Today, it’s the return of Ask Ed in which YOU ask me questions and I try to answer them. Send your questions to ebouchette@aol.com

--- YOU: I read in the PPG that, though the would have taken him if available, the Steelers only had William Jackson III ranked slightly higher than Artie Burns. Is this spin? If not, do you have any specifics on how they rated the two?

ED: I know it’s been reported elsewhere that the Steelers would have taken Burns even if the Bengals passed on Jackson in the slot right before them. However, both Gerry Dulac and I have reported from separate sources on the team that they liked Jackson a bit better and would have drafted Jackson had the Bengals not done so. However, we also both reported that they rated both of them close enough that they were satisfied to take Burns. No, I have no specifics.

--- YOU: The Steelers practically ran to the podium with the pick for Artie Burns after the Bengals took William Jackson III. Did I miss that we had 10 minutes and several teams desperate to trade up for QB Lynch? Surely an extra 3rd round pick to trade back with Denver was offered and something bigger from Dallas and other teams. I cannot believe that we would not have gotten him in the next 10 picks which is where Dallas was.

Advertise with us

ED: They wanted Artie Burns and after him, they did not have any other cornerback or safety rated that high. Maybe YOU believe they would have gotten him in the next 10 picks, but they were not willing to gamble on your beliefs, so they grabbed the guy they wanted rather than stockpile draft picks that would have given them players they rated much lower than Artie Burns and perhaps not even in the secondary.

--- YOU: With Burns/Golson hopefully on the field this year will we finally get an idea of how capable Coach Lake is with the secondary? I really loved how he played but we have not seen great things from his secondary yet, due in part to lack of talent maybe? Obviously Coach Tomlin cut his teeth as a DB coach so he should know whether he is competent.

ED: In my humble opinion, Carnell Lake has done a job over and above the kind of talent he has had to work with in the secondary. It’s amazing how “good” coaches become when they have good talent. Bob Smizik and I had a running joke when we covered Pitt in the late 1970s about how great their defensive ends coach was – he coached Hugh Green and Ricky Jackson. John Fox was a wonderful secondary coach and later defensive coordinator and head coach, and his reputation got off to a pretty good start when his first job was coaching a Steelers secondary that included Lake and Rod Woodson. Yes, you are probably correct that Mike Tomlin should know that Lake is competent, at the very least.

--- YOU: I feel we may have finally upgraded the punting situation. Duke's Will Monday was held back by the coaching staff due to a poor return defense, see the Miami game ending tackling as a good example. Have you seen him kick?

ED: No, I have not, but he will get every bit of a chance, the kind that Jordan Berry got as a street free agent last year. He used that opportunity to win a roster spot from the incumbent punter, Brad Wing, who wound up being traded to the Giants for a seventh-round draft pick. And if the Steelers could only re-sign free agent safety Ryan Mundy, they could have a Mamas & Papas anthem on their roster.

Advertise with us

--- YOU: I jus wanted to say i think its very disrespectful for the bengals to take the rivalry this far as to draft william jackson in the first round just so the steelers couldnt. With two of there recevers gone they needed to get someone to pair with aj green and there was plenty of tallent out there that they could have gotten like the kind out of oklahoma sterling shepperd. I get its a rivalry but I feel that the rivalry should be settled on the field not off. Im not 100% sure but I really feel they did this deliberately just so we couldnt get jackson who would fit in our scheme very well. I have no problem with artie burn its just he played alot of man to man coverage at miami and we need help now.

ED: When the Bengals drafted Jackson, I immediately wrote a Tweet that they had just stuck it to the Steelers. I did not mean they drafted to spite the Steelers, just that they had gotten the cornerback the Steelers would have taken first. I do not believe the Bengals would use their first-round draft choice to block the Steelers from getting someone, instead of drafting the player they wanted.

--- YOU: I can't help but notice that when the Steelers cut a player, very few other teams are that interested in that player to sign them and that those that are signed rarely perform well for the new team, are the Steelers that inept with their drafting that it takes a super human effort by their coaches to get these guys to perform ,or are these guys who are cut, just beaten up and have nothing left?

ED: You may not see the forest through the trees, to use an old cliché. Similar things happen to most other NFL teams. When there are 90-man rosters in the offseason and a team cuts someone, it says they do not think he is good enough to be on their 90-man roster. Plus, some of their other players did sign elsewhere, either as unrestricted free agents such as Kelvin Beachum, Steve McLendon, Brandon Boykin and Antwon Blake.

They cut Dri Archer last year and so far he has been signed and released by the New York Jets and then signed by the Buffalo Bills, where he is on their roster. Remember when they cut guard Kraig Urbik, their 2009 third-round pick in 2010 and the Buffalo Bills claimed him off waivers? Urbik became their starting right guard and is now with the Miami Dolphins.

So, it does happen.