Comment From Scott from Erie

Gerry, any insight into what changes you think the defense will undergo under Keith Butler? Will Tomlin have more input than before?

Gerry Dulac: Scott, yes, Tomlin will have more input than before. I think, out of respect to Dick LeBeau, he didn't want to meddle with what LeBeau wanted to do. I will note that Tomlin is not a meddling type of coach, either. He is a delegator who lets his coaches coach. But there are some things he has been wanting to implement, and I think those things will be seen when they play sub package football. I can't go into specifics because, right now, I don't have any, but I believe it will have to do with applying more pressure on the pocket, being more aggressive and how to use different personnel groups in their nickel and dime packages.

Comment From John B.

Advertise with us

If you were an owner starting over, is it better to hire a GM first or a Coach first?

Gerry Dulac: Good question. It depends if you're going to let your GM help pick the coach. Considering that the GM has to work with the coach, that would appear to be the prudent move. But if a coach such as John Fox is sitting out there, and you haven't hired your GM yet, well, I'd go hire Fox and worry about the GM later.

Comment From Guest

Gerry, I know you are an NFL draft expert of sorts...so in the event (however unlikely) that Tampa Bay doesn't take a QB with the #1 overall pick, who would they take? Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: I will have a better feel for that during the NFL combine next month, but I don’t think there's any way Tampa Bay doesn't take either Marcus Mariota or Jameis Winston. And, as of right now, barring any further evaluation or bad workouts, I'll venture to say Tennessee will take the quarterback that Tampa Bay doesn't pick with the No. 2 pick, even though Ken Whisenhunt kinda likes Zach Mettenberger.

Advertise with us

Comment From John B.

Do you see Butler being more of an aggressive coach than DL?

Gerry Dulac: Let me say this, as a former LB who coached that position, Keith Butler understands more than anybody the value of getting pressure fronm your outside LBs in a 3-4. So, from that standpoint, I would imagine you will see him be more aggressive with pressure from the edge. And, by more aggressive, I mean have the OLBs rush more and drop into coverage less.

Comment From Guest

As a regular fan, what kind of changes might catch my eye when I see a Keith Butler defense take the field?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Basically speaking, I don't know that you will see any in the basic framework, especially their base 3-4 defense. I think it's what they do within that framework, and how they employ their personnel in their sub-package defenses, that will be different and perhaps noticeable. But I also think you will get an idea from the draft, and perhaps even free agency, if the Steelers plan to switch from a 3-4 to a 4-3 as their base package. I don't think that will happen, tho.

Comment From Guest

Is Bell still planning on playing in the Pro Bowl? I really hope not. Dude just needs to rest and be ready for Week 3 of next year. I say week 3 because he's likely facing a two game suspension for his arrest on possession of drugs. Thanks.

Gerry Dulac: Good point and you are right -- that is when his season will begin, in all likelihood, because of the marijuana charge. If Bell is healthy enough to play, he will play in the Pro Bowl. But, if there is even the slightest question, I'm with you - don't play. as of right now, he is planning to play. But that could change.

Comment From Guest

Advertise with us

So, you reported that LeBeau is headed to AZ to become the new DC...when will it be announced?

Gerry Dulac: No, I did not report that -- I reported that he has talked with the Cardinals. And, if you ask me, I don't know if he will go there. I think he prefers to stay on or near the east coast.

Comment From joe

Gerry, I love the Post Gazette but now begins a period of reduced content about the Steelers. I would love to see you, Ed, and Ray F. do a lengthy series where you break down many draft prospects, do multiple round mock drafts, and really dig deep into the draft this year. Can you do that? Thanks in advance.

Gerry Dulac: Well, Joe, beginning this Sunday, we will run a weekly series looking at every position on the team, where the strengths and weakness are, how they can improve and what they might target in the draft. I hope that helps to satisfy your appetite.

Advertise with us

Comment From John B.

Obviously we need to look into getting a TE. Do you think we should pursue a more traditional blocking TE like Heath or go with the new breed and get a pass catcher with speed?

Gerry Dulac: Good question, and I agree. I think they will look at a tight end who can do both, cause they don't just want one or the other. But they will lean more heavily toward the tight end who can catch first, block second. You can always teach them how to block; you can't teach them how to catch and run.

Comment From Guest

Gerry, on the radio you said that you'd bet your reputation that Oregon would beat Ohio State on Monday. You said you'd shave your head if Oregon lost. When will you fulfill your bet? I'm assuming it is for charity somehow. Which charity?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: And I'm assuming you're listening to the wrong station and have the wrong person because I never said such a thing.

Comment From Guest

Do you find it odd the way these coaches on our staff don't officially retire or leave the formal way?

Gerry Dulac: Not at all. Why, do you find it odd that they refuse to offer them another contract and show them the door?

Comment From keith

Advertise with us

Gerry, I base all of my game wagers on your picks. So, who do you have in the two games this weekend?

Gerry Dulac: Keith, you might have to wait at least another day until the picks are posted online at post-gazette.com. But I'll give you a little clue -- the 2012 draft.

Comment From Scott from Erie

Thoughts on the Dez Bryant catch? I think the Cowboys were cheated.

Gerry Dulac: Here's what I don't like about that rule: The league says you have to maintain possession throughout a catch, which means you can catch the ball in the end zone, roll over 10 times with possession of the ball, then lose the ball on the 11th roll and the play would be ruled an incompletion. But running backs or quarterbacks are allowed to dive over the line, have the ball hit an imaginary line that is considered the plane of the goalline for a mili-second, have the ball punched out and still be ruled a touchdown. Stupid, stupid, stupid.

Advertise with us

Comment From roger

Gerry, will the Post Gazette be sending any reporters to Indy for the Combine? I ask because me and some other Steelers fans in Indy are hoping you guys might do a meet up Q&A session here in town the way Peter King has done. Any info? Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: I will be in Indy for the combine, as I am every year. Right now, I am not planning any appearances. That would be left to the devices of local bar/restaurants who would want to stage such an appearance. Thanx

Comment From dude

Gerry, what are the rumblings going around in your NFL circles - Will Peyton Manning return to play next season?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Too early to tell, but I think he will. Unless the new coach doesn't want him, though I think he would be over-ruled by John Elway.

Comment From ???

Gerry, when you start your chat early it really hurts those of us who get here ON TIME because our questions get stuck WAY BACK at the bottom of the queue. Why don't you just show up and start your chats on time?! Also, you are late to the chats a lot.

Gerry Dulac: See, I got to your question, which really isn't a question at all. But here's a thought -- show up early, just like they do on Black Friday, to get the best opportunities.

And when I'm late I stay extra time to get to observations such as these.

Advertise with us

Comment From tim

Hey Gerry, I'm an ex-pat living in Japan, but I still bleed black and gold (NOT LITERALLY!). Anyway, I'm wondering if there will ever be a Japanese NFL player. There have been Japanese baseball players, but why no Japanese NFLers?

Gerry Dulac: Tim, I don't have an answer to that question, other than that perhaps they don't develop football players at a young age in Japan. But I don't know enough about it to accurately, or intelligently, respond.

Comment From Guest

Gerry! Why the heck are you starting your chat so early? C'mon, dude!

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: So you guys have extra time, dude. If you saw the inane questions I get, you would understand. I only publish the questions that show some semblance of thought, interest and intelligence. I do make exceptions from time to time, as you can see.

Comment From Scott in NEPA

Will there be any changes in the kicking game, the punting was shaky at times this year.

Gerry Dulac: I would imagine they will bring another punter to camp to challenge Brad Wing. At least I hope so.

Comment From Guest

Advertise with us

Apart from Ben (which is obvious), what are the priorities for the team in terms of extensions? Beachum/Heyward/Decastro/Others? Would be interested to get your ranked order of what you think the organization is prioritizing.

Gerry Dulac: Heyward is No. 1, after Ben and deciding what to do with Jason Worilds. Heyward is an unrestricted free agent after the season and locking him up will be at the very top of the list. That's another reason why Troy Polamalu, who is scheduled to make approx $6 million in 2015, will probably not be brought back.

Comment From Guest

I heard that even though he coaches OLine that Russ Grimm is angry he didn't get the Def Coordinator job. Why did he think he'd been offered it in the first place?!

Gerry Dulac: My suggestion is to stop listening to or reading people who have no idea what they're talking about.

Advertise with us

Comment From Tship

As much as the secondary is screaming for new bodies, is OLB the bigger need especially if Worilds leaves as expected?

Gerry Dulac: If Worilds leaves, absolutely it is!!! Even if he stays, I expect you will see an OLB anyway in the second or third round.

Comment From G-Dinero

Do you think the Steelers will resign LB- Worlids ?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think they have to re-sign him because if they don't all they have left is Jarvis Jones, who has three sacks in 21 games. He is unproven enough that he cannot be the sole person upon whom you rely. That being said, they can't and won't break the bank for Worilds. They have been painted in something of a financial corner. But the Steelers did him a tremendous favor by giving him a guaranteed $10 million down payment on a contract this year when they made him the transition player. And no other team would ever pay that.

Comment From Guest

What were your thoughts on Mike Mitchell's play the second half of the year...it seems it improved when he was paired with Will Allen and dropped when Troy was out there?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not going to disagree with you. I think it got better and he will be much better in 2015 for that reason.

Comment From Scott from Erie

As much as I hate to admit it, the Patriot's four-lineman "trick" is just another reason why Belichick is the best head coach in the league. Did you have any problem with this tactic?

Gerry Dulac: None. And you're 100 percent right!

Comment From Lewis from Fl

Do you think that Tomlin should have kept Blount on the roster (but perhaps suspended) until he found a back-up?

Gerry Dulac: No. He had no other choice. You tolerate that, other players start to lose respect.

Comment From AJ

Assuming we get rid of legends such as Troy and Keisel and we also re-sign Big Ben, do you think we will be active in free agency at all?

Gerry Dulac: I really don't think so. I think they can address CB in the draft, along with D-line. The only place might be at OLB if they are unable to re-sign Worilds. I don''t think they will be nearly as active as last year. I think they want to rebuild their depth w young players, and I agree.

Comment From Rob

I don't foresee the need for the Steelers to take a qb this year. However if the kid from Ohio State comes out and is there in the 3rd or 4th round would it be worth it for the Steelers to pick him up?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think he would last till the third or fourth round.

Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, that's all the time we have today. Tune in again next week, same time, same place. Come early, stay late.