The LeGarrette Blount story last week reinforced the importance of drafting and developing talent. When you don’t do that well enough you must rely on free agents from other teams.
It’s one of the reasons the Steelers rarely dipped into free agency in a big way in the past. Why take a chance on someone you don’t know about when you can get players in your program and develop them in the manner you wish?
The Steelers had to stray from their path because the drafts of 2008 and ’09 failed to produce one player who is still with the team. That left many holes on the roster, and the Steelers were forced to fill those holes with free agents.
Nothing illustrates this point better than the fact the Steelers declined to offer second contracts to their first-round draft picks from both classes. Running back Rashard Mendenhall was not wanted back after five up-and-down seasons. That forced the Steelers to use a second-round pick on Le’Veon Bell last season, which has worked out great for the team. However, it also forced them to look in free agency for a viable backup. They chose Blount despite his past, and that came back to bite them. He was a locker room cancer and the players applauded Mike Tomlin’s decision to release him.
The Steelers did not want to re-sign 2009 first-round pick Ziggy Hood so they signed Cam Thomas in free agency. It was a stop-gap move until rookie second-round pick Stephon Tuitt is ready to play, but the Steelers were hoping Thomas could play better than he has.
First-round busts aren’t the only draft picks that led to this problem. The Steelers released 2011 third-round pick Curtis Brown after three seasons so they had to look to free agent cornerbacks to replace him. They found Brice McCain, who surprisingly has been the team’s best free agent signing.
The one good thing for the Steelers is they did not commit huge sums of money in guarantees to any of their free agents. Sure, Blount got more than $1 million dollars for playing in 11 games as a backup, but he’s a dead-money cap hit of less than $500,000 next season.
The most money they guaranteed was to safety Mike Mitchell, who signed a five-year, $25 million dollar contract with $5.25 million guaranteed up front. The other five free agent signings were low-risk.
Let’s take a look at each free agent who came to the Steelers and assess a grade for each. (I am not including James Harrison or Brett Keisel or any of the other free agents who had previously been with the Steelers)
Blount is gone, back to the Patriots, after the Steelers released him on Tuesday. After Mitchell, he was the free agent signing with the second-biggest contract. He rushed for 266 yards and two touchdowns in 11 games. The Steelers knew Blount’s background when the signed him. He had been a troublemaker going back to his college days. They took a gamble and got burned. In an era when teams are finding productive running backs late in the drafted or in undrafted free agents the Steelers, in hindsight, could have spent their money better in free agency.
Grade: F
As previously mentioned, Mitchell was the biggest free agent acquisition of the offseason. He has started all 11 games, but his play has been erratic. This one is trending in the wrong direction, but the Steelers likely will give him the opportunity to remain with the team, which would be prudent considering the age of Troy Polamalu and the injury history of Shamarko Thomas. The hope is Mitchell gets better as he feels more comfortable in the defense, but he’s not off to a good start.
Grade: D
Linebacker Arthur Moats was signed to be a backup but was thrust into starting duties when starting right outside linebacker Jarvis Jones was injured in the third game of the season. He has been solid, but his playing time has decreased in recent weeks with the emergence of James Harrison, who was signed to the roster after Jones was injured. Moats has two sacks and 14 quarterback hurries in 11 games, but he played a season-low 11 snaps against the Titans.
Grade: B-
Everyone laughed when the Steelers signed McCain. Pro Football Focus rated him as the worst cornerback in the NFL last season. What many did not know was McCain played through injuries last season.
Healthy with the Steelers, McCain took over as a starter when the coaches benched Cortez Allen. He has an interception return for a touchdown and a fumble recovery. He also has been solid in coverage.
Ideally, he’s a solid slot corner, and he should return to that role when Ike Taylor returns from injury. Pro Football Focus rates him as the 87th best cornerback out of 112 this season. Allen is No. 112. I’m giving McCain the highest grade of all the free agent signings because he stepped in at a time of need and has made some big plays for the team.
Grade: B
Thomas was signed to provide depth, but he has started and played a lot because Tuitt has not been ready to contribute much. Thomas has a hard time getting off blocks and doesn’t add much to the pass rush. In 11 games, he has zero sacks and six quarterback hurries. The coaches finally seem to have come to the understanding that Thomas shouldn’t play starter snaps. In the past two games he has played 24 snaps in each, down from the 36-snap average he had in the first nine contests. Pro Football Focus rates Thomas as the worst 3-4 defensive end in the league.
Grade: F
Lance Moore was signed to replace highly successful slot receiver Jerricho Cotchery. He had a slow start because of a groin injury and has yet to find his niche. He is averaging only 17 snaps a game in the nine games he has dressed. He has 11 receptions and two touchdowns. The emergence of rookie Martavis Bryant does not figure to give Moore much chance to increase his workload in the final five games.
Grade: C
Darrius Heyward-Bey has played 111 snaps on offense and has four receptions. Mike Tomlin raved about his special teams work in training camp, but he has made some glaring errors on those units as well. He still manages to be active every week so there has to be some redeeming quality about him. However, I am still in search of it.
Grade: D-
What grades would you give to the seven free agents? Post your comments below.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.