Ben Roethlisberger has always said his goal is to win more Super Bowls than anyone. The number to reach is five, and Roethlisberger is three rings away from reaching his goal. At 32, he had better start winning some playoff games again.
That hasn’t happened since January 2011 when the Steelers beat the Jets in the AFC championship game at Heinz Field. Since then, he lost to Aaron Rodgers and the Packers in Super Bowl XLV; to Tim Tebow and the Broncos in a wild-card game in January 2012; and to Joe Flacco and the Ravens last week in another AFC wild-card game.
It’s the first time his career Roethlisberger has lost three consecutive playoff games. He started his career with a 10-2 playoff record before the current three-game losing streak. But he’s not alone in going through a playoff slump. Plenty of his contemporaries and plenty of his boyhood idols who are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame have gone through similar stretches, including Tom Brady, Joe Montana and John Elway.
But it’s also worth noting none of them ever lost four in a row. This is why Roethlisberger’s legacy will be on the line the next time he sets foot on the field in a playoff game. I did a study of Hall of Fame worthy quarterbacks from Roethlisberger’s era as well as the quarterbacks from the Super Bowl era who are already in the Hall of Fame. Of the 22 quarterbacks (15 Hall of Famers and seven who are still playing) only one ever lost four consecutive playoff games.
That was Warren Moon, who was 3-7 in the postseason and lost the final four playoff games of his career.
Here is a look at how Roethlisberger compares to some of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time when it comes to playoff performance. Remember, for those who before 1966 and after, there was only one playoff game a year – the NFL championship or AFL championship game.
The records are for games in which the quarterbacks started, not played in.
The Hall of Fame quarterbacks (in alphabetical order)
TROY AIKMAN (11-4)
Aikman began his career with an 11-1 playoff record and won three Super Bowls, but he finished with three consecutive losses to Carolina, Arizona and Minnesota. None of those three teams advanced to a Super Bowl the season they beat Aikman.
TERRY BRADSHAW (14-5)
Bradshaw never lost three consecutive playoff games, but he lost two in a row twice. He lost to Miami in the 1972 AFC championship game and then Oakland in a divisional round game the next season in 1973. He broke that losing streak by beating Buffalo in a divisional round game in 1974, the first of three in a row that season en route to his first Super Bowl. A few years later, Bradshaw lost two in a row again. He lost the 1976 AFC championship game and the next season a divisional round game against Denver. Both of those games were on the road.
LEN DAWSON (5-3)
Dawson only competed in eight playoff games and never lost three in a row. He did lose two in a row – the 35-10 loss to the Packers in Super Bowl I and then a 41-6 loss to the Raiders the following season.
JOHN ELWAY (14-7)
Elway went out on top, winning his final seven playoff games, including two Super Bowls, but he had to go through heartbreak before reaching the summit. The previous three playoff games before his seven wins in a row were all losses. He lost to the Bills in the 1991 AFC title game, lost to the Raiders two years later in a wild-card game and then three years after that in 1996 lost to the Jaguars in a divisional round game.
DAN FOUTS (3-4)
Fouts never lost consecutive playoff games but he never won consecutive playoff games, either. He never played in a Super Bowl.
BOB GRIESE (6-5)
Griese started his playoff career 7-2, including consecutive Super Bowl wins. However, he lost his final three playoff games to the Raiders in 1974, Oilers in 1978 and the Steelers in 1979.
JIM KELLY (9-8)
Kelly never lost more than two consecutive playoff games. He was 0-4 in the Super Bowl.
DAN MARINO (8-10)
Marino lost five of his final seven playoff games in his career, including three in a row in 1994, 95 and 97 to the Chargers, Bills and Patriots. In his final playoff game he lost, 62-7, to the Jaguars, and tossed two INTs.
JOE MONTANA (16-7)
Montana lost three consecutive playoff games once in his career. In 1985, 86 and 87, he lost the first playoff game. He lost to the Giants, 17-3; the Giants, 49-3; and the Vikings, 36-24. The next season he got back on track and won three playoff games to get his third Super Bowl ring.
WARREN MOON (3-7)
Moon is the only Hall of Fame quarterback from the Super Bowl era to ever lose four consecutive playoff games. They came from 1991-94 and included the 41-38 loss to the Bills that remains the biggest collapse in NFL playoff history.
JOE NAMATH (2-1)
Namath only played in three career playoff games. He won his first two, including Super Bowl III over the Colts. He lost to the Chiefs, 13-6, the following season. His stat line: 14 for 40 with three INTs.
BART STARR (9-1)
Starr lost his first playoff game to the Eagles in the NFL championship game in 1960. He then won nine in a row to end his career, including the first two Super Bowls.
ROGER STAUBACH (11-6)
Staubach never lost three consecutive playoff games, but he lost his final two playoff games – to the Steelers in Super Bowl XIII and to the Rams the following season in the divisional round.
FRAN TARKENTON (6-5)
Tarkenton never lost three consecutive playoff games, but he lost three Super Bowls.
JOHNNY UNITAS (6-3)
Unitas never lost consecutive games in the playoffs that he started. He lost his final playoff game to the Dolphins in 1971, when he threw three interceptions.
STEVE YOUNG (8-6)
Young never lost consecutive playoff games. Like Unitas, he threw three interceptions in his final playoff game, against the Falcons in 1999.
The contemporaries
TOM BRADY (18-8)
Brady lost three consecutive playoff games, starting with the 17-14 Super Bowl loss to the Giants after the 2007 season. In 2009, he lost to the Ravens, 33-14, in a divisional round game and in 2010 he lost to the Jets, 28-21, in a divisional round game. Of note, after starting his career with 10 consecutive playoff victories, Brady is 4-6 in his last 10 playoff games.
PEYTON MANNING (11-12)
Manning lost three consecutive games twice in his career. He opened his career with three playoff losses in a row to the Titans, 19-16; Dolphins, 23-17; and Jets, 41-0. More recently, he lost three in a row spanning two teams and four seasons. He lost the Super Bowl to the Saints, 31-17, following the 2009 season and lost a wild-card game to the Jets the next year in 2010. After missing the 2011 season with a neck injury and then signing as a free agent in Denver, he lost his first playoff game with the Broncos, 38-35, to the Ravens. Oddly, two of those games were at home and the other was at a neutral site.
AARON RODGERS (5-4)
Rodgers is currently on a two-game playoff losing streak. Since beating the Steelers in the Super Bowl after the 2010 season he is 1-3 in playoff games.
ELI MANNING (8-3)
Eli Manning lost his first two playoff games by a combined score of 46-20, but he is 8-1 since with two Super Bowl victories.
PHILLIP RIVERS (4-5)
Rivers has never lost more than two playoff games in a row. He’s also never been to a Super Bowl.
DREW BREES (6-5)
Brees has never lost consecutive playoff games. He’s 1-0 in the Super Bowl, but he hasn’t been back to an NFC title game since winning it all in 2009.
JOE FLACCO (10-4)
Flacco will play in his 15th playoff game Sunday against the Patriots, the same number as Roethlisberger, who started his career four years earlier. If the Ravens lose he’ll have the same playoff record as Big Ben. Flacco has been to the playoff six times in his first seven seasons in the league. He has never lost consecutive playoff games and he’s 1-0 in the Super Bowl. He hasn’t been a great regular-season quarterback, but he’s been a winner in the playoffs.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.