As Kelvin Beachum continues to make the rounds around the NFL with a free agent visit to Jacksonville Monday, the Steelers are exploring their options at left tackle and don’t appear content with Alejandro Villanueva, Beachum’s backup who played the final 10 games last season after Beachum was injured.
Veteran Russell Okung, a first-round pick of the Seattle Seahawks in 2010, visited the team Sunday. They’re taking a look at other free agents, too.
It might signal that the team doesn’t believe it can go forward with Villanueva as their starter. Or at the very least, they’d like to bring in some competition to challenge him should Beachum sign elsewhere.
Last night, I decided to watch Villanueva against the Broncos in the playoff game to see if I could see why. It was the first time I had watched the game since viewing it live in Denver.
The Broncos had an excellent defense and Villanueva struggled in pass protection, especially in the first half against Demarcus Ware. He was much better in the run game, but that didn’t mean much because the Steelers had a game plan to pass versus the Broncos.
I watched the game in its entirety. Below is a blow-by-blow of some of the struggles Villanueva encountered:
*On the first play of the second offensive series, Ware initially lined up over a receiver before walking back toward the line of scrimmage. As the ball was snapped, Ware rushed with a head of steam. It’s here that Villanueva’s inconsistent technique got him into trouble. He failed to get an initial punch on Ware, who drove him back and almost into Ben Roethlisberger.
Villanueva is big (6-9, 340) and should not bull-rushed like that. But he puts himself in those situations because he’s not a polished pass protector with his technique. It was almost like he was on ice skates, getting pushed a good three steps back into the pocket before he finally recovered. The play resulted in a 1-yard loss when Roethlisberger unloaded a quick pass in the flat to Fitzgerald Toussaint.
Two plays later, Villanueva initially helped Ramon Foster secure the 3-technique, but he was slow to recognize blitzing safety TJ Ward, who almost got to Roethlisberger before he got rid of a short pass to Sammie Coates that wound up being a 37-yard gain on third-and-8. For the second time in three plays, Villanueva didn’t properly execute his assignment. Roethlisberger wasn’t touched, and the Broncos probably weren’t even credited with a pressure. But Villanueva didn’t properly carry out his assignment.
Later in the drive, on the ill-fated fourth-and-1 when Roethlisberger threw incomplete to Markus Wheaton in the end zone, Villanueva had a relatively easy assignment. He was responsible for the 3-technique to his inside, but he overset and the 3-technique applied pressure to Roethlisberger. It wasn’t the main source of pressure on the failed play. That came as a result of a whiff from Toussaint on a blitzing edge rusher, but it was nonetheless an imperfect pass set from Villanueva.
Villanueva was much more comfortable in the run game. He was effective getting up onto linebackers. This is where he looks most comfortable. Still, he easily could have been called for a hold on Toussaint’s 15-yard run that set up the Steelers’ first touchdown late in the first quarter.
Villanueva’s athleticism doesn’t appear to be his problem. He is nimble enough, but he has a hard time playing with leverage, which is understandable considering he is 6-9. On Toussaint’s 15-yard run to the Broncos 1, Villanueva had no problem getting to the linebacker, but the linebacker shed him easily, and Villanueva grabbed his jersey to hold him up.
Early in the second quarter on Darrius Heyward Bey’s 58-yard reception, Villanueva once again has trouble with Ware, who bull rushes him. This time, Villanueva does not recover and is pushed into Roethlisberger.
Luckily for the Steelers, Roethlisberger bounced off Villanueva and managed to throw off balance to a wide open Heyward-Bey. Villanueva once again doesn’t get a first punch on Ware and allows Ware to get his hands squarely in the center of his chest.
Ware was able to collapse the pocket through the first two quarters. It happened again on the next series when Roethlisberger had nowhere to go when defensive tackle Derek Wolfe sacked him. Wolfe recorded the sack because Foster failed to pick up a stunt, but Ware’s collapsing of the pocket made sure there was no escape route.
If Villanueva could break his habit of dropping his hands every time he moves his feet he’d have a better chance against really good pass rushers like the ones the Broncos have. Bus his failure to get his hands on them allowed the pocket to be pushed far too often.
To his credit, Villanueva did play better in the second half. I think he still has potential, but for a team that is in win-now mode he might not be an ideal left tackle, especially for the Steelers, who pass so often.
In another era, when the Steelers ran more often, Villanueva’s weaknesses wouldn’t be exposed so often. But in this offense the Steelers probably need a more reliable pass protector, which explains why they seem so intent on signing one.
*The free agent tackle market is interesting. The Jets appear to be using Beachum as leverage with veteran D’Brickashaw Ferguson. The Jaguars don’t appear to have an immediate need for a starter with Luke Joeckel in place.
The best option for the Steelers would be for Beachum to return on a one-year contract. He can prove himself and hit free agency again next year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.