Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Tom Dill: Do you think the steelers are putting to much pressure on this years rookie class? They've never counted on rookies before. Now they have to. Especially the corners that are drafted.

Ed Bouchette: They never counted on them because they never had to. That started to change in 2013 when they drafted Jarvis Jones and last year with Ryan Shazier. Rookies, on occasion, do start and make an impact in the NFL with some teams.

RIP Chief: Hi Ed. Do you think going with current crop of CB's and developing draft picks this year is a mistake? Why not at least look at Brown or Bowman?. Know they're older but aren't they starter capable or at least an upgrade in depth? Both should easily fit under the cap. Thanks.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I would have signed Brice McCain back, at least. His two-year, $5.5 million contract is nothing, even with $3 million guaranteed. Then they could have drafted someone or sometwo or somethree. McCain can start if he has to, like last year.

Mike M: Ed, do you believe the Steelers learned from past mistakes and will stop the policy of restructuring contracts to stay under the cap and do a better job in the future?

Ed Bouchette: You should go read my blog this morning because I explain all that. That kind of thinking became old-fashioned with the new CBA in 2011 that allows teams to carry over cap room to the next year and so on.

matt milion: If Jarvis Jones turns out to be a bust what is plan B for the Steelers. Any injuries at all will leave olb position in real trouble.

Ed Bouchette: Yes, I think they will have another veteran at CB before they open training camp.

Advertise with us

RIP Chief: With depth at ILB and SF having a need for LB's, can you see the two talking trade at or before the draft? What could the Steelers get for Williams? Would it be worth the drop in their ILB depth?

Ed Bouchette: Cover It Live not working so well today. That previous answer goes with the above question.

As for the Jarvis Jones question, it does not seem as though they have much of a Plan B at outside linebacker. They are throwing a lot of stuff against the wall and hoping some of it sticks.

Troy: Ed, Is it true that Cortez Allen played hurt most of last year, which why his play dropped off so much over the previous season? Good chance he gains his starting job back since Mccain wasn't resigned?

Ed Bouchette: What, did all the DBs play "hurt" last year? No, I think he just stunk. But he has a chance to make a comeback and they are fully committed to it, since they gave him his $3 million roster bonus 10 days ago.

Advertise with us

John: Will signing James Harrison have any effect on how the Steelers approach the early rounds of the draft?

Ed Bouchette: No, I think he is insurance.

RIP Chief: Ed, please settle a debate. If J Jones ends up a first man up/quality back up, is he a bust? I say no. Agree more should be expected from a #1 but a bust doesn't contribute in my opinion.

Ed Bouchette: A first-rounder who cannot start, in my opinion, is a bust. Maybe not as big a one as, say, Huey Richardson, but a bust nevertheless. Or maybe those drafting should take the bust statue home with them if that's the case.

Guest: Ed, NFL.com's mock has the Steelers taking Marcus Peters in Rd 1. Do you think that is possible or do you think his red flags would preclude him?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: No way, jose

John: Will the Steelers add a kickoff return man in the draft or do they think they have their man in M. Wheaton?

Ed Bouchette: Kickoff return men are no more than 7th-round draft picks, if that, unless they also can return punts. But then, the Steelers used a third-round pick on one who turned out couldn't do the job anyway.

Mike M: I can't stand the "Jarvis Jones is a bust" talk. Rookies never start at OLB and he was hurt last year. Wasn't Troy really bad his rookie year then turned out to be a Hall of Famer? Shouldn't us fans give him some leeway?

Ed Bouchette: I have written as much many times this year. Jarvis Jones cannot be regarded as a bust for those reasons you suggest. He may still reach that category but not based on what we've seen so far. The previous question was if I thought he would be a bust if he remains a backup.

Advertise with us

Troy: Would it not be smart to lock up Cam Heyward long term? If he plays even better than last year he will play himself off the Steelers payroll.

Ed Bouchette: I think that is their plan. He is under contract for 2015 and they can reduce his nearly $7 million cap number with a long-term deal, not that that seems to be a pressing matter if they're not going to use that cap room.

Guest: Do teams evaluate players draft value by comparing them to other years? For example, would the team compare Trae Waynes to the 2014 CB draft class when determining his draft grade? Or is his value based solely compared to the current CB draft class?

Ed Bouchette: No, they do not look back. They rate players based on their rating systems.

dave: Have you seen any indication that Dri Archer is capable of returning punts?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: No, just the opposite.

Guest: I'm sorry, is that "no way, jose" as in no way they take Peters OR "no way, jose" as in no way his red flags would eliminate him from draft consideration?

Pat: Do you think the Steelers can get enough quality at the CB and OLB positions to make an impact this year or is this another building year for the D

Ed Bouchette: I think a cornerback could come in and help them. I do not think a rookie outside linebacker would this year.

Mike M: Did you like the idea of a veteran's combine last week? Any chance it sticks?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I think it was a flop, and was surprised at the number of writers who actually tried to cover it and junked up my Twitter timeline with all those photos from it.

Guest: I noticed that Gerry is in AZ for the meetings. How do you break up that work? Do you choose Super Bowl coverage and then Gerry picks winter meetings or does your boss decide?

Ed Bouchette: Gerry had not been to those meetings in a long time and I had been covering them for 30 years. I thought it just time for me to take a break and Gerry wanted to go. Like McArthur, I will return.

Mike M: With Lance Moore and Justin Brown gone, do you think the team will look for a veteran as the #4 WR or draft one again?

Ed Bouchette: Maybe DHB? I think they will pick one up. I thought Jacoby Jones could have filled that role and returned punts/kickoffs for them.

Advertise with us

Guest: Do you ever get residual checks from your role in Invincible?

Ed Bouchette: They paid me a flat fee, somewhere around $80 minus taxes, same as all of the other extras. And they put us up and fed us. The experience was much more valuable.

Troy: Why would Haley say Bryant would push for the #2 job at WR? I think he sealed the deal over Wheaton for that job.

Ed Bouchette: If you are a coach, you can't go telling a second-year player the job is his already. It's the same reason they said the right outside linebacker job was open.

Scott from Erie: Say training camp ends and it is determined that the top two outside linebackers are James Harrison and Jarvis Jones. Who plays on the left?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Arthur Moats. But if push came to bull-rush, it would have to be Harrison.

dave: Why did they sign Harrison for 2 years instead of 1 year? I know they can cut him after 1 year, but why even bother with the 2nd year?

Ed Bouchette: Same reason they signed Brett Keisel to a two-year contract last year, to spread out the signing bonus.

Randy: With their history of drafting late round corners, why not trade a 4th or 5th round pick for someone like Keenan Lewis? I know he's now off the table but someone of that ilk

Ed Bouchette: How do you know you can get someone of that ilk for a fourth or fifth rounder?

Advertise with us

Scott from Erie: Did James Harrison's tweets on Saturday force the Steelers to sign him now? Or was this the plan all along?

Ed Bouchette: No, I think he was being honest and they took him at his word.

RIP Chief: With FA all but done for the Steelers, what grade do you give them? Could they have even had a chance for an A or should Woodley's dead money limit them to a max B grade.

Ed Bouchette: An A? Even a B?  As Troy Edwards said so many times, "What they done?"

They signed a backup running back. They lost a cornerback. They did not sign a cornerback. They re-signed two outside linebackers they had on their team last year.

Advertise with us

Now, what they did not do is throw good money after bad players, but they didn't thrown much money at anyone.

I'll give them a C for standing virtually still. Sometimes, there's nothing wrong with that.

John: Can we expect R Shazier to be matched up more often against opposing team's athletic tight ends this year? I can't see Polamalu or S Thomas covering them well.

Ed Bouchette: Well, you won't see Polamalu covering anyone, at least not for the Steelers. And Shazier will be more cover linebacker than stout run defender. He also should be able to blitz from inside.

RIP Chief: Glad James is back. Don't get the thought process of those that think it will hinder JJ's development. If he can't beat out Harrison, we have our answer on what they got in the first round 3 years ago.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Bingo

JamesinNYC: Love Harrison taking other LBs out training, better than Blount with Bell, how about the two in Jones and Lemon?

Ed Bouchette: You mean Howard Jones and Lemon. Haven't heard much what they're doing.

Ralph: Hi ed, great chat! I'm higher on Moats than most. His time in buffalo ended because he was miscast (a la Harrison with Cinci), and I think he could be as starter here, any thoughts?

Ed Bouchette: I heard him called a "journeyman" on the radio the other day. I liked what I saw from him last season and he's done more early in his career than James Harrison did.

Advertise with us

steelmann58: Ed What if any plan rule changes do you see being added.

Ed Bouchette: None, other than to fix the New England Patriots fake lineup thing

Guest: ED what do you think Edge Rusher and then Cb in the first two rounds?

Ed Bouchette: Or, vice versa

John: Do base defenses like the 3-4 still matter or is defense in the NFL just about sub-packages and mismatches?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I believe they've fully explained their position to Troy. They obviously do not want to say so publicly, most likely because of what he has meant to the organization on and off the field. They'd like to see him retire and are just allowing him to come to that conclusion.

Bill in Bedford: Do you know if the Steelers have made any special requests for scheduling next season? I see Baltimore has asked to schedule their west coast games back-to-back.

Ed Bouchette: I have not heard. They usually do not make such requests that I have ever known. It would be nice if they could play at Seattle one week and at San diego the next. I could use a week in San Diego.

NewEnglandSteelFan: Ed, I heard Colbert giving your campaign credit for the Harrison signing. Do have any other great advice they could follow?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, get that contract done with Ben Roethlisberger.

Troy: Would you rather play New England to start the season or play them later in the year, if your Mike Tomlin?

Ed Bouchette: If I am him, I would want to play them when I have Le'Veon Bell at my disposal. If I am me, I want to see them in the opener because the weather up there would be better than December -- I think the snow will have melted by then -- and I could then hang a few more days in my old hood over the weekend.

Scott from Erie: Was Colbert's admission that Worilds was not a priority to resign (even before his retirement) an indictment of his play last year, or did they just truly believe they couldn't afford him?

Ed Bouchette: I've always found Kevin Colbert to be a truthful man, but saying it after the fact has no impact. Had he said that in February, now that would have carried more weight.

Guest: Hi Ed quick question. Why would of it been a bad idea to let Ben play out his last year, and then put the tag on him the next two years while looking to draft his replacement in that time?

Ed Bouchette: No

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you next Tuesday.