In today’s Post-Gazette, I wrote about how the Steelers are attempting to flip their script this season and win a Super Bowl with a top-rated offense and a lower-rated defense. Everyone knows the NFL has changed in the past decade or so. It’s never been easier to move the ball on offense, especially through the air.
Teams are now getting to and winning Super Bowls with highly productive offenses and lower-ranked defenses. I included a chart to go with my story that illustrated the point. Here it is (the NFL total defense ranking in parentheses):
2013
Seattle (No. 1) Denver (No. 19)
2012
Baltimore (No. 17) San Francisco (No. 3)
2011
NYG (No. 27) New England (No. 31)
2010
Packers (No. 5) Steelers (No. 2)
2009
Saints (No. 25) Colts (No. 18)
2008
Steelers (No. 1) Cardinals (No. 19)
2007
Giants (No. 7) Patriots (No. 4)
2006
Indy (No. 21) Chicago (No. 5)
2005
Steelers (No. 4) Seattle (No. 16)
2004
Patriots (No. 9) Eagles (No. 10)
But I wanted to know when things changed and if my suspicions were true that defense really did rule the roost in the early years after the merger. The answer was an emphatic yes.
In 34 of the past 45 Super Bowls (we did not include the first three Super Bowls because they were pre-merger) the winner of the game had a top 10 defense. From 1970-86, 14 of the 17 Super Bowl winners had top 10 defense, including five that were No. 1 overall in the NFL.
Here is that list (Super Bowls IV through XXI) in descending order:
1986
Giants (2) Broncos (9)
1985
Bears (1) Patriots (7)
1984
49ers (10) Dolphins (19)
1983
Raiders (4) Redskins (12)
*1982
Redskins (12) Dolphins (7)
1981
49ers (10) Bengals (1)
1980
Raiders (11) Eagles (2)
1979
Steelers (2) Rams (7)
1978
Steelers (2) Cowboys (3)
1977
Cowboys (1) Broncos (9)
1976
Raiders (18) Vikings (6)
1975
Steelers (4) Cowboys (5)
1974
Steelers (1) Vikings (10)
1973
Dolphins (3) Vikings (12)
1972
Dolphins (1) Redskins (4)
1971
Colts (1) Cowboys (3)
1970
Chiefs (6) Vikings (1)
And here is the list from Super Bowls XXII through XXXVIII in descending order.
2003
New England (7) Carolina (8)
2002
Tampa (1) Oakland (11)
2001
New England (25) St. Louis (3)
2000
Baltimore (2) Giants (5)
1999
St. Louis (6) Tennessee (17)
1998
Denver (11) Atlanta (8)
1997
Denver (5) Packers (7)
1996
Packers (1) New England (21)
1995
Cowboys (9) Steelers (3)
1994
49ers (8) Chargers (14)
1993
Cowboys (10) Bills (27)
1992
Cowboys (1) Bills (12)
1991
Redskins (3) Bills (27)
1990
Giants (2) Bills (8)
1989
49ers (4) Broncos (3)
1988
49ers (3) Bengals (15)
1987
Redskins (18) Broncos (9)
*1982 was a strike-shortened season.
• A couple of other nuggets from my research:
• Ed told you last week how the Steelers had the No. 1 offense in the league in 1979, the only time that has happened. Well, did you know the Steelers had the worst defense in the league in 1988? That team that went 5-11 allowed 362.8 yards per game.
• This season the Steelers are giving up 354.5 yards per game.
• Everyone still talks about how great he 1976 defense was, and rightfully so. That defense gave up 237.4 yards per game. Isn’t it about time that people nationally recognize how great the 2008 defense was? It gave up 237.2 ypg.
• Think that’s impressive? The 1970 Vikings gave up 200 yards per game. But the Vikings just could not defend 65 toss power trap. They lost to the Chiefs, 23-7, in Super Bowl IV.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.