In the days leading up to Super Bowl XLV in Dallas a little more than four years ago a writer covering the Packers wrote a story about how the Packers could be set up for a long run of success if they beat the Steelers. The story explained how the Packers had one of the youngest rosters in the NFL, a franchise quarterback and a manageable salary cap situation that would allow the team to keep its nucleus together.

I was reminded about this story this week after the Seattle Seahawks blew their opportunity to step into history by repeating as Super Bowl champions. The Seahawks were 1 yard and 20 seconds away from beating the Patriots and becoming the eighth team to win back-to-back Super Bowls.

The Seahawks could still go on to become a great team that wins multiple Super Bowl championships in a short time period, or they could end up being the Packers, who haven’t even made it back to a Super Bowl since beating the Steelers after the 2010 season.

The Packers had everything set up for them to repeat in 2011. They were 15-1 in the regular season and earned home-field advantage throughout the playoffs. But they frittered that away by losing to the Giants, 37-20, in a divisional round game. They lost to the 49ers the next two seasons in the divisional round and wild-card round before making it back to the NFC championship game this year, when they let a 14-point fourth-quarter lead slip away.

Advertise with us

The Packers are Exhibit A of how hard it is to build a dynasty in the NFL. That’s why it remains impressive what the Steelers did in the 1970s by winning four Super Bowls in six years, what the Cowboys and Patriots did by winning three in four years in the 1990s and 2000s.

The Seahawks had everything lined up for a dynastic run. They have the franchise quarterback, the top defense in the NFL and a manageable salary cap situation with the most important players tied up to long-term contracts.

The Seahawks are good enough to make it back to the playoffs again next season. Perhaps they will make it to a third consecutive Super Bowl. Perhaps they will even win it again.

But their chance to stand among the greatest teams in NFL history was derailed for the time being in Phoenix.

What is a dynasty?

Advertise with us

There has been a lot of talk about dynasties this week after the Patriots won their fourth Super Bowl in 14 years. Certainly, the Patriots deserve to be in the conversation for greatest NFL dynasty though the 10-year gap between Super Bowls is problematic. One can probably make a better argument that their three Super Bowls in a four-year period from 2001-04 was more impressive than adding a fourth trophy a decade later when the only remaining connection with the first three were Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. I always thought of dynasties as multiple championships in a short period of time, but I suppose it depends upon how one defines a dynasty.

The Patriots might have had a better argument had they beaten the Giants in 2007 or 2011. Five or six Super Bowls in 14 years is much different than four. The Redskins won three in a 10-year span from 1982-91 and no one ever puts them in the conversation as one of the best dynasties of all-time. I think that has something to do with Joe Gibbs and his ability to win with three different quarterbacks.

Anyway, NFL history is littered with heartbreaking postseason losses that changed the way we view teams.

Here is a look at how some other great NFL teams exited the playoffs and how history changed as a result:

1974 – The Dolphins were the two-time defending champions and had a 26-21 lead late in the fourth quarter in a divisional round game at Oakland. Then Ken Stabler threw a desperation pass to Clarence Davis, who hauled in what became known as the “Sea of Hands Catch.” The Raiders won, 28-26. Had they won the Dolphins, by virtue of a better record, would have played host to the Steelers in the AFC championship in Miami. The Steelers went to Oakland the next week, beat the Raiders and won their first Super Bowl over the Vikings two weeks after that.

Advertise with us

1976 – The Steelers were the two-time defending champions and had a dominating defense, but their playoff run was short-circuited when running backs Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier were injured against the Colts and could not play against the Raiders in the AFC championship game in Oakland. The Raiders won, 24-7.

1990 – The 49ers were the two-time defending champions and were an 8-point favorite at home to defeat the Giants in the NFC championship game. They led, 13-12, with 2:42 to play when running back Roger Craig fumbled at the Giants 40-yard line. Matt Bahr of the Giants kicked a 42-yard field goal as time expired to deny the 49ers a chance to win three consecutive Super Bowls.

1994 – The Cowboys were the two-time defending champions and had to play at San Francisco in the NFC championship game. The Cowboys outgained the 49ers, 451-294, but were doomed by three Troy Aikman interceptions and lost, 38-28. The Cowboys beat the Steelers in Super Bowl XXX the following year for their third title in four years.

2005 – The Patriots had won three Super Bowls in a four-year period and would have played host to the Steelers in the AFC championship game if they won at the Broncos in a divisional round game. But Tom Brady lost to Jake Plummer. I repeat. Tom Brady lost to Jake Plummer. The Patriots outgained the Broncos, 420-286, but Brady threw two interceptions. The Broncos won, 27-13. The Steelers went to Denver the next week and beat the Broncos in the AFC championship game en route to their fifth Super Bowl.