That iconic over-the-shoulder catch that helped the Steelers win Super Bowl XL, those franchise-record 1,000 receptions, all of those bone-jarring blocks that intimidated opposing players and fostered change in the NFL rulebook. None of those Hines Ward moments would have happened for the Steelers if not for the advent of compensatory draft picks.
Compensatory picks were introduced in 1994 to help teams offset the loss of free agents from the previous year. Ward came along in the third round of the 1998 draft, but only after the Steelers lost some important free agents to other teams the previous spring.
In 1997, the Steelers did not retain Chad Brown, Willie Williams, Ray Seals and Ernie Mills. They were awarded four compensatory selections the following spring, the first of which was used on Ward.
“The picks can be really valuable,” said Tom Donahoe, former director of player personnel for the Steelers who oversaw the team’s drafts from 1991-1999. “Anyone who loves the draft knows the value of extra picks. Every pick in the draft is important. Anytime you can get an extra player, it’s great. I don’t think the player ever matches up to what you lose, but there is always the chance you can get a Hines Ward.”
Some championship foundations were built on compensatory picks. The New England Patriots struck gold in 2000 when they used a sixth-round compensatory selection on four-time Super Bowl winning quarterback Tom Brady. Hall of Fame guard Larry Allen of the Dallas Cowboys also was a compensatory pick.
Most don’t become Hall of Fame-caliber players, but teams use the picks to add quality prospects to their roster they otherwise would not get.
The Steelers have been especially good at it over the years. Starting left tackle Kelvin Beachum was a compensatory pick, the Steelers’ fourth choice in the seventh round of the 2012 draft. He is one of five compensatory selections currently on the roster.
Some other notable compensatory selections over the years for the Steelers include linebacker Mike Vrabel (1997), running back Amos Zereoue (1999), offensive lineman Willie Colon (2006) and cornerback William Gay (2007).
It’s a strong reminder for fans when they complain in March if their teams don’t spend in free agency or retain free agents. For many teams, including the Steelers, compensatory drafts picks are a big part of their roster-building process.
The Baltimore Ravens have accumulated more compensatory draft selections (41) than any other team in the past 21 years. The Steelers have drawn 29 compensatory picks, seventh most.
Among the other teams to accumulate more than 25 compensatory picks are the Packers, Eagles and Patriots.
Teams that have accumulated 13 or fewer include the Jets, Redskins and Browns, who have the fewest (6).
“You find teams that win consistently draft consistently,” said Rob Rang, a draft analyst for CBS. “The teams that hoard the compensatory picks, you can see the success they have. They find gems in the middle rounds. [Baltimore and Seattle general managers] Ozzie Newsome and John Schneider are really good at it. It’s not just getting the compensatory picks; it’s hitting on them.
“What those picks do is give you more opportunities. First-round picks might be a little overrated and late-round picks might be a little underrated. So what they do is give you more chances to win the lottery, so to speak. The smart teams are the ones who are giving themselves more opportunities. The savvy teams know what to do with those picks. It’s a nice way for the rich to stay rich.”
It’s not an exact science, but teams attempt to figure out where their compensatory picks will come each year, and they factor that into their offseason decisions.
When Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert traded a third-round pick to Cleveland to move up in the fourth round to select Shamarko Thomas in the spring of 2013, he did so knowing the team likely would receive a compensatory third-round pick in 2014 after losing Mike Wallace to the Dolphins in free agency.
The Steelers used that selection on Dri Archer, one of three compensatory choices form last year’s draft that made the Steelers’ opening-day 53-man roster. The Steelers also chose offensive lineman Wesley Johnson in the fifth round and nose tackle Daniel McCullers in the sixth round. Archer and McCullers remain with the team.
The only negative associated with compensatory picks is they cannot be traded. How they are awarded also remains a well-kept secret and can sometimes cause confusion. No one outside the NFL office knows exactly how the league calculates compensatory picks, including personnel of the league’s 32 teams.
It is believed teams are awarded picks when they lose more or better free agents than it acquires in the previous year, with the draft round determined by a formula that takes into account the salary, playing time and postseason honors of the departed players.
Teams project the picks to the best of their ability, but they don’t know for sure what they will get until the annual league meetings, one month before the draft. A few years ago, the Steelers were surprised to find out they received a fifth-round compensatory pick instead of a third-round pick when Alan Faneca left for the New York Jets in free agency. It turned out there was a little-known rule that 10-year veterans can bring no better than a fifth-round choice in return.
The Steelers aren’t the only team to get surprised. Donahoe works as a consultant for the Eagles now and was general manager of the Bills after he left the Steelers. He had similar experiences.
“No one has ever been able to figure out who gets what,” Donahoe said. “It’s one of the great mysteries of the NFL. We’d show up to the meetings some years and say, ‘How did we get this pick?’ ”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.