The Steelers finally got that tall and fast corner that had eluded them in the first round of the NFL draft in previous years, but the selection of Artie Burns is not without controversy.

Many of the draft experts have concerns about Burns and whether he was worthy of being the No. 25 overall pick.

Pro Football Focus, for instance, gave the Steelers a D for the pick. It was one of only three Ds they handed out in the first round.

“In a mismatch of skillsets and scheme, the Steelers take Burns with the hope that they can develop his 6-foot plus frame into a dependable player,” wrote Steve Palozzolo of Pro Football Focus.

Advertise with us

“The problem here, much like the [Eli] Apple pick to the Giants, is that the Steelers played more zone coverage than any team in the league last year and that’s where Burns has his struggles. His +2.8 coverage grade ranked 42nd in the draft class, and though he does show skills as a man coverage cornerback, but his overall game remains raw. If Pittsburgh plans on altering their scheme to play more man coverage, this pick makes more sense, but at this point, it’s an example of a cornerback’s size and speed moving him up a draft board at the expense of his on-field play.”

Tomlin, Colbert discuss first round pick Artie Burns

The Steelers were targeting Houston cornerback William Jackson III, but he was chosen by the Bengals one pick before the Steelers. Pro Football Focus gave the Bengals an A for picking Jackson.

Palozzolo wasn’t alone in his criticism of the Steelers picking Burns. Mike Mayock of the NFL Network said Burns is a “boom or bust” prospect.

“Burns is a tall cornerback and he has world-class speed,” Mayock wrote on NFL.com. “He's very raw. I know teams with a third-round grade on Burns and others that believe he could end up the best corner in this draft.”

It appears the Steelers were one of those teams. The Steelers almost always take the best player available on their board. General manager Kevin Colbert said it was an “easy” pick to make. He said they felt “fortunate” that Burns was still available.

Advertise with us

But it is worth noting that Burns was the seventh-rated corner according to nfldraftscout.com. They had Mackensie Alexander, Kendall Fuller and Sean Davis rated above him. All three are available tonight when they second round gets underway.

Daniel Jeremiah, a former scout with the Ravens and Eagles and now an analyst for the NFL Network , had him rated as his No. 49 overall prospect.

“Burns was a two-year starter for the Hurricanes,” Jeremiah wrote on NFL.com. “He is a tall, leggy cornerback with good play speed and ball skills. In press coverage, he carries his hands low and fails to re-route opponents. He does a good job of staying on top of receivers and he does flash a burst when has to work back downhill. From off coverage, he is efficient in his plant/drive but he doesn't fully trust his eyes to anticipate throws. He has very good ball skills down the field. He is very disappointing against the run. He gets rag-dolled by much smaller wide receivers. Overall, Burns has a lot of tools but his competitiveness is worrisome.”

Lance Zierlein, also of the NFL Network, had Burns as his No. 82 prospect.

But there is at least one draft analyst that has a high opinion of Burns. Charley Casserly, the former general manager of the Redskins and Texans, predicted the Steelers would take Burns in his mock draft, and he had Burns going before Jackson and Alexander.

Advertise with us

“Some will say this is a reach but he is my next-best cornerback,” Casserly wrote on his mock draft.

Only time will tell who is right. What is certain is the Steelers have that long and fast corner they have coveted. Now it’s up to the coaching staff to get the most out of him.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com or on Twitter: @rayfitt1.