The Steelers signed veteran tight end David Johnson Tuesday, and the first thing I thought of was Super Bowl XLV.

Sorry, Steelers fans.

If you don’t want to relive the agony of that 31-25 loss, stop reading now.

OK, I warned you.

Advertise with us

The Steelers, you’ll remember, fell behind the Packers, 21-3, before mounting a big comeback. They trailed, 21-17 entering the fourth quarter. On the first play of the fourth quarter, on second-and-2 from the Green Bay 33, former offensive coordinator Bruce Arians called a running play for Rashard Mendenhall, who then fumbled away a chance for the Steelers to take the lead.

But the fumble wasn’t all Mendenhall’s fault. Johnson, who lined up as a fullback on the play, whiffed on Packers outside linebacker Clay Matthews, who jarred the ball loose. It was a simple kick-out block that was complicated by the fact that center Doug Legursky didn’t get a clean block on a penetrating Packers defensive lineman.

Johnson got caught thinking which player to block – the penetrating lineman that came into his vision or Matthews, the player he was assigned to block. That split second of indecision allowed Matthews to get a clean shot on Mendenhall.

I remembered Johnson’s role in the fumble, but I had totally forgotten about Legursky’s. Legursky was playing for injured starter Maurkice Pouncey, and apparently Arians didn’t want to alter blocking assignments at that stage of the season.

Pouncey, a rookie at the time, was and remains one of the most athletic centers in the NFL and is adept at pulling.

Advertise with us

On that fateful play, right guard Ramon Foster was asked to block down on the nose guard and right tackle Flozell Adams was asked to avoid the lineman in front of him and block down on the inside linebacker. Legursky was asked to pull and pick up Adams’ man.

Legursky, in his second season at the time, made it to the NFL as an undrafted free agent out of Marshall. He was a tough player who battled his way to find a roster spot. Pulling, however, was not one of his strong suits.

Whether it was poor execution, poor play design or poor ball security, that play ruined the Steelers’ best chance to seize control of that game.

And there you have it, another breakdown of the second-most famous Super Bowl blunder in Steelers’ history – right behind Neil O’Donnell’s Super Bowl XXX interception to Larry Brown.

With the Steelers, homecomings are always possible. Legursky left the Steelers after four seasons to sign with the Bills. The Steelers signed him last season when Pouncey was injured.

Advertise with us

Now Johnson, who left the Steelers after the 2013 season, has a chance to come back and help them win that seventh Lombardi Trophy that eluded them that February night in Dallas.

Onto your Twitter mailbag questions:

From Dave

Question: With the rookie wage scale, why does it take so long to get guys signed? Are they negotiating special incentives, clauses, etc?

Answer: It’s been less than a month and three Steelers draft picks have signed. Some teams already have all of their draft picks signed. When you say, ‘why does it take so long?’ I guess it’s a matter of perspective. In 1987, Rod Woodson missed half of his rookie season holding out. All of the Steelers picks will be signed before June 1. That’s my prediction. The agents might be trying to get a few thousand extra in a signing bonus, but that’s about it. There’s really not that much to negotiate. In fact, a few players around the league are not hiring agents for their first contract because of the rookie wage scale.

Advertise with us

From Mike D

Question: Will the Steelers bring in another veteran CB?

Answer: The Steelers got rid of some veteran cornerbacks to make room for younger ones they’ve drafted the past two years. Antwon Blake and Brandon Boykin were not re-signed, and the Steelers are counting on Senquez Golson (second round 2015) and Artie Burns (first round 2016) to help remake their secondary. Unless there is an injury I don’t think they’ll bring anyone in to compete unless they believe they can do better than Ross Cockrell, who will battle with Burns for a starting job this spring and summer. Cockrell has been in the system for a season and did some good things in his first year with the team. I just don’t think they’d bring someone in to compete with him unless they definitely knew it was an upgrade. And at this stage of free agency the starting-caliber cornerbacks are all signed.

From James

Question: How long will it take for Hargrave to pass big Dan?

Advertise with us

Answer: That’s third-round pick Javon Hargrave and Big Dan McCullers, who will compete for the starting nose tackle job in training camp. We’ll have to wait and see how Hargrave performs in camp for that answer. McCullers can be a reliable run-stopper and might be hard to take off the field on running downs if he plays well. Hargrave, however, is a versatile player who can play three-technique and five-technique in addition to nose. So Hargrave very well could play more snaps than McCullers without necessarily unseating him as the starting nose tackle. The value in Hargrave is his ability to play up and down the line.

From Tom

Question: Is a Timmons extension inevitable, or can they fit new deals for 26/66/draft class/etc without any cap maneuvering?

Answer: Timmons, who turned 30 earlier this week, enters the final season of his contract with a $15 million cap hit. Obviously, if the Steelers can lower that hit by signing Timmons to a new deal they would like to do it. That would depend on a few things: A.) Do the Steelers believe Timmons can be a starting caliber linebacker during his age 32 season?; and B.) Is Timmons amenable to signing a deal when he is just months shy of testing his true worth on the open market?

Timmons clearly isn’t the player he was at 27 or 28, but the Steelers have played with aging linebackers in the middle in recent years. James Farrior remained effective for a time after he lost a step. So did Larry Foote.

Advertise with us

I think it all comes down to Timmons and whether he wants to remain with the Steelers or become a free agent.

As for how that decision affects the long-term extensions for DeCastro and Bell, it could. DeCastro’s extension could lower his cap hit in 2016. He is playing on a fifth-year option worth about $ 8 million. He’s likely to sign for about that amount, or slightly more, per year, but the cap hit could be lowered in the form of a signing bonus should the Steelers structure the contract that way.

Bell is a different story. The Steelers would have to free up money in their cap that they don’t have now because he is playing on such a cheap contract now. That money could be freed up after new deals for Timmons and DeCastro.

From Raindancer’s Blues

Question: Did Steelers put a claim in for Dri Archer, Boykin and/or Mettenberger?

Advertise with us

Answer: I don’t know for sure, but why would they? Kickoffs are being deemphasized and Archer was ineffective in that role when he was here. Boykin is not needed because Golson is going to be the slot CB and Mettenberger is not needed because Bruce Gradkowski was signed as the third QB last week.

From Jon

Question: How do you think the kicker situation will play out?

Answer: I think Chris Boswell will be the kicker and Shaun Suisham will be traded or cut.