all if they get to the playoffs and he doesn't want to derail another Patriot championship?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, because Goodell is so friendly with the Patriots these days.

GSK: How can a player be taken off the field several times (Burfict) including an apparent head injury and not go in the concussion protocol?!

Ray Fittipaldo: Sounds like a question the NFL should be posing to the Bengals this week. I agree with you. Not a good look for the NFL. But in all fairness, trying to diagnose a concussion on Burfict might be harder than with other players.

Nick in VA: The Steelers burned two timeouts in the first quarter yesterday. What was the reason for that? Was it crowd noise or was there something else involved? The broadcasters kept talking about how Ben would get everyone to the line and call the plays so he had time to review the defense and adjust with plenty of time.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They scored on their first three drives so I view it as a positive. The timeouts ensured they got into the plays they wanted that eventually led to points.

Tom: Scenario yesterday..Bungles down by 16, have only scored 10 points in 3 qtrs. The other team moved the ball all day and punted just once. What makes a coach think he will score three times AND hold the other team in the final few minutes? Every coach does this, do they all lack a sense of reality at times?

Ray Fittipaldo: That was one of many bad decision by Marvin Lewis yesterday. He also made a questionable decision when he allowed Mike Nugent to attempt a 54-yarder in the first half. He missed and the Steelers got great field position as a result.

Guest: Gay's celebration was bush league, why was he and Joey Porter crawling on their knees??

Ray Fittipaldo: Who knows? He's had five in a row for TDs now. By now, you'd think he'd just hand the ball to the ref and get on with his day.

Advertise with us

Tiny: Jarvis Jones continues to be just a guy, what happens with him contractually after this season?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he'll still be here next year, but I don;t think they'll exercise the fifth-year option for him.

Ryan Lanning: Pretty underwhelming day from Bryant and Brown, what do you attribute that to?

Ray Fittipaldo: Brown had 87 receiving yards. That's below his standards, but it's nothing to sneeze at. He had some big catches that helped set up their touchdowns.

Touchdown Joey: Can the Bengals beat anybody with McCarron at the helm?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Did you see what San Francisco did yesterday? They lost to Cleveland. So yes, the McCarron-led Bengals can win in SF. As a matter of fact, I expect them to be favored.

Richie: Is it hard to type while you're laughing at the overly harsh criticisms? I mean, the offense puts up point after point, the defense gets key plays, picks, scores and yet we have the worst team ever in some people's opinions....

ChicagoNate: Hi Ray, just wanted your thoughts on Tomlin leaving his starters in the games. DeAngelo does not need to pound the ball in the endzone to make it a three score lead with 7 min left in the game. If Williams gets hurt, they are right back to where they were heading into the playoffs last year. Starting a RB with zero experience or touches.

Ray Fittipaldo: What happens if Fitz Toussaint fumbles and the Bengals run it back 99 yards for a touchdown and only trail by six with seven minutes to go? That's the way you have to think when you're a coach.

Leo Lee: What happens with the LT spot after this season? Might be me, but I feel like AV has been more solid than Beachum

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure teams will be lining up to sign Beachum coming off an injury. maybe the Steelers let them compete next summer if they can get Beachum signed at a reasonable price.

Forceiswithus: How are the Steelers situated cap wise next year? Can we extend Villenajueva on the cheap?

Ray Fittipaldo: AV is not a free agent so no reason to extend him yet.

Latrobe Guy: I think Gay's celebration episode had a lot do with the Bengal's celebrating when Bell was hurt in the November game as well as their mouth's leading to the game and Burfict's crossing the line into the Steeler's area before the game, your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: No idea. I just wish he'd be like Franco and hand the ball to the official. I'm an old man though so maybe I'm in the minority.

Advertise with us

Lonnard: Big game at Denver this week...thoughts on how it goes?

Ray Fittipaldo: That big game vs. Denver is at Heinz Field and the Broncos haven't exactly lit it up on offense in their past two games.

Guest: Is there any chance Mike Adams plays for the Steelers next year? We need depth, and he's being injured all year

Ray Fittipaldo: I doubt it, but I don't think many other teams would be interested either so he could come back on the cheap hoping to prove himself.

Latrobe Guy: Any idea who will be the starting QB for Denver next week?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Haven't seen anything that Manning is coming back for this game so I'm assuming Osweiler.

Fletch: I know you don't typically weigh in on your poll question, but will you indulge me and share your thoughts on the most likely outcome for the Steelers?

Ray Fittipaldo: 11-5 is very doable, but the Broncos have a good defense and are capable of winning at Heinz Field. So either finish 11-5 and earn No. 6 seed or finish 10-6 and miss the playoffs because the Jets probably don't lose two of their final three.

Rudolph The Red Nosed Yinzer: Heath due $4MM in salary next year does he get paid or are we going to see an *adjustment* either in salary or TE or both?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's played pretty well this season, hasn't he? No reason not to bring him back.

Nick in VA: Who would you like to see next week?

Ray Fittipaldo: Depends on how healthy Manning is. If he is healthy and can run the offense he's the better option over Osweiler. But if he's hurt the Steelers likely would have their way with him.

Guest: With regard to 10-6 not making playoffs, if the Jets lose to the Patriots or Bills and finish 10-6 don't the Steelers win the tiebreaker?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. The Steelers only win the tiebreaker over the Jets when both teams finish 11-5, not 10-6.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for taking part in the chat this week. We'll do it again next week after the Denver game.

Follow Ray Fittipaldo on Twitter @rayfitt1.