Whether you believe in the ratings or not, Pro Football Focus keeps extensive stats and grades of every individual player in the NFL with a certain minimum number of snaps. For amusement purposes only then, here are some high and low grades they have for the Steelers. We left out those who garnered grades in the middle of the pack.
The Good
Antonio Brown ranks first among all NFL receivers with a 25.9 overall rating in PFF’s system.
Le’Veon Bell ranks first among NFL halfbacks at 14.4, and DeAngelo Williams ranks seventh at 7.3.
Ben Roethlisberger ranks third among quarterbacks at 20.2 (Carson Palmer leads with 36.1, Tom Brady is next at 33.4).
Ramon Foster ranks ninth among guards at 11.5 and David DeCastro 14th at 9.2.
Read More
Cam Heyward ranks sixth among 3-4 defensive ends at 25.4 (Stephon Tuitt is 23rd at 5.6).
James Harrison ranks seventh among all 3-4 outside linebackers at 14.7.
Mike Mitchell is the ninth-highest safety with a 6.5.
The Not-So-Good
Bud Dupree ranks 49th out of 51 outside linebackers in a 3-4 defense with a minus-7.6. Arthur Moats ranks 36th at minus- 2.5.
Lawrence Timmons ranks 54th of 57 inside linebackers with a minus-18.6 rating. Ryan Shazier is 38th at minus-9.0.
Antwon Blake ranks No. 109 of 110 cornerbacks with a minus-18.6. (Ross Cockrell is the Steelers’ highest-rated corner at 2.8 for 34th).
Alejandro Villanueva ranks 57th out of 74 offensive tackles at minus-12.7.
Cody Wallace ranks last of 36 centers at minus-37.0
Chris Boswell is the 50th of 52 ranked kickers overall with a minus-2.6. Although he gets a 1.6 on his field goals and extra points (tied for 16th), his overall grade is dragged down by his minus-4.2 rating on kickoffs.
The Team
The 6-4 Steelers rank 16th overall among NFL teams with a 1.2 ranking. Their offense ranks seventh at 30.9 and their defense 26th at minus-29.0.
The offseason? Already?
Some personnel decisions, as usual, must be made after the season but why wait until then to bring it up? Here is just a handful:
• Keep Shaun Suisham or Boswell as their kicker? Both are signed for 2016, but Suisham will cost them a salary of $2.4 million and Boswell $525,000.
• Try to sign Kelvin Beachum, who will be a free agent, or go with Villanueva as the left tackle? If they sign Beachum, Villanueva can be the No. 3 tackle. Villanueva is signed for $525,000 for next year and cannot become an unrestricted free agent until after the 2018 season. Mike Adams, who did not play this season because of a back injury, also becomes a free agent in March.
• Have Harrison return at age 38 for a rather modest $1.25 million salary in the final year of his contract? Or just swing it open to the young players?
• Foster, PFF’s ninth-ranked guard, can become an unrestricted free agent. They made no move to extend his contract before the 2015 season. Should they after this one?
• Pay Cortez Allen another $4.4 million in salary for 2016 or cut ties?
• Bell enters the fourth and final year of his rookie contract and would become a UFA afterward. Sign him to an extension before the season?
• Keep Williams at age 33 for a $2 million salary to back up Bell or look for another No. 2 halfback?
• Re-sign veteran Bruce Gradkowski to back up Roethlisberger or turn the job over to Landry Jones, who has it now and will be paid $675,000 in the fourth and final year of his rookie contract?
• Re-sign Steve McLendon, who can become a UFA, as the versatile starting nose tackle and backup end or turn the nose tackle job over to Daniel McCullers?
• Defensive backs William Gay, Will Allen, Antwon Blake, Robert Golden and Brandon Boykin all can become UFAs. Try to sign any of them or move on? (Shamarko Thomas anyone?)
• There’s also one other matter. The Steelers made the somewhat unprecedented move when they took $2 million in salary from Antonio Brown’s 2016 salary and gave it to him this year. He remains under contract through 2017. With his salary reduced to $6.25 million next season because of the advance given to him this year, might he want more? The Steelers easily could take another $2 million from his $8.71 million salary due him in 2017 and give it to him in 2016. Then, they could extend his contract before the final year in 2017, which would then be torn up and a whole new contract written. That sounds like a plan.
Joey says …
We close with a piece of advice from one of the most passionate players — and now assistant coaches — the Steelers have employed. Joey Porter was intimidating enough that he may have intimidated Seattle tight end Jerramy Stevens right into a poor Super Bowl — including a dropped touchdown pass — merely by calling him out during the press conferences beforehand. Here is what Porter said this week when about whether intimidation is still part of the game:
“I don’t think intimidation will ever be out of the game. But to have intimidation, they’re not going to believe it if you’re not playing like that.
“There’s a certain thing that comes with intimidation; you can’t just talk and have it, you have to play that type of football to demand it. If you’re not playing good football, who’s going to be scared of you?”
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.