Here's a little game we like to call "In or Out?" because we tried and we can't think of a better name for it. "Up or Down?" probably would work. "Ketchup or Mustard?" would probably not.

But we're wasting time, so c'mon, let's play "In or Out?"

It's simple. I describe a football coach in stark terms having to do essentially with wins and losses, and you tell me whether he's in -- i.e. recently employed -- or out -- recently unemployed.

"In or Out?"

Advertise with us

Coach 1 had a winning record this season, and not just any winning season, the first winning season for the franchise in 10 years.

"In!" say you, with logical confidence.

Wrong; he's out.

Coach 2 won his fourth consecutive divisional title this season, had a record of 46-18 over the course of such excellence, and took the franchise to its first Super Bowl in 15 years last January.

"In!" say you, with great and justifiable assurance.

Advertise with us

Wrong; he's out.

Coach 3 took his team to the conference title game three times in the past three years, took it to its first Super Bowl in 18 years, and posted a 44-19-1 record for a franchise that had won seven games or fewer in seven of the eight seasons before he arrived.

"In!" say you, because it's simple and because you're fairly guileless.

Wrong; he's out.

Yes, it's a frustrating game about a frustrating league, this NFL, so if you think there's potentially more than is publicly evident about the "resignation" of Dick LeBeau and the subsequent elevation of Steelers linebackers coach Keith Butler to the club's defensive coordinator position, know that this was a simple swap of coordinators in a franchise that is legend for its stability. Imagine trying to figure out what's going on at the head coaching level in a sampling of organizations that have slightly less patience than the Rooneys.

Advertise with us

Coaches 1 through 3 in the above examples were Buffalo's Doug Marrone, Denver's John Fox, and San Francisco's Jim Harbaugh, all on the outs. True, Marrone left by exercising his own option, via which he beat the Bills out of $4 million and sprung himself to seek a better climate in every sense of the term.

Fox is gone from the Broncos essentially for not winning just a couple of games that John Elway really wanted him to win, last year's Super Bowl and this year's Super Bowl.

Harbaugh had the temerity to go 8-8 this year after starting 36-11-1, bringing empty seats to a new stadium and allowing 49ers CEO Jed York to conclude that it was "in our mutual best interests to go in different directions."

I doubt it, but there it is.

But, hey, back to the action.

Advertise with us

"In or Out?"

Coach 4 hasn't had a winning season in four years, couldn't settle on a quarterback to deliver on his chronic Super Bowl predictions, and traffics primarily in self-serving bombast.

"Out!" you say, because that would make sense.

Wrong; he's in.

Coach 5 strung together three 8-8 seasons for a hyper-profile owner in a market with a tortured playoff history going back 20 years, got his club into the postseason in progress but was eliminated on the second weekend.

Advertise with us

"Out!" you say, because you want to get at least one of these right.

Wrong; he's in.

Coach 6 did not have a winning season in his last four years as a head coach, had only three winning seasons in an 8-year run, and reportedly had ties to the Jacksonville Jaguars.

"Out!" you say, and, congratulations, you're 0 for 6.

Wrong; he's in.

Advertise with us

Coach 4 is Rex Ryan, who is not only in with the Bills but received anxious interviews by the Atlanta Falcons and the 49ers on his way to Western New York. He started right in with the trademark clairvoyance at his Buffalo news conference.

"I know we'll lead the league in defense," Ryan said Wednesday.

This from the guy who claimed his Jets were running non-stop service to the Super Bowl during his first two training camps, only to experience interminable layovers in Indianapolis and Pittsburgh.

It says here that Ryan never will get closer to a Super Bowl than at the moment Steelers rookie Antonio Brown got free in the Jets secondary for a dagger of a first down that sent Mike Tomlin's team to its second Super Bowl in three years on Jan. 23, 2011.

Coach 5 is Dallas's Jason Garrett, who not only survived three consecutive .500 seasons to go .500 in his first postseason (1-1), but got a new $30 million contract as a result.

Advertise with us

Coach 6 is Jack Del Rio, the new head coach of the Oakland Raiders, and the ninth person to have that phrase follow his name since 2002.

Thanks for playing our game today.

What?

Lovely parting gifts?

Who do you think we are, the Buffalo Bills?

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.