Poll Question: Which previously suspended player will have a bigger impact on Monday night, Martavis Bryant or Antonio Gates? Bryant (75%) Gates (25%)

Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started.

Adam: How do the tryouts for kickers work? Do they just have them kick in an empty stadium without any distractions or rushers?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. The tryout on Saturday was in rainy and windy conditions at Heinz Field. So at least they got the kickers to compete in some less than ideal conditions.

Advertise with us

Adam: Will the offense open up a little more this week with Vick given he will have had 11 days off to prepare for San Diego?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. I would expect that. The Steelers basically had one day of practice before the Ravens game. This week, they'll have five. That's two more than a usual week. It gives Todd Haley a chance to install more and it gives Vick a better opportunity to work on timing with his receivers, which was an issue in the Ravens game. Plus, Martavis Bryant returns. That will open things up for Antonio Brown a little bit more.

Adam: Why couldn't the Steelers come up with more clever ways to get Brown the ball? I usually hate end arounds or bubble screens, but the inside screens could go to brown sometimes. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: As I said in the previous answer there was really only one day to prepare for the Ravens. And I would argue the problems in the passing game had more to do with chemistry between Vick and the receivers than the play-calling. I can hardly find fault with Todd Haley on the fourth-and-1 call in OT. He designed a play that got Brown wide open. Vick just didn't hit him. That's not Haley's fault.

Adam: The defense is playing well above the level of expectations everyone had for them before the season started. WHat can you attribute to the success?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: The defense has played well in spurts. There have been more sacks. The coverage seems to be better. New DC Keith Butler seems to be changing things up with his play-calling, making the defense less predictable. However, the rush defense wasn't good vs. the Ravens. It's been up and down so far.

The4ngryG4mer: I saw a Bleacher Report article that Ben is on pace to be back for the Chiefs game. Foolish speculation or do you concur?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's been 4-6 weeks all along. That would be 4 weeks. I don't think anyone is breaking any news there.

Adam: I still don't believe the record of the Bengals reflects their abilities. Do you think Ben can return in time for that crucial divisional home game against them and, if so, should we be favored?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure why you think the Bengals are not as good as their 4-0 record. Their defense appears to be stout again with the return of Geno Atkins and the offense is playing well because Andy Dalton is playing well. I thought the Bengals were a playoff team before the season. My only question was whether Dalton could lead them to a playoff victory, which he hasn't been able to do previously.

Advertise with us

JSNH: Good Afternoon Ray, I hated the 4th and 2 call for a Vick sweep, but how do feel about the 4th and 1 call that ended the Steelers drive? Your kicker is 42% from 40-49 yds has missed two already and your QB is completing over 70% of his passes (plus the Ravens D was keying on Bell. Understandable call by Tomlin and Haley?

Ray Fittipaldo: Agree with you. mentioned this in a previous answer. Brown was wide open. That was on Vick for not making the completion.

Guest: Hi Ray, How accurate do you think the report from La Canfora on Sunday is about Ben returning for the KC game on the 25th?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just answered this. It would be four games if he comes back for the Chiefs. It's a 4-6 week injury. The fact that he was able to get off crutches so well is a good sign. It means the bruise is healing well. But he'll still miss four games.

QB1: Was there any mention f Vick's throwing mechanics? He didn't seem to setting his feet or regularly stepping into his throws....

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I talked to Vick on Friday and he was talking about his incomplete pass to Brown on fourth down in overtime. He said he set his feet well enough, but he threw across his body for some reason. Obviously, he has to do a better job in that kind of situation.

Gus: Not to belabor a dead issue but in the HOF game why wasn't Suisham implicity told not to attempt to make a tackle by the special teams coach? If Kickers are this fragile and apparently important

Ray Fittipaldo: Hindsight is 20-20, but Suisham has always stuck his nose in there.

Alan: Steelers inability to stop the run was a big problem in the Raven game that has been somewhat overshadowed by Scobee's missed FG's. Great play by Ravens O line or is our D line that weak?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers were out of their gaps too often vs. the Ravens. Plus, they got caught in some blitzes. The frustrating thing for the Steelers is the Ravens were having a hard time running the ball before the game. That might not be a good sign.

Advertise with us

Guest: Vick is now 3-13 in last 16 starts, is he just not a winning QB because of vast innacuracy?

Ray Fittipaldo: He'd be 4-12 if the kicker could make a 41-yarder.

Adam: Why did the Steelers continue to stick with Scobee so long as to make his inability to do his job a critical factor in a game? Most people could see he wasn't cutting it, yet even reporters kept arguing there was no reasonable alternative when it looks like there is (at least in theory).

Ray Fittipaldo: He had four misses this season, two on Thursday. He actually made six in a row before the two misses vs. the Ravens. When a kicker loses a game for a team like that sometimes the best remedy is to change the kicker.

Chip: Did Vick not look to throw the ball down the field at all on Thurs. night, or was the game plan to check down all night?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Several receivers I have talked to in the days since told me the Ravens were backing up in the secondary and not allowing the Steelers to take deep shots. Maybe you still have to threaten them with one or two in those situations, but they were content to give up the short routes and not allow the long ones.

WAROnTheRock: Comment(s) on Philbin firing? (maybe off topic)

Ray Fittipaldo: I thought they should have fired him after the bullying scandal.

Qix: What is your opinion on the OLB rotations so far this year? JJ needs more snaps.

Ray Fittipaldo: Overall, I think the OLBs are doing pretty well though I agree with you that Jones might need to get on the field a little more. Harrison made a big sack near the end of regulation.

Advertise with us

The4ngryG4mer: I expected to see more old school play calls with Vick in instead of Ben - more ground and pound couple with play action passes over the top. Looked like they still had a bunch of timing and scat plays called. Is it time for Haley to adjust?

Ray Fittipaldo: You can't just ground and pound in this league anymore. You have to be able to throw the ball. Vick only passed 26 times in the game. If it had been a game decided in regulation it would have been around 20 throws. That's perfect for someone like him.

Dirk: Good Afternoon Ray, could please tell us what it would take for Colbert to start feeling heat with the organization? I know where he drafted Antonio Brown, but he's also responsible for the Rainey and Blount fiascos; he drafted Adams, Archer and Alameda; he extended and grossly overpaid Cortez; Shark Thomas hasn't developed; Cam Thomas is stealing a paycheck; and now he's traded for 2 players who will do nothing but collect a pay check. Never mind the disappointment that the Vick signing has brought a majority of the fan base. This can't be acceptable, can it?

Ray Fittipaldo: You pointed out a number of personnel decisions that appear to be mistakes. In addition to Brown he drafted Pouncey, Martavis Bryant and Ryan Shazier. Pouncey is a perennial All-Pro when healthy and it looks like Bryant and Shazier are guys who can be All-Pros if they can stay healthy and stay clean off the field. But you can do this with every GM in the league. Colbert hasn't been perfect in recent years, but they're saying the same thing about GMs in other cities too.

Alan: how would you rate Jarvis Jones thus far?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Jones has been OK. He's playing fewer than half the snaps too so it's not like there is a big body of work from which to judge.

The4ngryG4mer: Do you think Tomlin gave up on Scobee too early? Going from "not concerned" about his kicker to cutting ties seemed pretty rash. Other variables in play?

Ray Fittipaldo: Scobee lost a divisional game against a rival all by himself. It would have been hard to bring him back under those circumstances.

teddyballgame14: Steelers aren't the only team experiences struggles with their kicker(s). A number of teams lost games this weekend, because their guy missed a kick or two they shouldn't have. Any comment on what seems to be a league-wide epidemic? Is this the worst year in recent memory for kickers? Or, am I just noticing it more?

Ray Fittipaldo: When it's a local problem you tend to notice those things more, but I saw someone had a stat today that said the kicking isn't a whole lot worse than what it usually is.

Advertise with us

Adam: WHy not use some read option next week? We have the personel. Vick, Bell, Brown, and Williams can do some real damage and there wouldn't be any tape of the STeelers doing it.

Ray Fittipaldo: More time to game plan this week so you might see a few more wrinkles. Not sure if the read option is among them but the game plan will be more expansive this week for the Chargers.

The4ngryG4mer: Assuming Ben is back for KC, how many more games can this team afford to lose until then?

Ray Fittipaldo: You've got the Chargers on the road and the Cardinals at home in that stretch so you'd like to go 1-1. Not saying they'd be out of it at 2-4, especially in what is looking like a mediocre AFC, but 3-3 would be much better obviously.

The4ngryG4mer: If Vick gets the first down and the Steelers win the game on a TD (not field goal), does Scobee still have a job?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably because in that case he'd have missed just one FG, a 49-yarder. You don't cut kickers for missing 49-yarders.

Guest: I'm not excusing Scobee, and I have no problem with cutting him, but why do people assume that the game would have been over if he'd made one of those field goals? The Steelers would have only been up six, the Ravens would have had enough time to drive for a touchdown, and the Steelers' track record against Flacco in those types of situations is not the greatest.

Ray Fittipaldo: With 1:59 remaining, with the Steelers facing a third-and-5, numberfire.com calculated the Steelers' chances of winning the game at 99.82 percent. Assuming the Ravens started at the 20 after the kickoff they would have had to have driven 80 yards with no timeouts to score a TD. That's almost impossible.

Eddie: In your opinion, is this one of the toughest loses the Steelers have had in a few years? Tough to lose a 10+ point lead with so many missing pieces AND the kicker having the opportunity to put it away not once but twice!!

Ray Fittipaldo: It was the first time the Steelers blew a 13-point lead at home more than a half century. Yes, I think it qualifies as one of their toughest losses in quite some time.

Advertise with us

JamesinNYC: Vick looked awkward on that pass to Brown, was he too shallow in his drop or does Vick just have a difficult time throwing short passes across his body?

Ray Fittipaldo: He mentioned on Friday how he wouldn't throw across his body if he had to do it over again.

The4ngryG4mer: Did you get a sense of how disappointed AB really was to have lost his famous 5-50 streak? I'm sure he said "What matters is that we lost", but he has to be seething about it, no?

Ray Fittipaldo: He had to know it was going to be hard to keep that streak going without Ben. All receivers are divas to some extent so I'm sure he is upset about it ending. He said Vick has to adjust his game a bit for the passing game to click without Ben. We'll see if Vick can make those adjustments with 10 days between games.

The Ranger: Ray how would you grade David Decastro's play so far this season?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He's been OK. Some expected him to take the next step this season to be a Pro Bowler. He hasn't played at that level yet, but he's been OK.

Adam: Will Shazier be ready to go by next Monday?

Ray Fittipaldo: Shazier practiced today so it's looking good for Monday

Steve: Has Boykin been that bad or is Ross Cockrell just good enough to be the future of the Steelers CB group?

Ray Fittipaldo: Cockrell had a pretty good game on Thursday. No reason to make a change after the guy made an INT and scooped up a fumble.

Advertise with us

Tship: Hi Ray, thanks for your time again. How much of the Ravens running succes can be attrributed to Shazier being out? A lot of times I think it was set up for a backer to swop in an make a tackle.

Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure that was part of it. However, on at least one occasion they were in a blitz and the Ravens popped a big play. Forsett had a 33-yarder on one blitz in the third quarter, on the drive when the Ravens cut the lead to 20-14.

EmbraceThisMike: If we're assigning blame... It wasn't' Scobee that "cost them the game".

Ray Fittipaldo: You're wrong. Scobee cost the Steelers the game.

Guest: Chargers seem banged up at WR this week, should this lead to a Steelers victory?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I saw that. Maybe more of a level playing field because the Steelers will be without two of their top offensive players in Ben and Pouncey

Adam: Has Beachum played extremely poorly so far this year? If he continues to play average football, does that put him in the STeelers price range as a FA?

Ray Fittipaldo: Like DeCastro, Beachum has been OK. Not spectacular but nothing real bad either.

jt: is it a special teams or head coach error that you have your kicker in the 4th quarter trying to make game winning kicks into the "open or difficult" end of Heinz field when you got to pick which side you started the game on. the Ravens deferred which in sense gave the steelers the choice into which end your were faacing in 4th quarter. or conditions had no bearing on those missed kicks or non issue

Ray Fittipaldo: Shaun Suisham made plenty of kicks to that end of the stadium. So do a lot of other NFL kickers.

Guest: If your kicker misses two kicks into the wind, neither team has an offense to score a quick TD, Why choose to take ball and kick into the wind in OT?

Ray Fittipaldo: Please. You always take the ball in OT.

THEE MMC: Ray do you think Vick plays his game more this week with the return of Bryant? He looked more comfortable out of the pocket

Ray Fittipaldo: Bryant's return will be big for him. Vick said as much Friday. They had some chemistry in the preseason. He's another weapon in the arsenal.

Adam: I've noticed the chargers aren't playing that well. Does this make it a winnable game? Is this close to a must win game to avoid back to back losses without Ben?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's not must-win but if they're injured and struggling you have to be able to take advantage of those types of situations on your schedule. Remember, the Steelers are banged up too.

Qix: Will Ben be wearing any brace or protective gear when he gets back?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. He has been told he'll have to wear a knee brace. He has never worn one in the past.

Guest: I saw on several plays where beachum didn't block; especially, on the 4th down booth leg play. Is it me or does beachum miss a lot of blocks?

Ray Fittipaldo: That play was not well blocked by anyone. Heath Miller missed a block too.

EmbraceThisMike: It was Todd Tricky that deserves the majority of the blame, not Scobee! Never should of gone to OT! On 3rd & 5 a first down wins it and tricky called a submissive title run/lay down in middle... Bell followed instruction and turtled! Then on 4th & 1 in OT, Tricky calls for a all or nothing pass across Vicks body, ALL THE WAY OUT TO THE FLAT PASS to AB!!! You've NOT the smartest guy in the place Todd... JUST STOP trying to prove that you are! (See opening drive vs NE, Drive killer/trick play!)

Ray Fittipaldo: The pass to Brown is a pass an NFL QB has to be able to complete. Sorry, but I'm not blaming Haley there. He designed a play that got Brown wide open on fourth down.

Adam: Brown catches that TD 9/10 times. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: That was a more difficult catch than people are making it out to be, but yes, Brown makes that play 7 or 8 times out of 10. He has such high standards based on his body of work.

Adam: WHat's the status on Pouncey's injury?

Ray Fittipaldo: To my knowledge Pouncey hasn't done an interview since the injury. Everything would appear to be on track with his rehab, but he's not talking yet.

bill w.: Do the salaries of all these kickers count against the cap?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they do, but Hartley's salary could come off the books once he is healed and they reach an injury settlement.

JamesinNYC: Is there any way they can bring Graham back after he heals?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. He was placed on IR.

Steve: Ray, do you think 3 teams will make playoffs from AFC Central or AFC East..both "strong" divisions this year.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Bills didn't look very good yesterday. The Jets might be a team to watch with that defense they have. I'm guessing two come from the North and probably two from the East. One each from the South and West.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for taking part in the chat this week. We'll do it again next Monday before the San Diego game.