Maybe that horseshoe on the side of the helmet does more than just serve as the official logo of the Indianapolis Colts. Maybe it actually works.
How else to explain the good fortune of being able to follow Peyton Manning, arguably the greatest quarterback of all time, with Andrew Luck, who is on a similar track after just 21/2 seasons in the NFL?
How else to explain that twice in 14 years, faced with a decision over which quarterback they should choose with the No. 1 overall pick in the draft, the Colts selected the right one each time?
When Indianapolis chose Luck over Robert Griffin III with the top pick in 2012, it wasn't the first time the Colts had to think long and hard about which quarterback would better serve their franchise for the long haul.
In 1998, coming off a 3-13 season, the Colts had the choice of Manning, who passed for 11,201 yards and 89 touchdowns at Tennessee and set the Southeastern Conference record for career victories with 39, or Ryan Leaf, the Pac-10 offensive player of the year and a Heisman Trophy finalist at Washington State, with the top choice.
They chose Manning, who is still setting NFL passing records with the Denver Broncos after 14 glorious seasons with the Colts. Leaf, who was out of football by 2002, is considered one of the great draft busts of all time.
Striking it rich at quarterback with two No. 1 overall picks is rare enough. After all, the league has been littered with quarterbacks who never lived up to their status as a No. 1 overall pick -- Steve Bartkowski, Vinny Testaverde, Jeff George, Tim Couch, Michael Vick, David Carr and JaMarcus Russell.
But for that franchise to be able to replace a record-setting quarterback such as Manning with a quarterback who is already ahead of his predecessor's pace is not common in the NFL.
"It's unbelievable," said former New York Giants quarterback Phil Simms, who will be in the broadcast booth when the Steelers (4-3) face the Colts (5-2) for the first time since Luck became their quarterback at 4:25 p.m. today at Heinz Field. "I thought when I saw Brett Favre leave, man, I'll never see a guy throw a football like that the rest of my life. And the next guy comes in and might throw it better.
"It's the same thing in Indy. All the people who said Andrew Luck was a once-in-every-10-year quarterback, they were right. He is something special."
Best of both worlds
Luck has been an instant sensation since he left Stanford after his junior season and became the No. 1 pick in the 2012 draft.
The Colts went from 2-14 in 2011 to 11-5 in 2012 when Luck set a rookie record with 4,374 yards passing and broke Ben Roethlisberger's rookie record (five) with seven comeback victories in the fourth quarter or overtime. That also tied the league record by any quarterback in a single season since the 1970 merger. Since 1966, only Roethlisberger has won more games as a rookie (13) than Luck.
He followed his rookie year with another 11-win season in 2013, amassing a two-year total of 8,196 passing yards -- the most by any quarterback in his first two years in the league. He added to his reputation as a comeback quarterback by leading four more winning drives in the fourth quarter or overtime, giving him an NFL-record 11 in his first two seasons. That included the second-largest comeback in NFL playoff history against the Kansas City Chiefs.
Arizona Cardinals coach Bruce Arians, who has worked with Manning, Luck and Roethlisberger, said Luck is a combination of the other two Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks.
"I always called Peyton the piranha because you couldn't feed him enough information," said Arians, who was Manning's first quarterback coach with the Colts in 1998. "Ben was just the opposite. The more information you gave him, he said, 'Here's our book, play football.' He was the ultimate gunslinger and swashbuckler.
"Andrew has the information ability to decipher like Peyton and regurgitate it like that and go out and execute it. And he's got Ben's swashbuckler in him. Throw the ball away? No way. Go make a play and throw a touchdown."
Luck has made plenty of those this season for the Colts, who have won five in a row and lead the NFL in points scored (216). He is third in the league behind Manning and Philip Rivers with 19 touchdowns -- 15 in the red zone -- and leads the league in attempts (302), completions (199) and yards (2,331).
"They got a quarterback who can handle a lot of information," Simms said. "When you do that and put a lot of responsibility on his shoulders and you can handle it? Information for him is nothing."
In a city where Manning is a legend, Luck is already forging his own reputation as a winner, passing whiz and comeback master.
"He handles the whole Peyton thing because he doesn't think about it at all," said Steelers receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey, who played with Luck last season in Indianapolis. "He understands the history Peyton brought to that organization, but Peyton wasn't there when he was and a lot of people who played with Peyton weren't there. It was a new slate. He kind of takes it on. He's a tough kid, so he can handle it."
The fortunate ones
Since the dawn of the Super Bowl era, the team with the greatest fortune of having one Super Bowl-winning quarterback follow another is the San Francisco 49ers, who were able to replace Joe Montana with Steve Young.
Montana won four Super Bowls from 1981-90 and Young added another in his 49ers career from 1991-98. Each quarterback ended up being inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
The only other time a quarterback tandem ended up in the Hall of Fame was when Norm Van Brocklin (1949-57) followed Bob Waterfield (1945-52) with the Los Angeles Rams. The duo combined to win four NFL championships.
Bob Griese (1967-79) and Dan Marino (1983-99) are Hall of Fame quarterbacks who had close proximity to each other in their careers with the Miami Dolphins, but Marino did not immediately succeed Griese.
Super Bowl-winning tandems are rare, as well.
In addition to Montana and Young, only two other teams have had back-to-back quarterbacks who each won a Super Bowl -- the Oakland Raiders with Ken Stabler (1979) and his successor, Jim Plunkett (1980, 1983); and the Green Bay Packers with Favre (1996) and his replacement, Aaron Rodgers (2010). Plunkett is the only eligible quarterback to win two Super Bowls who is not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Stability, along with production, defines some of the other great tandems to play in succession. For example, Dan Fouts followed John Hadl with the San Diego Chargers and for 24 consecutive years they passed for 76,543 yards around the NFL and old American Football League.
Because of Favre's longevity, he (16) and Rodgers (seven) have combined for 23 years of outstanding quarterback play in Green Bay. Tom Brady has been a starter since replacing Drew Bledsoe in 2001 for the New England Patriots, but that twosome put together a streak of 22 consecutive years that featured three Super Bowl titles -- all by Brady.
Ken Anderson and Boomer Esiason each took the Cincinnati Bengals to a Super Bowl, where each lost to the 49ers, during a span of 21 consecutive years that began in 1972.
Some teams not only had a run of two quarterbacks who played back-to-back, they had a trio of consecutive quarterbacks who won championships for their team.
The best might have been the Raiders triumvirate that began with Daryle Lamonica, who won three AFL championships and was named the AFL's MVP three times before turning the reins over to Stabler in 1973.
Hall of Fame quarterback Sonny Jurgensen led the league in passing three times with the Washington Redskins -- he also won the 1960 NFL championship with the Philadelphia Eagles -- before being replaced by Billy Kilmer, a two-time All-Pro who lost to the 1972 unbeaten Dolphins in Super Bowl VII. Kilmer was followed by Joe Theismann, who took the Redskins to back-to-back Super Bowl appearances in 1982 and 1983, winning Super Bowl XVII.
Manning and Luck are headed for a select group, if they aren't there already.
"Its very rare you find one franchise with two quarterbacks like that," said Steelers defensive coordinator Dick LeBeau, who has been around the league as a player and coach for more than 55 years. "They're very fortunate."
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com; twitter: @gerrydulac.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.