Today’s poll: In honor of the Gridiron Gold event, which Western Pa. QB is the best?
Joe Montana ( 18% )
Dan Marino ( 18% )
Johnny Unitas ( 36% )
Joe Namath ( 9% )
Jim Kelly ( 0% )
George Blanda ( 18% )
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to this week's Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started soon.
Comment From steelmann58
HI Ray two weeks in shorts done anyone of the wr stand out and how does Coats look catching the ball
Ray Fittipaldo: The passing game overall looks pretty good. I wrote about Martavis Bryant yesterday. He should put up even bigger numbers in his second season. He looks good. Coates looks good too. It looks like he's picking things up pretty quick, which will help him. The possibilities with Bryant and Coates on the field at the same time are limitless when it comes to route trees and the free space that could provide for AB and Heath Miller. Of course, Coates has to prove it first and get on the field.
Comment From The Dude
I often hear that a guy is getting another chance based upon the fact that he was a draft pick, or a high draft pick. Shouldn't it be based on talent alone? It seems like the ego of a front office trying to prove themselves right. If the guy can't play (see Archer, Dri), it doesn't matter whether or not he was drafted.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's just not the way it works. Draft picks are always afforded more opportunities to prove they can play. It's an organizational decision and whether you like it or not those higher draft picks are given more opportunities to prove they belong. The Steelers have cut fourth round picks in their first season but you don't see it too much with guys drafted in the third round or higher. Archer will get another opportunity to prove he belongs this year.
Comment From The Dude
What are the chances of Gardner being the 5th WR AND the 3rd string QB? Low, I know, but would free up a hat on Sundays.
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin did give Gardner some snaps at QB last week, but that's a tall order for anyone much less a rookie. You just don't see that much, if at all, around the league. Gardner would have to beat out Darrius Heyward Bey and prove he is better than Tahj Boyd and Landry Jones to make that happen, I don't see it. There is a reason no one in the NFL wanted him as a QB and encouraged him to try WR.
Comment From The Dude
In your opinion, how good of a QB is Ben at reading defenses, compared to other top QBs. He doesn't have the Tom Brady/Peyton Manning/Drew Brees reputation for preparation.
Ray Fittipaldo: Early on in his career he was known for his improvisation and some things were reported about his film study. I think that has changed as he has grown older. With this Todd Haley offense he has to make quick reads and get the ball out of his hands earlier than he did under Bruce Arians. I don't know how he compares to Brady and Brees and Co. when it comes to that, but he's much better than he used to be.
Comment From The Dude
All other things being equal, wouldn't it make more sense to keep a UFA over a draft pick? Less of a cap hit.
Ray Fittipaldo: Undrafted free agents make a lot of 53-man rosters throughout the NFL including the Steelers, but those UFAs usually are not knocking high picks out of roster spots when those high picks are in their first or second years. Third and fourth years, yes, but not when those high picks are young.
Comment From The Dude
Has Tomlin been more vocal in OTAs regarding the defensive side of the ball? Given his coaching past, I am hoping he puts more of his own stamp on the defense.
Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't been able to discern much of a difference at all in his approach.
Comment From The Dude
Do you see Mike Munchak sticking around as our OL coach for the long haul or do you think he will look to move up again.
Ray Fittipaldo: Munchak has never been a coordinator and he was a head coach for only three seasons so when you say lookig to move up you're saying back to head coach, and those jobs are hard to come by, especially for a coach who failed to make the playoffs in three seasons with the Titans. Munchak seems happy with the Steelers, and I don't anticipate him moving on for another O-line job at this point.
Comment From Cliff
How did Dri Archer look? Any improvement on what can only be considered a poor season?
Ray Fittipaldo: We really won't know until the season begins. Archer look good at times in camp last year and his skills did not translate in the real games.
Comment From The Dude
Has Ike been at all of the OTA sessions? I hope he's not teaching the young DBs how to catch.
Ray Fittipaldo: I remember seeing him only for the first week.
Comment From Guest
Seems like the defense has a lot of potential as there are several players who could contribute significantly now that they have had at least one year learning the system - if they stay healthy (Shazier, JJones, Mitchell, Thomas, Moats, tuitt) unlike the past couple of yeas, primarily the D is not relying on rookies to contribute immediately. Again, just football in shorts, but does the D seem to be 'more on the same page' than previous couple of years?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think the secondary is ahead of where they were last year. Mike Mitchell spoke to that early in OTAs. He was in his first season with the team last year and it took a while for him to get comfortable with the established players. But you mentioned a lot of players who represent a lot of ifs and ifs are always worrisome to me. You'd like to have fewer questions about guys who are playing important positions.
Comment From The Dude
Out of all the rookies/new players so far, who has been the best interview/most thoughtful?
Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't interviewed any of them more than once, but L.T. Walton seems like a pretty sharp kid.
Comment From HeavyMedicine
Do you see us adding anymore RB depth before/during training camp? Do they feel that good about Josh Harris during LeVeon suspension?
Ray Fittipaldo: They always seem to bring in new RBs during camp. Josh Harris was a late addition last summer and he made the practice squad and eventually the 53-man roster after LeGarrette Blount was released.
Comment From joe
The Steelers first 4-5 games seems brutal without Bell in the lineup. I have concerns 2-3 or 1-5 is a real possiblility, your thoughts.
Ray Fittipaldo: He's only missing three games and one is at home vs. a rebuilding 49ers team. Another us against a Rams team with Nick Foles as the starting QB. 2-1 seems very doable to me unless the Rams defense is able to shut down the Steelers offense.
Comment From Guest
Is there anyway the front office realizes Landry Jones isn't an NFL QB and they cut ties? I'm sure they could find someone better & younger
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Tahj Boyd will push him this summer.
Comment From ChicagoSteelerStore
Hi Ray, when I look at the current Steelers roster, I cant help but think this team is loaded with talent. I understand some of the young players will need to perform however even on defense, they have number 1 picks all over the place. I feel this is one of the most talented teams I have seen from them in a while. I know you are down on some of the young defenders that have not proven there worth yet, but do you disagree with my assessment?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not necessarily down on many of the defenders. I just haven't seen them perform at a high level yet. There is a difference. Jarvis Jones has not played ;like a No. 1 pick. That's a fact. Some of it has to do with injury, but the numbers speak for themselves. The same goes for Ryan Shazier, who dealt with injuries throughout his rookie season last year. We'll see what Bud Dupreee can do, but if you're counting on a rookie to improve your pass rush you are in trouble. Lots of guys who have never performed in the NFL with any amount of consistency have to do that this season in order for the defense to be good. That's why I'm skeptical.
Comment From The Dude
Very important question - since he was just released by the Browns, will we bring in Spencer Lanning for a look.
Ray Fittipaldo: If they picked him up, would he even report? He might think Antonio Brown's right foot will meet him at the front door of the facility.
Comment From Cliff
Any chance Goodell reduces Brady's suspension and allows it to start in Game 2 so he doesn't miss the national spotlight in the opener?
Ray Fittipaldo: No that would not be a good look for the NFL. They'll have that straightened out before the season begins. It might get reduced, but if he misses any games I think the suspension will start with the Steelers game.
Comment From Scott
How long of a leash does Jarvis Jones get before we see Harrison taking the bulk of the snaps?
Ray Fittipaldo: Harrison is 37, and even though he played well last season, you have to find out about Jones one way or the other. The only way to do that is to run him out there to see if he can do it.
Comment From Guest
How has Cortez Allen looked so far? Any indication he and his confidence has improved?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll reserve my judgment for training camp and the preseason games when it comes to Cortez.
Comment From The Dude
Cam Thomas is in the last year of his deal, yes? Who would you rather have on the roster this year, Cam Thomas or Brett Keisel on a 1 year deal.
Ray Fittipaldo: Brett's body failed him in each of the past two years. Injuries prevent him from playing a full season. That's what happens when you get older. I'm not a big fan of Thomas, but you can't continue to bring back older players year after year and expect them to stay healthy.
Comment From JamesinNYC
Could the Steelers agree to support a charity of a player? I understand it is sort of cheating, but the player does not receive a direct benefit. I have been on the Kevin Beachum bandwagon from the day he was drafted so hope he is signed.
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers can give players like Beachum a platform for his charity work by writing about him on their web site or doing a video, but I doubt it's legal under league bylaws for teams to donate to player charities for obvious reasons.
Comment From TX_Steeler
Do you know why Shazier missed a couple of days of OTA? I know they are voluntary, but ....
Ray Fittipaldo: You're right, they are voluntary and because they are no reason was given for his absence.
Comment From The Dude
I read that Sean Spence was staying after practice with Antonio Brown. Any of the young WRs staying after practice to work on drills with him?
Ray Fittipaldo: AB and Spence have been regulars staying after practice to work on their strength and conditioning. It's not receiver work though so I haven't noticed any of the other WRs working with him. Sometimes, it's just AB and Spence but they are joined by others at other times.
Comment From The Dude
How much was Tunch working with the OL at OTAs?.....Thanks for the chat Ray
Ray Fittipaldo: Tunch does not work with the O-linemen during the OTA practices. When he does work with them it's on their own time.
Comment From Joe
Do Steelers scouts specialize in particular positions or are they assigned geographic regions? If they look at positions, whoever has been scouting WR's should be promoted while the guy in charge of CB's should be fired.
Ray Fittipaldo: Generally, they have scouts assigned to regions. Mark Bruener, for example, has the northwest area. And they generally are trained to evaluate all positions.
Comment From The Dude
There must be a bunch of old fogeys on this chat, Unitas is beating Marino. Just kidding. I never saw Unitas play, Marino was the best pure passer I've seen play.
Ray Fittipaldo: Johnny U was known as a pure passer too. Could sling it with anyone and won two NFL championships in 58 and 59 before he won Super Bowl V in 1970.
Comment From Dude_From_Cali
Do you think Sean Spence's knee injury cost him a step slower or was he 100% healed with no ill effects?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's hard for me to remember what Sean Spence was like as a rookie in those preseason games. I know they had high hopes for him, but he did start nine games last season for a playoff team. The Steelers, or any other team, are not in the business of starting guys because it's a feel-good story. Spence earned those starts. I'd have to ask Spence if he felt like he's lost a step, but the fact of the matter is he returned to play in the NFL and played at a pretty good level.
Comment From The Dude
That was a good question -- wouldn't it make sense to have scouts who specialize in scouting certain positions?
Ray Fittipaldo: The assistant coaches come in and evaluate these guys as well once the season is over. So Mike Munchak is able to look at OL prospects and give his opinion in the weeks leading up to the draft.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for chatting today. We'll do it again next week.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.