Steve: How much more significant is Bell's potential 2 game suspension with the apparent lack of depth at RB? Do you think with quality RBs falling to later rounds lately that the Steelers will need to draft another RB in the 2nd or 3rd round next year?

Gerry Dulac: Bell's 2-game suspension won't be till next year, and it could be have a significant impact because he has a significant impact on the offense. But it won't be as significant as Roethlisberger's 4-game suspension at the start of the 2010 season, and the Steelers went 3-1 without him. Of course, the Steelers also had a much better defense and better backup QBs then to bail them out.

Guest: Most fans wanted Tyler Eifert, Cordarelle Patterson, or Kenny Vaccaro over Jarvis Jones. Patterson and Vaccaro have both been benched for the year and I didn't see much of Eifert this past game. Jones at least started to flash before he got hurt. Isn't the draft just a crap-shoot and shouldn't Colbert get some credit for passing on those TRUE busts?

Gerry Dulac: The reason you didn't see Eifert is because he has been on their short-term IR since the second week of the season. I was all for taking him on the first round to give Ben another weapon. He is the real deal. Patterson is a raw talent and I don't think he is a bust. Kevin Colbert really liked him in the draft, but they had a much higher grade on Jarvis Jones. And I thought Vaccaro was a second-round talent. I wouldn't call any of them busts, not yet. I will wait, just as I will wait before I anoint Jones the answer to their woes, even though he was starting to flash.

Advertise with us

Jack Splat: Gerry, love your work. I'm not sold on Shazier as a LB but given Steelers defensive personnel he may be a better, "new breed" NFL strong safety. Spence/Williams are fine at ILB. Thoughts on that for 2015?

Gerry Dulac: My colleague Ed has advanced that thinking, but Shazier serves a better purpose with his speed as a linebacker. However, i think he needs to add a little weight because he is easily moved, and I'm sure he will. But, to your point about 51 and 98, right now that is a better option than playing Shazier. He has missed too many games for a rookie to be effective at this point in the season, and the mix of Spence and Williams give them a nice combo at ILB.,

Norm: Is there any way the Steelers could get Champ Bailey to come out of retirement got to be better than anyone we got back there now

Gerry Dulac: No.

Carmen: Why not put Ike Taylor at safety? He has good size and packs a punch when he hits. He doesn't seem to have the speed for corner anymore.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Ike is not a safety. If that happens, they really are in trouble.

Scott: Gerry, I don't understand all the conversation about Bell's increased workload. The NFL is about winning now. Players focus on not looking past the current week's game, so why worry about his long term career with so much at stake in the present?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man Shirley. You are 100 percent correct Scott. Go to the head of the class.

Ed: Is Shazier in the dog house? Spence is not grading out well nor is he passing the eyeball test. Seems a shame that petulance is perhaps holding this defense back from a potential upgrade.

Gerry Dulac: No, Shazier is in the whirlpool, not the dog house. He has missed too much time because of injuries as a rookie to be effective the way they would need him to be this late in the season.

Advertise with us

TD: Ed's article this morning points out how the Steelers have possible the best offense ever in their history. Yet, people still want Haley fired? Tomlin brought his team back from and 0-4 start and has us in solid position this year with a rebuilding team. Yet, people want him fired. Colbert passed on fan picks of Cordarell Patterson, Kenny Vaccaro, and Tyler Eifert when all three have been benched for the season. Yet, they want him fired. Is it possible to please Steeler fans or are there really better options out there?

Gerry Dulac: The wails to fire Haley have subsided, and rightfully so. And you and the previous questioner are reading the same wrong material. Eifert is on short-term IR, so your observation is flawed.

TD: Aren't RB's going to be even cheaper in FA this offseason? All the guys who got top money last year (Chris Johnson, Toby Gerhart etc) showed they weren't worth it.

Gerry Dulac: Not only that, teams are seeing they can get good to quality running backs in the third through fifth rounds of the draft. But there is always a GM or two out there who will make a moronic decision.

Scott: How do you see the outside linebacker rotation shaping up as both Harrison and Jarvis return to the lineup? Seems foolish to reduce Moats' participation right now...

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think they will continue as they did in Cincy -- with Moats playing on first down and some second-down situations, and Jones playing on most passing situations. Moats had 31 snaps against the Bengals, Jones had 34. I think that even split will attempt to be matched.

kpeagler: I know the Steelers don't often delve into free agency and lately the results have been mixed. But do you see them making a real defensive splash since our offense is SB caliber and we need defensive help via the draft to aid the lack of defensive talent?

Gerry Dulac: No. This year is as big a splash as you are going to see when they signed Mitchell and even Cam Thomas to be a starter and Moats and McCain to be top backups. Now, with so much turnover coming this year -- Keisel, Harrison, Ike, Polamalu and prob even Jason Worilds will be gone -- the Steelers will have to find one starter for sure in free agency. But I don't think they are going to go out and spend any more money on a player than they did on Mike Mitchell.

Tship: Based on recent history the is a strong reason to believe the Steelers struggle and or lose to Atlanta. Is this just Steeler Nation paranoia taking over or our my fears well founded. Either way it looks like we need 40 points to have a shot at winning.

Gerry Dulac: You might call it paranoia, but that paranoia is rooted in recent history. Just look at what's happened this year against Tampa Bay, Jets and New Orleans, not to mention struggling with Jax and Tennessee. The fears are well-founded, even though Mike Tomlin always says he doesn't live in his fears.

Advertise with us

Guest: Gerry you are a great sports guy, but the PG's horoscopes have been lacking..both in the paper so why don't you take over those duties? Isn't that the same as asking Steelers to switch from LB to Safety?

Gerry Dulac: Thanx, but if you have paid attention to my weekly NFL picks, you will see that whatever I predict for the Steelers, the opposite happens. I'm 4-9 on the Steelers this year. Ugh.

Guest: If the Steelers did beat the Jets and Bucs they would be 10-3. Do you really see this team as having that record or are they about where they are expected to be a solid 8-5?

Gerry Dulac: A great coach once said you are what your record says you are. And their record does indeed do that.

TD: Steelers and Ravens are both in "transition" periods. Ravens have only beaten teams with losing records this year and get creamed when playing good teams, while the Steelers have beaten good teams and lost to really bad ones. Which franchise has a better outlook?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I've always tried to figure out which was worse -- beating the good teams and losing to the bad ones or beating the bad ones and losing to the good ones. In each of their past two Super Bowl seasons in 2008 and 2010, they were 12-4 and all eight losses were to the best teams in the league, They never lost to an inferior team or one with a bad record. So maybe that's the way to go.

GSK: Hi Gerry, at this point why not play Shamarko on passing downs instead of Troy?

Gerry Dulac: Won't get an argument out of me.

Guest: Harison and Gilbert available for Sunday?

Gerry Dulac: Iffy. I think 92 should be back. 77 must have had a setback because last week Tomlin said he had a "strong chance" to return and didn't. He sounded less certain this week.

Advertise with us

TD: Another 42 point game. Will fans ever like Haley or have we made up our minds that he needs to go? Did all the Ben won't get along with Haley talk/drama poison our minds?

Gerry Dulac: With all due respect, it doesn't matter what you and the fans think. And perhaps all that talk did poison your mind. But, based on what you've seen, does it really matter if Ben and Haley get along? Do you think because their offense is going so well that means they are getting along. If the offense is not going good, does that mean they are not getting along. I'm not saying they are or they aren't; I'm just saying it doesn't matter. One has nothing to do with the other.

Scott: Tomlin was pretty elusive yesterday when asked who was more to blame for the coverage breakdowns against the Bengals. Whats your take? Doesn't it fall on the safety to be in position when the corner gets beat deep?

Gerry Dulac: Sometimes, but not always. Tomlin is usally not going to single out a player for a mistake, so when he blames the execution or whatever it usually means a player blew an assignment.

JamesinNYC: I just read what Chris Rock said in the NY Post about Ben, good for a laugh in Baltimore but isn't it going over the line?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: You just made me go Google it because I didn't hear about it. Yes, it is, but that's what comedians do -- they push the boundaries and go over the line sometimes. This is no defense, but he was in Baltimore and it gave him an excuse for a cheap joke against a Steelers player. He wouldn't use that line, say, in New Orleans or Houston.

Gerry Dulac: That's all time we have today kids. Thanx for the questions and see you next week.