A year ago at this time the addition of two more teams to the NFL playoff field appeared to be gaining momentum. Commissioner Roger Goodell was enthusiastic about the idea and the general consensus was the league’s owners would vote to make it happen in 2015.
Goodell, however, backtracked a bit on his previous comments last week before the Super Bowl.
“There are positives to it, but there are concerns as well, among them being the risk of diluting our regular season and conflicting with college football in January,” Goodell said.
Count me among those who are completely baffled by the reference to college football, as if that has anything to do with the decisions NFL owners make about their product. It should be up to college football to make adjustments around the NFL schedule. Making concessions to the greedy people who run college football is ludicrous.
But even if there are legitimate concerns about diluting the NFL product there are arguments that can be made to refute them.
It has been true for years the teams that are playing well down the stretch can win a Super Bowl. The Steelers proved this in 2005 when they won their final four regular-season games and sneaked into the playoffs as the No. 6 seed with an 11-5 record. They became the first No. 6 seed to win three road playoff games en route to a championship.
Five years later, in 2010, the Green Bay Packers did the same thing. They won their final two games to finish 10-6 and earned the final playoff berth in the NFC. In the playoffs, they blew out the top seed in the NFC, the Atlanta Falcons, by three touchdowns and beat the Steelers in the Super Bowl.
It’s a bit of a stretch to say the playoff field would be diluted with the addition of one extra team from each conference.
Last season, for example, Houston would have been the seventh team from the AFC. The Texans won four of their final five games to finish 9-7. They would have faced the Denver Broncos in their first playoff game. The Broncos, by contrast, were fading at the end of the season and ended up losing by 11 points to the Colts on their home field in their first playoff game in the divisional round.
I understand owners wanting to reward teams for finishing first or second in the conference. Perhaps they should instruct Goodell to use that as a reason for nixing expanded playoffs in the future because diluting the product just doesn’t make sense. Plus, who wouldn’t have watched J.J. Watt chase Peyton Manning around for 60 minutes? Heck, The Texans just as easily could have pulled the upset.
In the NFC, a 10-6 Eagles team would have made the playoffs and played the Packers in their first playoff game. That could have been interesting because Aaron Rodgers was limping around with his calf injury in the divisional round against Dallas even with a week off.
Steelers president Art Rooney II said last month he would not mind the playoffs expanded to include more teams, but he is concerned how that would be scheduled and does not like the idea of reducing the number of teams that get a bye in the first week from two to one.
Rooney II said he doesn’t see the issue being resolved this season.
One can make an argument the Steelers should be one of the teams pushing the hardest for playoff expansion in 2015. They face one of the league’s most difficult schedules with games against the NFC West, AFC West and the Patriots and Colts because they finished in first place in the AFC North last season.
It’s also a solid plan to support playoff expansion for the long haul considering the level of competition they face in the AFC North on a yearly basis. Baltimore is one of the strongest teams in the league and has missed the playoffs only once in the past seven years. Cincinnati has missed just once in the past six seasons.
If, as Rooney states, seeding and bye weeks are the issue I’m not sure how it gets resolved. Teams eventually must come around on the idea of the No. 2 seed playing a wild-card game with the No. 1 seed as the only team to get a bye. The only other solution is to expand by four teams with no bye weeks. In that case, letting 16 teams into the playoffs really might be diluting the postseason product.
*Notice I didn’t mention Cleveland, which hasn’t made the playoffs since 2002. And after the events of this week I’m guessing the Browns won’t be a threat to break that streak in 2015. So far this week their franchise quarterback has entered rehab, their franchise receiver has been banned for one year for repeated violations of the league’s substance abuse policy and their general manager is facing a suspension and loss of draft picks for communicating with his coaches during games via text messages. The Browns team picture is next to dysfunctional in the Merriam-Webster dictionary.
*I’m writing about the tight ends next Sunday in our weekly position analysis series. Jason LaConfora of CBS reported Wednesday unrestricted free agent tight end Jordan Cameron doesn’t want to re-sign with the Browns. Cameron is a pass-catching tight end without much blocking pedigree, but he might be able to help bridge the gap between Heath Miller and the next tight end of the future unless, of course, the Steelers select one in the first few rounds of April’s draft.
Cameron made the Pro Bowl in 2013. He missed six games last season, mostly due to concussions. He’s had three known concussions. That is a definite concern for teams, but it also could make him a little bit more affordable for teams like the Steelers. The question is whether the Steelers would employ a tight end whose blocking skills are minimal in hopes that he could add a different element to the passing game? (Miller had only two touchdowns last season and that doesn’t figure to improve much next season when he turns 33)
My gut feeling says no, but it should be noted that this is not a great year for tight ends in the draft. There is one – Maxx Williams of Minnesota – who is projected as a late first- or early second-round pick. The next tight end is projected as a third-round pick.
Why? Because spread offenses proliferate college football and NFL-ready tight ends who can block and catch are difficult to find. Todd Haley said in December that pro coaches and scouts do a lot of guessing when it comes to trying to figure out which players from the colleges can play in the NFL. You’re either trying to figure out if a pass catcher in college can develop the blocking skills necessary to play in the NFL or whether a run blocking tight end can develop into a reliable receiver.
Miller has done both at a high level for a decade.
The only tight ends under contract for next season are Miller and 2014 seventh-round pick Rob Blanchflower, who spent his rookie season on the practice squad. Reserves Matt Spaeth and Michael Palmer are unrestricted free agents.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.